General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAny Camp Pfizer people pulling up stakes and hiking over to Camp Moderna?
The Moderna shot has proven to have slightly better durability than Pfizer. Both boosters are going to be the same dosages of the same formulations as I understand it. This leads to the natural question: would the Moderna booster be a universally better option at this point? Only Pfizer is FDA approved at this time, but that reality will be short-lived.
The official answer appears to be to stick with your one type. However, there is reason to be skeptical of that. Vaccines don't linger in your system for long, after six months the only lasting effect is the imprint on your immune system. That is very different from how a drug regimen works.
Consider the question of whether drugs can be combined with alcohol use or not. The official answer for the 10s of thousands of prescription drugs is NO. Do all these thousands of drugs really have harmful interactions with alcohol? Probably not, but the issue is that pharmaceutical companies aren't going to spend all that money on research and expanded clinical trials to make sure. It just isn't cost effective. So putting that verbiage in there is an easy way to reduce those costs as well as limit any resulting liability.
Is the same thing going on here?
16 votes, 0 passes | Time left: Unlimited | |
Sticking with Pfizer for the booster | |
14 (88%) |
|
Getting the Moderna booster if possible | |
1 (6%) |
|
Undecided | |
1 (6%) |
|
0 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided. | |
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll |
lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)So I'm not so sure my preference matters.
Siwsan
(26,250 posts)The medical clinic I use gave the Moderna vaccine. I was vaccinated with Pfizer at another location (got an earlier appointment at Meijer). She recommended I stick with Pfizer.
Haggard Celine
(16,835 posts)My upper arm was very sore around the injection site, and it felt like I had a knot in my back muscles on the same side. No nausea or cold symptoms or anything like that, though. They told me I had to wait a couple of weeks before I get my flu shot, so I'll be going back to do that soon.
brush
(53,743 posts)Walgreens or other pharmacy store?
Haggard Celine
(16,835 posts)I made an appointment to get the booster at CVS, then I got a text from them saying that I could have my flu shot and my pneumonia and shingles shots done there, too. So I made an appointment for the other shots as well.
Then when I went to get the flu shot I told the nurse that I was scheduled to have the booster shot a few days later. She said that she could give me one shot or the other right then, but I would have to wait two weeks before I got the other. I told her that I thought the booster was more important, so let's do it now.
She asked for my vaccine card and I didn't have it with me, so I had to go all the way home and back so I could get the shot. Don't forget to take it with you!
brush
(53,743 posts)brooklynite
(94,358 posts)Is that reason based on medical science?
If so, please provide a citation. If not, why is this any better reasoning than HCQ or de-worming paste?
ProfessorGAC
(64,854 posts)It's true of all vaccines that the vax itself doesn't linger long term, nor does it have to.
The OP pointed this out as a way to differentiate from a drug therapy. That differentiation exists, and it has been common knowledge for decades that therapeutic drugs & vaccines don't work the same way, physiologically.
No citation is needed to support the obviously true.
brooklynite
(94,358 posts)when CDC has said they dont recommend it.
ProfessorGAC
(64,854 posts)It's not even close.
It was clearly making a direct comparison between drug & vaccine mechanisms.
Not sure how you inferred anything other.
brooklynite
(94,358 posts) The official answer appears to be to stick with your one type. However, there is reason to be skeptical of that.
gldstwmn
(4,575 posts)vaccinations. I'm not going to risk it with Moderna. I've no complaints with Pfizer
ProfessorGAC
(64,854 posts)...both a higher % of side effects, & somewhat more intense.
For you, staying with Pfizer seems wise.
For me, I was Moderna anyway, so I'll stick with that for the booster.
voteearlyvoteoften
(1,716 posts)I did try to switch to Moderna but the unvaccinated!! pharmacist at Walgreens wasnt going for it. He told me If I decide to get vaccinated I will get Pfizer Cue me going What?? You arent vaccinated? Well I hardly ever lose it in public but I cussed him out. ( He said something lame about FDA approval) The Covid is raging in Florida and I didnt want to wait so went to another Walgreens today and got the Pfizer booster. I would have had to lie to get Moderna which would be easy enough just say it was my first and not show my card. Its been almost 8 months since first 2 Pfizers and as it was I had to claim medical necessity. ( Every slot was open on their online appt site so I know I didnt take it from someone else) Btw they updated their site last night so the option for booster is there( wasnt yesterday) They will take walk ins too. Sept 20 is the date it opens for everyone for boosters but I know lots of people who have them already. Dont want to get caught in the rush. So thats my booster story. Be well and have a great holiday weekend DU friends 🇺🇸👍🏻🌎
Shermann
(7,399 posts)Corgigal
(9,291 posts)probably dont need a booster anyway. Titter always wanes after every vaccine, but the HPV shot. They dont know why it doesnt with the HPV yet.
Ms. Toad
(33,999 posts)They use the same mechanism, but the delivery vehicle is different and the Moderna dose is 3x the quantity of mRNA than the Pfizer.