General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWisconsin teachers resign after investigation into disturbing question about how to 'punish' slaves
In early February, news broke that a small group of teachers gave a truly shocking assignment to sixth-graders at Patrick Marsh Middle School in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. The activity? Some middle schoolers were asked how they would punish slaves, as reported by NBC News. Yes: Really. The framing apparently relied on ancient Mesopotamian laws. The question is, of course, inappropriate and horrifying for all of the obvious reasons. The district launched an investigation and determined the three social studies teachers involve made the lesson independently. In other words: They did not get approval from the school or district-level administrators for that particular assignment.
The three teachers, whose names have not been publicly released, were initially put on leave, and as of mid-April, have resigned, as reported by NBC 15. According to the local outlet, the educators will also not return next year. Local outlet WTMJ reports that the teachers will remain on paid leave for the rest of the school year, even with resigning. Adding to the upsetting and mind-boggling situation is Madison.coms finding that the wording of the question matches that of a lesson on the site Teachers Pay Teachers, an online resource where educators can buy and sell education materials.
So, how did different parties respond? It seems the school district did react quickly and seriously, with Superintendent Brad Saron and fellow school administrators initially emailing parents to apologize for the grave error in judgment that occurred in the classroom.
The news site reports that Teachers Pay Teachers removed the question from its site when they were made aware of its existence. Thats great, but also makes one wonder how many times this question has been used to teach studentsand how many others like it slip by. That said, the company released a statement saying in part: We unequivocally stand against anything that may cause trauma or further the marginalization of people of color. The statement also described the assignment as antithetical to the sites values.
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2021/4/15/2026060/-Wisconsin-teachers-resign-after-investigation-into-disturbing-question-about-how-to-punish-slaves
harumph
(1,900 posts)eye for an eye and all that jazz...
You know, it might just be that some questions though offensive can provoke discussion.
How about this one? "You are a wealthy New Yorker of Pakistani heritage and have a live in Pakistani housekeeper. Your wife
took the housekeeper's visa and she is being held under duress. She is paid a small allowance and meals. How do you correct her for substandard work." This actually happened in this century.
Discussion of horrible topics does not mean acceptance or normalization of same. I guess it depends on the lesson, the kiddos and the
teachers.
stillcool
(32,626 posts)Texas high schoolers disciplined for 'slave-trading game' that auctioned off classmates based on race
Schools officials in Aledo said they discovered that students had engaged in cyberbullying and racial harassment.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/texas-high-schoolers-disciplined-slave-trading-game-auctioned-classmates-based-n1264012
April 13, 2021, 10:02 PM EDT
By Sarah Kaufman
A Texas school district has disciplined students who it said engaged in an online "slave-trading game" and pretended to auction off classmates based on race.
A student from the Aledo Independent School District posted a screen capture of the game on Snapchat. It shows students using a chat labeled "Slave trade," along with a racial slur, to "trade" students of color.
A student posted "$1 for Chris" and "would be better if his hair wasn't so bad."
Aledo Independent School District parents say the Texas district has not done enough after an online game was discovered in which ninth-grade students were "slave-trading" students of color and labeling the group chat "Slave Trade," "N" Farm and "N" auction.KXAS
The school district, which is southwest of Fort Worth, condemned the game and the students' behavior.
The district said in a statement Monday that it discovered that students from the Daniel Ninth Grade Campus had been engaged in racial harassment and cyberbullying more than two weeks ago "and launched an immediate and thorough investigation that involved law enforcement."
-----------------------------------
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/texas-high-schoolers-disciplined-slave-trading-game-auctioned-classmates-based-n1264012