Preventing digital feudalism
Reforming the digital economy so that it serves collective ends is the defining economic challenge of our time.
https://www.socialeurope.eu/preventing-digital-feudalism
The use and abuse of data by Facebook and other tech companies are finally garnering the official attention they deserve. With personal data becoming the worlds most valuable commodity, will users be the platform economys masters or its slaves?
Prospects for democratising the platform economy remain dim. Algorithms are developing in ways that allow companies to profit from our past, present and future behaviouror what Shoshana Zuboff of Harvard Business School
describes as our behavioural surplus. In many cases, digital platforms already know our preferences better than we do and can nudge us to behave in ways that produce still more value. Do we really want to live in a society where our innermost desires and manifestations of personal agency are up for sale?
Capitalism has always excelled at creating new desires and cravings. But with big data and algorithms, tech companies have both accelerated and inverted this process. Rather than just creating new goods and services in anticipation of what people might want, they already know what we will want and are selling our future selves. Worse, the algorithmic processes being used often perpetuate gender and racial biases, and can be manipulated for profit or political gain. While we all benefit immensely from digital services such as Google search, we didnt sign up to have our
behaviour catalogued, shaped and sold.
Economic rents
To change this will require focusing directly on the prevailing business model, and specifically on the source of economic rents. Just as landowners in the 17th century extracted rents from land-price inflation, and just as robber barons profited from the scarcity of oil, todays platform firms are
extracting value through the monopolisation of search and e-commerce services.
To be sure, it is predictable that sectors with high network externalitieswhere the benefits to individual users increase as a function of the total number of userswill produce large companies. That is why telephone companies grew so massive in the past. The problem is not size but how network-based companies wield their market power.
snip