= new reply since forum marked as read
It's so hard but it's what we have to do sometimes, if they're unwell and can't enjoy life any more. You did the right thing.
about her.😢 I am so sorry for your loss.
I'll be thinking and living with her shadow for a long time! 
I am so sorry you lost your friend.
Feel what you need to in this time of loss and don't hold back, okay? Those feelings are part of the experience and they will abate as you go through the grieving.
Remember, too, that your loss is based on ten years of companionship and love. You will remember that and be thankful for the time and experiences most of all and it will be clear that even though everything ends, you were so fortunate to have her in your live and vica versa! The real loss would have been to not have that.
Be Well! I know that feeling.
I know how hard it is to say goodbye. I hope you stayed while they put her down, I think they need us there at the end.
Sometimes we have to let them go, because we love them.
I too have been where you are and it is painful beyond words. Sending you a heartfelt hug during this very difficult time.
I appreciate all your words!
I think I did the right thing...
Doesn't make me feel any better though.
Thanks....
It is the worst feeling in the world but you will get over it and remember the good times.
time together . 
You and she were lucky to have each other for these ten years -- so much love.
I'm so sorry.
Please know that she knew your love.
Tikki
Lost our fourth Shepherd in October. Riley was sweet, smart, and handsome. I'm so sorry for the loss of Echo. They are such special beings.
Our pets do become our best friends, and children and it is devastating when we have let them go.
I have a chihuahua as my trucking buddy and I know I'll be beside myself when it's time for him to leave this earth.
Big hug for you and I hope you can find peace soon.
they're family and it's so hard to lose them.
It's heartbreaking having to our furry family members put to sleep. It's also heartbreaking when they have personality changes from suffering unbearable pain. I've been there, it's awful!
You are not alone. We had to make that decision for one of our dogs last August. I still cry for her. At some point I hope the pain will ease for us.
It’s heartbreaking to lose our fur babies.
my first dog died at home right before her 15th birthday. I skipped Christmas that year (10 days later). Her ghost was here for about a week. I felt her move under my bed, against my bed, at the closet door, etc. I heard her chain at these places too. Since then I have learned that a few friends had the same experience.
My baby now is 16 1/2 and every single night I wonder if this will be my last day with her. I think she is hanging in there just for me since my dad died suddenly 8 months ago. Until then my dog's death is the worst thing I have ever experienced in my life, nothing comes close.
I dread the day when I wake up and she is no longer here. I am crying just thinking about you and feel empathy for your loss. Please take care of yourself!
Even my recent loss, it does not get any easier.
My dog was 16 and the last month has been so hard. I do have a dog now so it's helped but still, having a dog like that for so long and now not anymore has been extremely difficult.
which will numb me but not fill the empty space in my heart or home. My health sucks and I will not get another baby since it wouldn't be fair to leave her. Dogs are as emotionally attached to us as we are to them. I am grateful that I will last long enough to be able to take care of her like she has taken care of me all these years.
I am leaving most of my assets to the Humane Society and the Morris Animal Shelter in Phila. I was a foster parent to dogs while in college and lived across the street. It is the oldest animal shelter in the US (1874).
https://www.morrisanimalrefuge.org/
in our hearts.
My Echo was just an integral part of my life for the last 10 years.
I got her from a local shelter when she was "about" 2 years old.
They said she was a "breeder" from a puppy mill....
She didn't like men much, chased her own tail out of nervousness,
bit strangers because she was fearful....
It took me years to make her feel at home, loved, comfortable, safe....
After about 5 she was happy here and was happy to be with me. She always
followed me everywhere. I would say that if I stopped short.. I'd have a tail
coming out of my ass! LOL! 
That's the part that is already making me crazy! Every time I move I am always looking for her.
Because I always know, she's right behind me.... Not so much anymore.
My Ex-wife never liked her much, always said she had "no light in her eyes".. I was more upset
today about losing Echo after 10 years than my ex-wife after 10 years... Tells you something..
OK, enough stories for now....
I cried for a month and just thinking about it brings tears to my eyes.
I've also lost many unexpectedly, where there is no time to say goodbye. It never gets any easier.
Our little graveyard has greatly expanded here on our farm over the past 5 years.....dogs, cats, goats, horses, donkeys, and various species of fowl. Every time I walk past, I say--I see you. It means, your life mattered. You meant so much to me, and I still love you dearly. It makes me feel a little better.
So, say--I see you, Echo. Your life will always be intertwined with mine.
Losing a dog is just heartbreaking. My condolences.
She was 11 but quite lively and healthy. Went downhill fast - vet thought cancer.
She died at home on her favorite blanket near us.
It was hard. I still get melancholy about it, but I'm glad she didn't suffer long.
You were there for her and gave her a good life, after what sounds like a bad start. She must have loved you with all her doggy heart!