General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsShe Was Smacked at the Group Home. He Cowered in Fear. Bruises Everywhere.
The people who worked at the brick building that housed 24 developmentally disabled residents called it the Bronx Zoo.
One worker regularly hit a resident while he ate, making him cower in fear at mealtimes. Another worker would repeatedly smack, punch and push a female resident, sometimes when she tried to watch staff members cook. A female worker sat in the lap of a male resident who used a wheelchair, placing his hands on her breasts and moving provocatively while other employees laughed and cheered, according to records and depositions.
Darlene Ruffin, an employee turned whistle-blower, told state investigators that she saw bruising every day. I couldnt keep up, she said.
The abuse first came to light five years ago, leading to a public outcry and an investigation by the state, which runs the facility, called the Union Avenue I.R.A., in the Bronx. But in a new review of the case, The New York Times found that when officials tried to fire 13 employees for abuse or neglect at the home, they failed each time.
The workers were shielded by the state arbitration process, whose shortcomings a focus of earlier Times reporting often return abusive employees to the job.
The Bronx case is emblematic of a larger problem across New York. Hundreds of pages of disciplinary records from 2015 to 2017, obtained by The Times under the state open-records law, show that more than one-third of the employees statewide found to have committed abuse-related offenses at group homes and other facilities were put back on the job, often after arbitration with the workers union.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/she-was-smacked-at-the-group-home-he-cowered-in-fear-bruises-everywhere/ar-AACBxRe?li=BBnb7Kz
Mosby
(16,319 posts)They protect bad cops, correction officers, teachers and state health "care" workers.
Eta - apparently these assaults are not even being reported to the police, someone needs to put a stop to this.
I can't say here what I would do if it was my relative, but I damn sure would insist on a police report.
If coumo can't even get these crimes reported and prosecuted under criminal codes then we have a major problem and heads need to roll in the DA and police dept.
marylandblue
(12,344 posts)Union protections often let bad workers get away with their behavior.
A union leader once told me privately, "Representing employees under disciplinary action is like being a lawyer for the mob."
Downtown Hound
(12,618 posts)Of all the criticisms I've heard of unions, the only ones that hold any water for me are how they sometimes let bad employees get away with bad behavior. And the reality is, I've seen this happen on more than one occasion. I love unions and think we need more of them, but this is one criticism of them that I do partially agree with.
And it is only compounded because the right then takes this legitimate critique and uses it to bash all unions, ignoring the good that they do do in many other areas.
mopinko
(70,135 posts)she had a teacher that came here from eastern europe, escaping the war there in the clinton years. tho she polished up her english well enough, she had been traumatized, and was breaking down.
as she became increasingly worse, they tried to fire her.
my friend insisted she deserved due process, and it took over a year to get her out of the classroom.
a classroom that would have had a GOOD teacher in there in a week in that district.
she used to chide me about the lack of accountability in homeschooling, which i did. i used to say- my students are picking my nursing home, or wiping my ass themselves. where will your broken students be?
this is my biggest beef w teachers unions.
it's ridiculous and both sides arent equal.
kids get one chance.
Mosby
(16,319 posts)mopinko
(70,135 posts)not that some teachers arent fired for bullshit.
they are.
but shit.
CaliforniaPeggy
(149,641 posts)NewDayOranges
(692 posts)Health services industry!
There were also sick phuckers working in the same industry for decades in institutions before Reagan threw these at risk people in the streets...