General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums53 Years Ago Today; Star Trek (TOS) airs for the first time on US TV 🖖
"The Man Trap" is the first season premiere of the American science fiction television series, Star Trek. Written by George Clayton Johnson and directed by Marc Daniels, it first aired on September 8, 1966.
In the episode, the crew visit an outpost to conduct medical exams on the residents, only to be attacked by a shapeshifting alien creature seeking to extract salt from their bodies.
This was the first Star Trek episode to air on television, although the sixth to be filmed; chosen as the first of the series to be broadcast by the studio due to the horror-based plot. "The Man Trap" placed first in the timeslot with a Nielsen rating of 25.2 percent for the first half-hour and 24.2 for the remainder. It aired two days earlier on Canadian network CTV.
<snip>
Reception
Broadcast
A month prior to the premiere of Star Trek, Desilu held a screening for NBC executives to help decide which episode to broadcast first, and several stories were considered. Executives were concerned that "Mudd's Women", one potential choice, would have reviewers discussing "space hookers"; they felt another possibility, "Where No Man Has Gone Before", contained too much exposition, even though it was filmed as a second pilot. The final choice was between "The Man Trap" and "The Naked Time". Justman felt that "The Naked Time" would make it easier for viewers to understand the characters, but later agreed with NBC's decision to show "The Man Trap" first. In the book Inside Star Trek: The Real Story, he suggests that it was "scarier and more exploitable than the others".
"The Man Trap" was the sixth episode produced. Although Roddenberry initially disagreed with NBC's decision, he and production executive Herbert Franklin Solow came to believe it was the correct choice. Shatner also disagreed with the network, feeling that "The Man Trap" was the worst episode out of those available. The episode was the first episode of Star Trek broadcast in the United States, on NBC on September 8, 1966. "The Man Trap" formed part of NBC's "Sneak a Peek Week", in which the network showed the premiere episodes of several new shows in prime time slots, ahead of the rival channels ABC and CBS, who were still showing repeats from the previous season. Leading into Star Trek was the first episode of Tarzan showing Ron Ely, and leading out was Richard Mulligan's The Hero.
"The Man Trap" placed first in its timeslot, with Nielsen ratings of 25.2 during the first half-hour; some 46.7 percent of all televisions in use at the time were tuned in to the episode. In the same timeslot, The Tammy Grimes Show on ABC and My Three Sons on CBS received ratings of 14.1 and 9.4 respectively. During the second half of the episode, the rating for "The Man Trap" dropped to 24.2, with 42.2 percent of televisions tuned in. Bewitched on ABC increased that network's rating to 15.8, and CBS's Thursday night movie increased their rating to 10.7.
The following episodes saw a drop in ratings after "The Man Trap". "Charlie X" was broadcast the following week; the studio did not want that episode to run second, but "Where No Man Has Gone Before" was the only other completed story. It placed second in the timeslot during the first half hour, with a rating of 19.1 and an overall share of 35.9 percent of viewers. It was beaten by My Three Sons on CBS with a rating of 19.2. During the second half hour, Star Trek was pushed into third with a rating of 12.3 by the Thursday night movie on CBS and the season premiere of Bewitched, which was also the first episode of that series broadcast in color. The following week, with "Where No Man Has Gone Before", the series returned to the top place with a 19.9 rating during the first half hour, and second in the second half hour to Bewitched. The Trendex rating report for the first few weeks of Star Trek saw it ranked in 33rd spot for the period with an average rating of 18.7.
Overseas broadcasts and re-releases
The episode was not the first to be broadcast in the United Kingdom, which instead premiered Star Trek on BBC One with "Where No Man Has Gone Before" on July 12, 1969. The episodes continued to be broadcast in a different order than they had appeared in the United States. "The Man Trap" was shown nearly three months later on October 4 as the 13th episode. This was during the period when the channel was still broadcasting only in black and white; it was not until "Arena" on November 15 that the series was shown in color. During subsequent repeats of Star Trek, the channel reverted to NBC's schedule and showed "The Man Trap" as the first episode. Canadian network CTV aired episodes of the first season of Star Trek on Tuesday nights instead of Thursdays and so ran "The Man Trap" on September 6, 1966, two days before NBC. Airing American programs early was a common practice among Canadian broadcasters in order to avoid direct competition for viewers and advertisers with American border stations airing the same program at the same time. The practice became obsolete once simultaneous substitution of commercials was permitted.
A high-definition remastering of "The Man Trap", which introduced new special effects and starship exteriors as well as enhanced music and audio, was shown for the first time in the United States on September 29, 2007, in broadcast syndication. The episode was made available to over 200 local stations across the United States with the rights to broadcast Star Trek.
Critical reception
In an interview published in the 1988 book The Star Trek Interview Book, Johnson claimed that the response of critics to "The Man Trap", and the initial episodes of Star Trek in general, was "complete bewilderment". In previewing the broadcast of "The Man Trap", The Daily Reporter said that Star Trek had the "usual far-fetched suppositions" present in other science fiction works, but praise was given to the acting skills of Shatner and the plots of the initial episodes. The Edwardsville Intelligencer called the reveal of the creature in the episode "the kicker of a great sci-fi plot". Daily Variety columnist Jack Hellman gave the episode an unfavorable review over its "lack of meaningful cast leads", who "move around with directorial precision with only violence to provide the excitement." The weekly edition of the magazine offered a similar opinion, stating that the Enterprise "trudged along for a long hour with hardly any relief from violence, killing, ugly stuff and a distasteful monster".
Among more recent reviews, Zack Handlen of The A.V. Club gave the episode an "A-" rating, describing it as "done very well" with a plot that is dark and ambiguous. Torrie Atkinson and Eugene Myers reviewed the episode in 2009 for Tor.com, saying that it suitably introduced the characters, although certain elements of the show were not yet in place. These included the lack of the death of a redshirted character, as the crewmen who died in "The Man Trap" did not wear red shirts, along with the lack of red and yellow alerts, instead referred to as general quarters three and four in this episode. The duo added that the episode demonstrated that the series was "something special", and that it remained more culturally diverse than modern television. They gave it a rating of four out of six.
Ryan Britt, also writing for Tor.com, said that "The Man Trap" was not a good introduction to the series, but praised the screen time given to Rand, Uhura and Sulu. He added that the latter two were more interesting in this episode than they would be at any point until the start of the movie franchise. Britt said that "The Man Trap" was different than the rest of the series, and more akin to The Twilight Zone owing to the background of the writer. In Hollywood.com's ranking of all 79 episodes of The Original Series, Christian Blauvelt placed "The Man Trap" as 73rd, calling the creature "incredibly pointless". It was also listed as one of the show's "cheesiest classic creatures" by Wired magazine in 2007; however, Rolling Stone magazine listed it as the tenth best villain in the franchise.
In 2015, WhatCulture ranked this the 18th best episode of all time in the Star Trek science fiction universe.
The Guardian noted "The Man Trap" as an episode about a salt-eating shape-shifter, on the 50th anniversary of Star Trek's first public broadcast in 2016.
In 2018, PopMatters ranked this the 7th best episode of the original series.
</snip>
🖖 Live long and prosper!
Sherman A1
(38,958 posts)Balance of Terror.
cojoel
(957 posts)Or maybe, my son's friend and captain....
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)1. City on the Edge of Forever
2. The Doomsday Machine
3. Balance of Terror
4. The Ultimate Computer
5. The Devil in the Dark
The new remastered Doomsday Machine is every bit as exciting as any of the Star Trek movies that came out much later.
3catwoman3
(23,971 posts)...Amok Time and The Trouble With Tribbles.
A while back there was some thread here in which the Horta was mentioned. I dont recall the context. One of the responses was along the line of, If I know what a Horta is, does that mean Im a nerd/geek?
The time travel episodes are always on my favorites list:
City on the Edge of Forever
Assignment Earth
All our Yesterdays
Tomorrow is Yesterday
wcmagumba
(2,883 posts)Just a couple of days ago I had looked at my TOS calendar from my college days in 1976, Gene Roddenberry was doing a college ST Blooper tour to make some $$ after the show had been cancelled a few years before. Good presentation and video/film. He did autographs after the show and signed the center page of my calendar "To Craig, Long Live and Prosper" along with his signature. I suppose it would be worth something to a trekkie collector (especially since he signed it incorrectly) but I get a real kick out of having it, along with loving the shows...
Response to wcmagumba (Reply #2)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
Boomer
(4,168 posts)Sadly, I speak from experience, because I have a basement full of Trek souvenirs and you can't give it away anymore. Shrinking fan base as we all grow older.
But such great memories! Star Trek formed my values, my perspectives and it shaped the course of my entire life. I met my wife at a Star Trek convention, we're both lifelong fans of the show.
Response to Boomer (Reply #7)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)So did all my friends. Those were good times.
Response to Dave Starsky (Reply #22)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
3catwoman3
(23,971 posts)Back in the 70s, I went to 2 Star Trek conventions, one in Houston and one in New Orleans. Roddenberry was one of the speakers at one of them. He was very inspiring
Demovictory9
(32,447 posts)jpak
(41,757 posts)Back in the day, networks had "Preview Week"
It was phenomenal.
Couldn't wait to watch it.
KY_EnviroGuy
(14,489 posts)The mouth is identical......
----------------------------------
Photo before shape-shifting (Jeanne Bal as Nancy Crater).......
A very beautiful lady and talented actress (from Wiki)....
In 1961, Bal became a regular on the sitcom Bachelor Father, but left shortly afterwards. Her other television credits include four appearances on Perry Mason, including the role of Dr. Linda Carey in the 1962 episode, "The Case of the Angry Astronaut", and murder victim Vera Wynne in the 1965 episode, "The Case of the Telltale Tap". She also appeared in guest roles on Bonanza, Riverboat, Wagon Train, and I Spy. In the original Star Trek series episode "The Man Trap" (1966), she played a lethal shape-shifting alien which craves salt.
KY...........
luvs2sing
(2,220 posts)Mr. Spock was my childhood hero..obviously I was a child in desperate need of structure and stability. While all my girlfriends were watching The Monkees on another channel, my mother and I were on the sofa with a big bowl of popcorn watching Star Trek. I have several of those horrible albums Leonard Nimoy recorded in the 60s. Fan for life and beyond.
Live long and prosper, indeed!
Iliyah
(25,111 posts)I fell in love with Star Trek by watching my mom's videos. One of my favorite "Let that be your last battlefield".
A lot of the episodes dealt with social issues.
not_the_one
(2,227 posts)or the black/white, white/black episode, or the one about overpopulation...
I don't remember the episode names.
Star Trek was so much more than its immediate effect. Just look at what it has created in the long term.
Beartracks
(12,807 posts)mr_lebowski
(33,643 posts)Because the outfits and characters evolved really quickly and dramatically as shooting progressed. 'Where No Man Has Gone Before', being the first made (or close to it) used very different uniforms than the The Man Trap, and the behavior of Nemoy as Spock is WAY different.
I'd think viewers would've been bewildered by these sorts of changes that would've seemed very sudden and un-explained.
Anyways I remember watching the early syndication runs circa 1972-73 as a 2nd/3rd/4th grader. Man, some of them were pretty scary to a little kid, esp. 'What Are Little Girls Made Of' I believe the episode was called, the one with the Androids and Dr. Corby and Nurse Chapel ...
I've seen every episode of ToS many times by now, love that show. Season 3 though is generally far inferior in quality to the first 2, sadly. They were kinda running out of ideas it seemed, plus their budget was cut significantly that year.
BTW, the show started literally weeks before yours truly started ... life
pecosbob
(7,534 posts)even though I considered William Shatner one of the poorest actors I ever watched....what a ham!
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)so it wasn't new or special to me, also too TV show-ish. I regret now that I had no idea it'd become such an enduring part of our culture and watch it enough maybe even to get a little hooked. Of course I was a kid, so good luck for a long perspective.
Mersky
(4,980 posts)Can do what I did accidentally to key into Star Trek. Watch the third season of The Next Generation, then go back and watch from the first season. Watch thru TNG, then Voyager. After this, you'll enjoy the charm of the original series, and be versed for the later ones.
To super duper Trekkies, (of which I aspire to be, but have not yet acheived, as life gets in the way) this may be heresy, but I say, the more the merrier of those dreaming of that Star Trek lifestyle.
🖖🏼
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Hopefully, a mysterious force attacking the ship's life support systems will take me far, far away from the Republicans trying to do something too similar here.
Mersky
(4,980 posts)I borrowed the third season on VHS from a friend. His father was loaning the tapes to him, so I watched what was available as they came along. Worked.
Happy Trekking
lambchopp59
(2,809 posts)With young Clint Howard as Blalock.
I was 7 years old when first aired, both my older brothers and I were just blown away once the "evil" looking alien was revealed to be a ruse, and here was the super-intellectual being testing the explorer's true intentions.
We need Blalock or some other incredibly powerful yet benevolent being to visit us now, put the oligarchs out of power, put out the Amazon fires, blow idiotic religious idiocracy out of the picture and help us truly evolve.
MuseRider
(34,105 posts)with my best friend when I would spend the night in the tiny village her grandmother lived in. I now live there coincidentally. I did not get to really watch them until much later. My parents, for some reason, would not let us watch it. I was in Jr. High so I am guessing it was because there was some "tough guy" show on another channel. My mother could never get enough of watching men smash other people around. LOL Wasn't Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea with Richard Basehart on right before that? We did get to watch that.
UniteFightBack
(8,231 posts)crowd and make it a little less cerebral.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)Employing his unique fighting technique, including the "double handed chop to the neck" and the "double handed hammer to the abdomen then back of neck".
My understanding is that William Shatner studied kenpo karate under the great Ed Parker.
UniteFightBack
(8,231 posts)I loved that you could watch any episode at any time and follow along perfectly.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)There was a definite art and science to constructing a compelling, self-contained drama around cigarette commercials.
IMHO, it is a failing of television today that this is no longer done. I just don't have the time or level of interest to catch up on three seasons of a show to find out what in the hell I am supposed to be "enjoying" today.
Beartracks
(12,807 posts)If you produced standalone episodes, the could be shown in any order when they went to syndication (i.e. broadcast by network stations after the original shows had all aired). As long as you made enough episodes to make syndication worthwhile, that is, which Star Trek fortunately did -- because syndication is where it really became a phenomenon.
=======
Bayard
(22,055 posts)My two older sisters, and my big brother. All gathered around the kitchen table to watch on a little black and white TV. I always sat in my brothers lap.
Funny. We were allowed to watch Star Trek and Thriller (scared me to death), but not Lost in Space.
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)Your parents were trying to keep you from completely rotting your brain watching TV.
pecosbob
(7,534 posts)My mom banned me from watching that show.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Joe E Ross's catchphrase was perfect for the premise!
wcmagumba
(2,883 posts)I remember the theme song, now it is in my head....aghhh...
Dave Starsky
(5,914 posts)Now I've got it in my head again, too.
wcmagumba
(2,883 posts)HR Pufnstuf....oh noooooos! Who's your friend when things get rough.....
LeftInTX
(25,230 posts)jpak
(41,757 posts)It's about Time
It's about Space
It's about Time I slapped your Face
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)"We're doomed!"
Quixote1818
(28,928 posts)Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Trust me, I would've remembered since it aired around the time I hit puberty!
GREAT find!!
On edit: This skit came from 1991 - I was past puberty, but still would've remembered...
Collimator
(1,639 posts)Obviously, some of the stereotypical female behaviors are insulting, but the humor has to be broad to land properly. Burnett makes a fine Captain Kirk.
In the episode where Kirk switches minds with a woman, "his" behavior is more nuanced, but actually more insulting.
FYI, there was a show by Norman Lear back around that time that inverted the power dynamics of society by making women the "top" sex. It was interesting stuff, but I don't remember how well it was received.
BTW, I grew up on Star Trek and still appreciate its positive aspirations for our world.
Dennis Donovan
(18,770 posts)Loved it, but few did...
UniteFightBack
(8,231 posts)Snackshack
(2,541 posts)After that day TV was forever changed. I am greatful that I was able to grow up watching this show. It had a significant impact on molding who I am today.
Coventina
(27,100 posts)"No kill I"
AnnieBW
(10,424 posts)Trekkie from age 1 here! (Born in November, 1964). I'm told that it was the only grown-up TV show that I was allowed to stay up and watch.
elocs
(22,566 posts)I was 14 when it first debuted and I still watch parts of the episodes, but truth be told I just have a hard time with Shatner's acting.
One of my classmates from kindergarten on was a big Spock fan and even cut is hair like him. I hadn't seen him for at least 40 years and was thinking when I did I would give him the Vulcan salute and say, "live long and proper".
Then earlier this year I saw his obituary and I have a hard time watching Star Trek without remembering him.
wcmagumba
(2,883 posts)I don't remember the episode but watched my first color TV at friends of my parent's. It was Star Trek...I still vividly remember the ship orbiting some brightly colored planet...watching the original episodes takes me right back to that evening...
BumRushDaShow
(128,822 posts)Hands down!
BumRushDaShow
(128,822 posts)only in that episode!
dchill
(38,468 posts)er than I was on the 50th anniversary!
Stuart G
(38,414 posts)Star Trek Original series? Desilu Studios..ok In 1965 who ran Desilu? By then, the two had been divorced..
The ultimate decision I read to finance the first year was made by Lucille Ball. I read she made that decision, and also, I read that Lucille Ball was an outstanding business woman. Are you positive Stuart?.
.. No..I am not sure..., I read it a long time ago. I know Desilu was the studio..but I read that Lucille Ball made the final decision for the first year to get it started.
Anon-C
(3,430 posts)Uncle Joe
(58,348 posts)Live long and prosper Dennis Donovan