General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSupreme Court debate over Trump's financial records points to mixed outcome
The highly anticipated Supreme Court arguments over President Trumps efforts to block disclosure of his income tax returns and private financial records suggested Tuesday the possibility of a mixed outcome.
Moreover, several justices suggested there might be more work for lower courts to do, which could delay any turnover of the documents being sought by congressional Democrats and Manhattans district attorney until after Novembers election.
The courts conservative majority seemed far more critical of lawmakers demands, questioning whether approving the subpoenas issued by three congressional committees would open the door for a Congress ruled by one political party to make potentially harassing requests of a president from a different party.
What Congress proposes as a limiting principle that the request must be tied to potential legislation is really no protection at all, Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. said. Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. struck a similar chord.Your test is not really much of a test. Its not really a limit, Roberts told Douglas N. Letter, general counsel to the House of Representatives, who said the key was that the request was tied to potential legislation.
Letter had trouble coming up with an example of a legislative proposal beyond Congresss reach, which one of Trumps private lawyers pointed out.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/05/12/trump-taxes-scotus-hearing-live/
I'm not a lawyer so correct if I'm wrong. Letter has had months to work on this. Shouldn't he have been able to come up with something better? Too bad Carey Dunne isn't the House lawyer. He was awesome.
C_U_L8R
(45,021 posts)This whole argument seems arbitrary IMO.
Do police have quotas on how many powerful people they can arrest?
qazplm135
(7,447 posts)which will move it past the election, which will render it moot assuming Trump loses.
empedocles
(15,751 posts)some would think.
In Conference is where decisions will be made.
qazplm135
(7,447 posts)just strikes me as the most likely path that avoids hurting Trump but saves it for future Dem Presidents.
Straddles the line without directly helping Trump.
mitch96
(13,926 posts)I think if anything gets released the State of NY will use it to convict him of state crimes..
YMMV
m