Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

UpInArms

(51,285 posts)
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 08:03 AM Aug 2021

Afghanistan war neocons like George W. Bush would like you to know this isn't their fault

The neoconservatives who launched the war in Afghanistan would very much like you to know the war’s ignominious ending is someone else's fault.

In The Atlantic, Tom Nichols wrote a piece titled, “Afghanistan Is Your Fault,” saying the loss of the war should be blamed on American voters. Former Bush administration speechwriter David Frum said we could have won the war in Afghanistan with this one little trick (namely killing Osama bin Laden in December 2001 instead of May 2011). Eliot A. Cohen — a founder of the infamous neoconservative group Project for the New American Century — said now was a time for “for meticulous soul-searching” that is “without recrimination.”

But very few people in American history are as due for recriminations as the neoconservative cabal in then-President George W. Bush's administration who drove us heedlessly into decadeslong conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq. Sober analysts at the time made clear that remaking Iraq and the “graveyard of empires” into Western-friendly, capitalist, liberal democracies was a fool’s errand.

As we evaluate the failures of those efforts today, we must recognize the problem was not in the execution of the wars, or the withdrawals, but in the very idea of committing American lives and wealth to forcibly “rebuilding” nations across the globe to fit neoconservatives' vision of society. Their hubris and greed cost us trillions of dollars and thousands of lives — and did more to diminish American power than our stated adversaries ever could.

While neoconservatives claim to be motivated by a commitment to promoting liberal democracy abroad, their push for war and empire was justified through lies and deception. And that played a huge part in undermining the stability of liberal democracy here at home.

There is a direct line from the loss of trust in government caused by the Bush administration’s lies about weapons of mass destruction to Donald Trump’s claim as a presidential candidate that “I alone can fix it.” The hatred and fear mobilized to justify the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan seamlessly flowed from the Bush era into the tea party and then the white nationalist movement that Trump surfed to the White House. Most importantly, the trillions spent on weapons used to bring foreign populations to heel was money that was not allocated instead to pay for desperately needed health care, education or infrastructure here at home.

More at:

https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/afghanistan-war-neocons-george-w-bush-would-you-know-isn-ncna1277267

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Afghanistan war neocons like George W. Bush would like you to know this isn't their fault (Original Post) UpInArms Aug 2021 OP
Would've, could've, should've, an alternate universe Walleye Aug 2021 #1
The war in Afghanistan was an incredible, overwhelming success Orrex Aug 2021 #2
This X 1000! Prof. Toru Tanaka Aug 2021 #7
+++ BlueWavePsych Aug 2021 #11
+1 leftstreet Aug 2021 #23
If you really want to get to the root cause, just look at GoCubsGo Aug 2021 #3
Your last sentence is the truest sentence ever made. Butterflylady Aug 2021 #5
Agreed. And the recount launched Roger Stone, John Bolton bussed from DC to stop the counting. It Evolve Dammit Aug 2021 #12
Agreed wholeheartedly. calimary Aug 2021 #25
Agree 100%. Neocons To Blame. True Blue American Aug 2021 #4
It most certainly is their fault. War is big business. scarytomcat Aug 2021 #6
Their goal was to take control of 7-countries in 5-years with the military. Hotler Aug 2021 #8
This 👆🏼 UpInArms Aug 2021 #18
Ah, good ol' PNAC. Grokenstein Aug 2021 #20
Yep. Made my blood run cold. calimary Aug 2021 #26
K and R Moebym Aug 2021 #9
Politics is weird Sympthsical Aug 2021 #10
neoconservatives ended up in the NeverTrump camp different flavor of zealot NullTuples Aug 2021 #24
Fuck all those people. And I don't give a good goddamn how much they dislike Trump. Sure, Carlitos Brigante Aug 2021 #13
So would all the major MSM who elect Repubs, including W and tRump. Hortensis Aug 2021 #14
A lonely voice in the wilderness gets it right. Thanks for the link, Hortensis. nt crickets Aug 2021 #28
Never forget that bu$h & cheney took us to war based on knowingly false evidence. spanone Aug 2021 #15
W is living a life of luxury. Free from prosecution or the Hague fescuerescue Aug 2021 #16
Before the war Buzz cook Aug 2021 #17
Because "the prize" was not Afghanistan... Grins Aug 2021 #22
For the Bushies it was Iraq Buzz cook Aug 2021 #29
The only thing missing from the war architects' dodge is . . gratuitous Aug 2021 #19
My #1 complaint about Obama... Grins Aug 2021 #21
Yeah, well W and his neocon scumbag advisors can all jump up and bite my ass. Texin Aug 2021 #27

Walleye

(31,067 posts)
1. Would've, could've, should've, an alternate universe
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 08:26 AM
Aug 2021

Not reality. Nobody really knows what would’ve happened in any situation. All we know is what did happen.

Orrex

(63,228 posts)
2. The war in Afghanistan was an incredible, overwhelming success
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 08:34 AM
Aug 2021

Its goal was to funnel trillions in the pockets of war profiteers, and it’s hard to imagine a more sweeping and total victory in this regard.

GoCubsGo

(32,095 posts)
3. If you really want to get to the root cause, just look at
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 08:37 AM
Aug 2021

Sandra Day O'Connor, Anton Scalia, Clarence Thomas, and the other Supreme Court members who stopped the 2000 Florida vote count, that when completed, would have rightfully given the presidency to Al Gore. Not to mention Jeb Bush and his associates, who helped his brother steal those electoral votes. But, yes. Those who made the vote close enough to steal by casting their ballots for The Village Idiot or for Ralph Nader have this on their heads, as well. None of this would have happened under President Al Gore, along with a whole lot of other stuff.

Evolve Dammit

(16,781 posts)
12. Agreed. And the recount launched Roger Stone, John Bolton bussed from DC to stop the counting. It
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 05:11 PM
Aug 2021

worked. 45 is using the same basic model. They hate democracy and they hate this country. They want to rule, period.

scarytomcat

(1,706 posts)
6. It most certainly is their fault. War is big business.
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 09:41 AM
Aug 2021

We need to learn from this. Stop pushing people around. People have to want and understand democracy to keep it.

Hotler

(11,447 posts)
8. Their goal was to take control of 7-countries in 5-years with the military.
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 10:48 AM
Aug 2021

The only thing standing in their way was the American people. They wrote in their paper Project For A New American Century that in order to get the American people behind them they needed a "Pearl Harbor type event". They used 9/11 for that event.

Grokenstein

(5,727 posts)
20. Ah, good ol' PNAC.
Sun Aug 22, 2021, 08:25 AM
Aug 2021

Almost forgot about that. And once they were done taking over those seven countries, they intended to go ahead and take over the rest of the world through everything from military invasion to economic isolation and ruin. PNAC was a cartoon supervillain's map for global domination, doomed to failure but still destined to destroy countless lives along the way.

"Are we the baddies?"
"Naw, we're the heroes. See? Wrapped the Stars and Stripes around it. That means it's good."

calimary

(81,521 posts)
26. Yep. Made my blood run cold.
Sun Aug 22, 2021, 03:19 PM
Aug 2021

What they needed was a Pearl Harbor-like calamity to trigger their wet dreams of world domination. Exploiting some national tragedy for more power.

Sympthsical

(9,127 posts)
10. Politics is weird
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 02:38 PM
Aug 2021

A lot of neoconservatives ended up in the NeverTrump camp. Trump only arranged for the Afghanistan withdrawal because it was politically perfectly safe for him to do so. A lot of Trumpists wanted the withdrawal. Remember, he's a populist, and he would go to wherever those winds were blowing. The populist Right hasn't been gung ho about Afghanistan for a while now.

This past week, a lot of NeverTrumps are absolutely flipping on Biden. Weird, right? Because they're neoconservatives. They want that intervention (and $$$) and imperialism (and $$$) and a uni-polar world (and $$$).

I'm pretty harsh on how this withdrawal has gone, but I'm 100% in favor of Biden's policy.

Neoconservatives are not. Notice Liz Cheney refers to it as the "Trump/Biden" calamity.

This is why I have always said, "Be careful of getting too much in bed with NeverTrump. They are still neoconservatives at heart. Once he's gone, they'll turn." Getting rid of Trump served their purpose. Now, they have a new purpose.

It is not the liberal or Democratic one, rest assured.

Carlitos Brigante

(26,505 posts)
13. Fuck all those people. And I don't give a good goddamn how much they dislike Trump. Sure,
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 05:14 PM
Aug 2021

we'll take your vote. Now kindly disappear for a year or ten.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
14. So would all the major MSM who elect Repubs, including W and tRump.
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 05:41 PM
Aug 2021
Why the debate on Afghanistan is so distorted

As we have watched the rapid dissolution of the Afghan government, the takeover of the country by the Taliban and the desperate effort of so many Afghans to flee, the U.S. media have asked themselves a question: What do the people who were wrong about Afghanistan all along have to say about all this? (Sarcasm emoji appropriate here.)

That’s not literally what TV bookers and journalists have said, of course. But if you’ve been watching the debate, it almost seems that way.

The number of Afghanistan/Iraq hawks — the ones who brought us those twin disasters in the first place — who have been called on by major media organizations to offer their sage assessment of the current situation is truly remarkable.

Whether it’s retired generals who now earn money in the weapons industry, former officials from the Bush, Obama and Trump administrations who in many cases are directly responsible for the mistakes of the past two decades, or war enthusiast pundits with an unblemished record of wrongness, we’re now hearing from the same people who two decades ago told us how great these wars would be, then spent years telling us victory was right around the corner, and are now explaining how somebody else is to blame for Afghanistan.

One name you almost never hear in all the “Why this is President Biden’s greatest failure” talk is one George W. Bush, who took us to Afghanistan... You’ll have to look far and wide for an interview with someone who objected to the Afghanistan war when it began, but if you want to hear one former Bush official interview another former Bush official about what a mess Biden made, just turn on your TV.

This isn’t something new. In fact, it has characterized the debate over the entirety of this period. ...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/20/why-debate-afghanistan-is-so-distorted/

fescuerescue

(4,448 posts)
16. W is living a life of luxury. Free from prosecution or the Hague
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 06:02 PM
Aug 2021

I don't think he's worried about this.

In fact he's probably a little tickled that his name is back in the news.

sigh

Buzz cook

(2,474 posts)
17. Before the war
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 07:44 PM
Aug 2021

A letter circulated from a former military man who had served in Afghanistan with an NGO removing land mines.

It basically outlined a whole different type of conflict that wouldn't involve US troops and as a large part of it focus rebuilding the infrastructure of the border states such as Tajikistan.

Basically it was strategy to build on international good will in the aftermath of 9/11/01.

My understanding was that it was being discussed at the highest level. Heck Col. David Hackworth took an interest and we had a brief conversation about it.

At any rate it filled me with hope that America could engage with Afghanistan and capture Bin Laden and at the same time do some actual good in the world.

Then of course Bush went and fucked everything up.

Grins

(7,239 posts)
22. Because "the prize" was not Afghanistan...
Sun Aug 22, 2021, 11:46 AM
Aug 2021
…it was Iraq!! Where the oil and oil infrastructure was there for the taking. And all it needed was a “Big Lie” to make it happen.

Mere hours after the 9/11 attacks Rumsfeld was asking if it was Iraq. And he hoped it was. And then the Reich cobbled up the then “Big Lie” to give the neocons cover.

So we took our eye off the ball in Afghanistan for the shiny and rich target over there….

Buzz cook

(2,474 posts)
29. For the Bushies it was Iraq
Wed Aug 25, 2021, 12:11 AM
Aug 2021

With Afghanistan and Bin Laden being the distraction.
The Project for the New American Century spelled that out before election 2000.

For the sane amongst us it was a chance to sow and grow good will and get nations working together for the common good. And at the same time get Bin Laden.

So basically good vs evil. Evil won.

gratuitous

(82,849 posts)
19. The only thing missing from the war architects' dodge is . .
Sat Aug 21, 2021, 09:46 PM
Aug 2021

"Mistakes were made." Oh, and the ever-popular "Nobody could have foreseen . . ."

Grins

(7,239 posts)
21. My #1 complaint about Obama...
Sun Aug 22, 2021, 11:31 AM
Aug 2021

There are only a couple issues I have with Obama, but #1 is he refused to go after the Bush administration and the far Reich for KNOWINGLY getting us into the war in Iraq.

(His trying, for his entire time in office, to work with Republicans to find a non-existent common ground is #2.)

Texin

(2,599 posts)
27. Yeah, well W and his neocon scumbag advisors can all jump up and bite my ass.
Sun Aug 22, 2021, 05:05 PM
Aug 2021

Cheney and Rumsfeld and their dimwit puppet prezdent decided to invade first Afghanistan and then blunder into Iraq twenty years ago. They were all greedy Daddy Warbucks and oil moguls who saw a profit to be made for it. And here we are 20 years hence with some people in Washington and in the media bleating about the pullout and forgetting that first the Brits, followed by the Russians made the same mistake about colonizing Afghanistan long before we bungled into it. There was never going to be any kind of withdrawal that would not have ended exactly thus. And TFG made it worse by selling out to the Taliban.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Afghanistan war neocons l...