General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forumsso, rittenhouse was there to give first aid.
he brought no first aid equipment and he brought a gun.
but, fair point, you can't administer first aid for a gun shot wound if there aren't any guns involved, amirite?
seems to me he was aware of at least 3 situations where first aid was needed.
seems to me he didn't make any particular attempt to administer first aid at any point.
so...
not very good at this first aid thing, is he?
H2O Man
(73,559 posts)Kyle needs to be convicted. He is guily as sin. Yet the judge is doing his utmost to defend him.
exboyfil
(17,863 posts)That means that it would have been difficult to administer any sort of aid with the weapon slung over his shoulder, and he very well couldn't put it down and have it unsecured.
Hoyt
(54,770 posts)but he caused the bleeding.
Yarnie
(90 posts)so I checked out pix, and I see two straps across his back. The gun would have been on his right side, and the medical pack (if it exists) would/could have been on his left. Don't know. Is there any evidence, other than his testimony?
ColinC
(8,301 posts)and it looked like he had a bag on him. Of course, then he tried to murder 3 people so I think that defeats to the point.
imaginary girl
(861 posts)To administer aid to Rosenbaum and chose to flee instead, which resulted in another death and a horrible injury. I don't understand how that choice allows the self defense plea for the second two shootings. He wasn't being threatened after the first shooting until after he fled from the scene (gun still in hand).
Initech
(100,080 posts)Seriously... WTF?
Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)This has come out in the trial.
Kingofalldems
(38,458 posts)I notice he brought an automatic weapon though. Oddly, EMTs don't carry weapons to my knowledge.
Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)Illegally carrying that weapon, to boot.
Kingofalldems
(38,458 posts)He said he was there to help clean up. Where were his cleaning materials?
He brought a weapon to help clean up?
Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)Which I imagine you know. He was cleaning up graffiti earlier in the day. There was even some debate about the gloves he had been using for it. I can't speak to the details about the cleaning, because I didn't hear too much about that part.
You're arguing a narrative. I'm only interested in the law and facts regarding what he's actually on trial for.
Yarnie
(90 posts)of him and a bunch of others cleaning graffiti off a school, or something.
unblock
(52,253 posts)But in my own experience as an emt once upon a time, I was often in positions/situations where I wouldn't have been able to both administer aid and also properly secure weaponry.
I mean I'm carrying a gurney and someone else reaches for my gun I'm supposed to notice this and immediately drop the patient? Down the stairs maybe?
Im grateful I worked in an town where police were able to secure the scene and protect us while we worked.
unblock
(52,253 posts)Given that he never used it.
Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)He testified someone had slashed their finger (I believe), and he gave them gauze and bandage tape. And there was a girl who had sprained her ankle. That's his testimony.
As far as the victims, I don't see anyone stopping to render first aid when they're being chased and people are screaming at them.
At some point, common sense has to reign in this.
unblock
(52,253 posts)Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)I hope you're watching the trial right now, because all this video and testimony is showing how Rosenbaum behaved in the run up to his chasing Rittenhouse.
unblock
(52,253 posts)I'm not as close to the details as some here, but I've seen nothing to suggest that those victims were at fault.
My impression is that self-defense is debatable but plausible in the first case. After that, he was a scared trigger-happy person running around with a rifle in a crowded area. He was the one putting others in life or death frightening situations.
Sympthsical
(9,074 posts)If Rosenbaum is self-defense, then the other two may fall under it. The second two victims are no longer shot "in the commission of a crime." So the self-defense standard remains in play.
Again, if Rosenbaum is self-defense.
Your characterization is biased and wrong. He's not "running around." He's running away. He's retreating towards the police. He is being chased by a crowd shouting at him and making threats. This is on video.
was shot while clobbering him with a skateboard. Victim #3, Grosskreutz, admitted that KR didn't shoot him until Grosskreutz' gun was pointed at him.
The kid should NEVER have been there. He was a hero wannabe, a cop groupie, and a dumb kid. But, facts are facts.
Kingofalldems
(38,458 posts)Torchlight
(3,341 posts)would be almost identical to tenths of percentage, consisting of the same sea-lioning. Every day that passes, that impression becomes more and more a firm reality in my opinion.