Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMust-read, brilliant essay about stupidity!
The Third Force - On stupidity and transcendence
by Garret Keizer
In 1943, after being interrogated by Vichy police officers who suspected him (rightly) of conspiring to rescue Jews from the occupying Nazis, a French clergyman named André Trocmé stepped into the open air with a revised view of the human condition. Before he entered that police station in Limoges, he thought the world was a scene where two forces were struggling for power: God and the Devil, writes one of his chroniclers. From then on, he knew that there was a third force seeking hegemony over this world: stupidity.
....
Stupid doesnt mean unintelligent or even uninformed. The political philosopher Eric Voegelin was closer to the mark when he defined stupidity as a loss of reality. Its possible to take Voegelins definition a step further and say that stupidity is a denial of reality to the degree that ones own survival, to say nothing of the survival of others, is imperiled. Too dumb to live, we might say, summoning metaphors of dodo birds and dinosaurs, creatures who may not have been especially unintelligent but who owe their reputations as lamebrains in large part to their extinction. Stupidity is oblivious to negative consequences; it falls into a pit. Gross stupidity invites negative consequences; it looks for a pit. Theres an element of willfulness to it: let the oceans rise, let the virus rage, you cant scare me. Socrates held that human beings do not knowingly act against their best interests; perhaps his wisdom made it hard for him to imagine a human being who could say, To hell with my best interests, and screw Socrates too. A willful loss of reality, however death-defying it may appear, is never far from a wish for death.
....
So what prompts people to embrace stupidity and cling to it even if it kills themmight we at least be able to understand that? Anyone who believes in popular government had better try. A natural ally of all authoritarian regimes, stupidity threatens progressive democracy in two ways: first by impeding its initiatives, second and more fatally by undermining any faith that those initiatives are possible or worth the effort. What good is power to the people if the people are dolts?
Its possible that some individuals embrace stupidity because theyre afraid of being alone. Idiocy loves company more than misery does. When I taught school, I often remarked on the touching inclusiveness of the druggie segment of the student population. Looks, grades, and athletic prowess were of no account; the only requirement was that you do dope. There is an even more welcoming social circle where the only requirement is that you be a dope. Who among us hasnt basked for an hour or two in the self-congratulatory stupor of the like-minded? In contrast, thoughtfulness can be a lonely choice, especially when accompanied by courage. (Nietzsche contra Twitter: You seek followers? Seek zeroes!) If COVID-19 has highlighted anything as much as some peoples feckless disregard for scientific evidence and the health of their neighbors, its the utter and often poignant inability of many people to endure solitudeor even, in some cases, to avoid a large crowd. If they cant be in a packed bar, gym, or banquet hall, theyd just as soon be dead.
The rest:
....
Stupid doesnt mean unintelligent or even uninformed. The political philosopher Eric Voegelin was closer to the mark when he defined stupidity as a loss of reality. Its possible to take Voegelins definition a step further and say that stupidity is a denial of reality to the degree that ones own survival, to say nothing of the survival of others, is imperiled. Too dumb to live, we might say, summoning metaphors of dodo birds and dinosaurs, creatures who may not have been especially unintelligent but who owe their reputations as lamebrains in large part to their extinction. Stupidity is oblivious to negative consequences; it falls into a pit. Gross stupidity invites negative consequences; it looks for a pit. Theres an element of willfulness to it: let the oceans rise, let the virus rage, you cant scare me. Socrates held that human beings do not knowingly act against their best interests; perhaps his wisdom made it hard for him to imagine a human being who could say, To hell with my best interests, and screw Socrates too. A willful loss of reality, however death-defying it may appear, is never far from a wish for death.
....
So what prompts people to embrace stupidity and cling to it even if it kills themmight we at least be able to understand that? Anyone who believes in popular government had better try. A natural ally of all authoritarian regimes, stupidity threatens progressive democracy in two ways: first by impeding its initiatives, second and more fatally by undermining any faith that those initiatives are possible or worth the effort. What good is power to the people if the people are dolts?
Its possible that some individuals embrace stupidity because theyre afraid of being alone. Idiocy loves company more than misery does. When I taught school, I often remarked on the touching inclusiveness of the druggie segment of the student population. Looks, grades, and athletic prowess were of no account; the only requirement was that you do dope. There is an even more welcoming social circle where the only requirement is that you be a dope. Who among us hasnt basked for an hour or two in the self-congratulatory stupor of the like-minded? In contrast, thoughtfulness can be a lonely choice, especially when accompanied by courage. (Nietzsche contra Twitter: You seek followers? Seek zeroes!) If COVID-19 has highlighted anything as much as some peoples feckless disregard for scientific evidence and the health of their neighbors, its the utter and often poignant inability of many people to endure solitudeor even, in some cases, to avoid a large crowd. If they cant be in a packed bar, gym, or banquet hall, theyd just as soon be dead.
https://harpers.org/archive/2021/09/the-third-force-stupidity-and-transcendence/?fbclid=IwAR3pOTQ4vrZt8RH5ThY8K8i1OFg2Rx9PoRiEF1UloN5Ik0iy_Kt4DZug8Sc
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
2 replies, 1325 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (16)
ReplyReply to this post
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Must-read, brilliant essay about stupidity! (Original Post)
Ocelot II
Dec 2021
OP
Let's hope there is not some major party in the US trying to foist an alternative reality on people.
Bernardo de La Paz
Dec 2021
#1
Bernardo de La Paz
(49,002 posts)1. Let's hope there is not some major party in the US trying to foist an alternative reality on people.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)2. Someone is going to come along and
Exploit the stupid someday.