It's all relative, I guess.
By the way, Valencia speaks a version of Catalan known as "Valencià." It's distinct from the version spoken in Barcelona, but completely mutually intelligible to other Catalan speakers. During the time I was there, there was a folk singer just known by his first name, Raimon (equivalent to the Castilian Ramón). Songs with political content in Catalan were mostly forbidden from public shows and festivals, but Franco's government had declared, quite on their own, that Valencia was outside of Catalunya, and therefore didn't speak Catalan. Raimon had a song, in Valencian (i.e. Catalan), called "Ahir," or "Yesterday," but popularly known by its refrain, "Diguem No," which means "Let's say no" in Catalan. It was clearly a protest song against the government, but since he was from Valencia, well it couldn't POSSIBLY be in Catalan, could it? Needless to say, the song festival officials got in big trouble afterwards for allowing it, and instead of remaining an obscure song by an obscure folk singer, it became a protest anthem of the Catalans. Raimon was still making a living singing it decades after his voice had faded and his relevance should have, just because he had been made so famous after this one incident.
Like with our Republicans, if a government is going to lie to its people, that's one thing. If a government is going to lie to its people and then start believing its own lies out of pure intellectual laziness or plain stupidity, they will trip over themselves again and again.
= new reply since forum marked as read
