General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAre Democrats sleepwalking toward democratic collapse?
So whats your current level of concern?
David Faris
My current level of concern is exploring countries to move to after 2024. Im deeply concerned about the direction that the Republican Party has taken, especially over the last year or so. Things were bad in 2018, but the basic problem in 2018 was that we had structural factors working against the Democrats and you had a Republican Party that was fundamentally trying to keep people from voting.
The most destructive thing that Trump did on his way out the door was he took the Republicans waning commitment to democracy and he weaponized it, and he made it much worse to the point where I think that a good deal of rank-and-file Republican voters simply dont believe that Democrats can win a legitimate election. And if Democrats do win an election, it has to be fraudulent.
So 2020 felt like a test run. The plot to overturn the 2020 election never had a real chance of working without some external intervention like a military coup or something like that, which I never thought was particularly likely. But the institutional path that they pursued to steal the election failed because they didnt control Congress and they didnt control the right governorships in the right places.
So I worry complacency has set in on the Democratic side and people are lulled into thinking things are normal and fine just because Bidens approval ratings are good.
Sean Illing
2020 was a test run for what, exactly?
David Faris
It was a test run for a way to overturn an election with the veneer of legality. You have to give Trump and Republicans some kind of dark credit for figuring out that this is really conceivable. I think they now know that, even though it would cause a court battle and possibly a civil war, that if they cant win by suppressing the vote and the election is close enough, they can do this if they control enough state legislatures and the Congress.
If Democrats dont make some changes to our election laws and if they lose some races that they really need to win in 2022 and 2024, then were in real trouble.
https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/22432229/democracy-america-democratic-party-reform
brooklynite
(94,598 posts)StrictlyRockers
(3,855 posts)Back in 2018, I spoke with Roosevelt University political scientist David Faris about his book Its Time to Fight Dirty. His argument then was that Democrats had to play constitutional hardball and basically do whatever was necessary to win.
The situation today is even more dire than it was in 2018. Im not sure people appreciate how much danger we are in, Faris wrote in a recent Twitter thread. If Republicans succeed [in rigging the rules to take the presidency in 2024], they will crack this country in half.
WarGamer
(12,452 posts)USAFRetired_Liberal
(4,167 posts)I think Republicans are going to lie, cheat and steal there way to wins in 2022 and 2024....and if that doesnt work they will just throw out the votes they dont like....and when Democrats try to call them out for it, the MSM and Republicans will say both sides cry when they lose and now the Democrats are just doing the same thing that Trump and the Republicans did
TheRealNorth
(9,481 posts)Some people in Germany tried to run away from the Nazi's too.
If worse comes to worse, I plan to keep fighting, and eventually, you will have to fight them too- just like those who fled Germany that ran away to France, the Netherlands, or the United States.
doc03
(35,348 posts)2016 but to their surprise they won. In Trump's 2016 campaign he repeatedly said if I lose the election as rigged. I am afraid they may succeed in 2022 and 2024.
I think a lot of our leadership is asleep at the wheel.
ShazamIam
(2,575 posts)Please note, the media is not our friend and only makes a shallow pretense at informing, mostly they are engaged in controlling the narrative and dialogue and it is not strongly democratic.
example: They covered for the Republican voter suppression for years with the same old lies.
First the Republican states would purge voters then after the election the so called news providers would all carry on about how those Democratic just don't show up and vote. Never mentioning the purged voters, the closed polling stations, ballot disqualifications and all the other tricks of the game.
Florida in 2000 was their first huge success with the voter registration purging.
RobinA
(9,893 posts)is through the roof. I am 63 and have been following politics forever and I have never been this afraid. I always had confidence that our checks and balances would protect us and that most voters would be more or less sane. These people have no limits in what they will try. I don't think it's very realistic for most people to plan on moving to another country. There are rules upon rules involving settling down anywhere you would want to live. I have nothing that would make me able to live permanently in another country, we've been here since 1760 at the latest.
Cosmocat
(14,566 posts)I am pretty much resigned that this is not going to end well.
Rs are HELL bent on this path, and Ds just don't have the street fighter mentality needed to stop it.
SoCalDavidS
(9,998 posts)CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)Every day this type of thing is posted here by someone about our impending doom.
Stop.
StrictlyRockers
(3,855 posts)This is a real problem. Can you read One. Single. Article. about it?
PortTack
(32,778 posts)What if President Biden,Stacey Abrams or others took this terrible attitude? Seriously
These kinds of posts are exactly what the qgop want, and dont think for a moment they they dont read what we write here. They look at negative posts and think that worked, lets magnify it.
Yall act as if we have no power or options..again you play right into their hands!!
CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)This type of stuff used to not be allowed here.
The goal of these types of articles is to drive down enthusiasm and create dissent. Whether the author realizes it or not. That is what these types of pieces intend.
PortTack
(32,778 posts)The last thing we need
Fiendish Thingy
(15,624 posts)To make the dire stakes at hand undeniable.
Kind of like Greta Thunberg and climate change, except with American democracy.
If youd rather close your eyes, stick your fingers in your ears and go LaLaLaLa no doom and gloom! Work really hard and GOTV and everything will be fine! Thats your prerogative.
Just stock up on some SSRIs, cause youre in for one helluva emotional shock if HR1 doesnt pass.
CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)She isnt just telling people what the outcome is and she is definitely not telling people that there is basically no point unless X happens.
I think we had better be planning that HR 1 WONT pass and start with THAT in mind and get our ground game i order. Many of the election laws CAN be overcome IF we start working right now. Yes pressure Manchin and Sinema and frankly every sitting politician to put pressure on them to pass it but understand that talk about giving up the game if you dont get the call you wanted is a loser mentality.
But the statements that the democracy will end and everyone needs to start looking for a new country to live in is bullshit. And it needs to stop.
PortTack
(32,778 posts)uponit7771
(90,347 posts)... in the rest of the post but I can't see the union ... NOT ... becoming Belarus if the GQP get back into power in any way.
The US is still not at top of Democracy Index because of apartheid like voter suppression
PortTack
(32,778 posts)Some are choosing to find a path forward without EVER giving in or giving up..even when we dont get certain legislation passed
CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)I agree which is why I cannot allow the messaging to be that if HR1 doesnt become law that we have to accept that our democracy is dead. The jig is most definitely NOT up for me if that comes to be. And even still should Republicans take control I will not simply go belly up.
Fiendish Thingy
(15,624 posts)Ill keep on sounding the alarm that the stakes are extremely high, and that the fight is NOW.
I, for one, refuse to assume that HR1 will not pass, and will not give up on voting rights, as you seem prepared to do, and are too willing to fall back on your comfort-zone paradigm of work really hard, overcome Jim Crow 2.0 and win in 2022!
Ill stick with reality, as stark as it is.
But, Im open-minded; feel free to outline the steps you see that can overcome voter suppression
laws (court challenges might work, but not in time to affect the 2022 elections, and with the current SCOTUS, might not work at all).
P.S. Gretas activism absolutely includes discussion of the catastrophic consequences of failure to address climate change...and so does Biden.
If students in WV and AZ went on weekly democracy strikes, refusing to go to school, and their parents refused to go to work on those days until the filibuster was killed and HR1 was passed, youd see Biden sign a new voting rights bill by Halloween.
CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)Having dinner with the family at the moment but I think you misunderstand me. It is not my intention that we shouldnt push for HR1 to pass. Quite the contrary. What I have a problem with is the message that we are all Fucked if it doesnt that message is NOT helpful in the least. We will not be fucked. We will have to work harder. That is the long and short of it. Of course I have said as much on this topic previously.
PortTack
(32,778 posts)I work tirelessly for the Dems volunteering and back the DNC, the DCC and the ACLU with monthly contributions. I also support various dem candidates for the midterms, democracydocket.com and fairfight.org.
I write, email and call, and yes I have watched the video you posted.
We are all aware how important these bills are and no one is going lalalala!!
We need HR1, but if we dont get it we cannot give up and just say were f..ked, that doesnt work. ALL of the new voter suppression laws are being challenged, if not all, the most egregious parts will not stand in the courts. If you want updates on those suits follow Marc Elias on twitter and his organization democracydocket.com
I will never ever respond by simply saying we are f..ked..that is giving up!!
CrackityJones75
(2,403 posts)TwilightZone
(25,471 posts)You're unlikely to gain anything by ranting at people and making it personal. There is zero evidence that your assertions have any validity where the other poster is concerned. Ranting about it and doubling-down on the attacks is a bit childish.
Fiendish Thingy
(15,624 posts)TwilightZone
(25,471 posts)Particularly when they're on as shaky ground as this one. The argument that the Democratic Party is complacent is complete rubbish.
uponit7771
(90,347 posts)... the passing of SR1 in your sphere of influence that's way more than yelling in the dark with a flashlight in hand.
TwilightZone
(25,471 posts)And many of the persistent purveyors of same have been around a long time.
Paladin
(28,264 posts)We need to wake the hell up, take a serious look at the degenerates who are now in charge of the Republicans, get really angry, and fight back. Our country is rapidly going down the toilet, and we're not providing anything close to an adequate response.
JI7
(89,252 posts)Grasswire2
(13,571 posts)Not here.