General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNavy commander fired over vaccine refusal
WASHINGTON (AP) A Navy commander has been fired from his job as the executive officer of a warship because he refused to get a COVID-19 vaccine as required and refused to be tested for the virus, Navy officials said Friday.
Cmdr. Lucian Kins was relieved of his duties Friday as second in command of the USS Winston Churchill, a destroyer, by Navy Capt. Ken Anderson, commander of Naval Surface Squadron 14. Officials said Kins was the first naval officer to be fired as a result of a vaccine refusal.
Navy spokesman Lt. Cmdr. Jason Fisher declined to give the precise reason why Kins was relieved of command, citing privacy concerns. Fisher, who is spokesman for the Naval Surface Force Atlantic, said the reason for the firing was that Anderson lost confidence in Kins' ability to perform his duties after he failed to obey a lawful order.
Other officials, however, said it was because Kins refused the order to get the vaccine, and refused testing to ensure he did not have the virus.
https://krcgtv.com/news/nation-world/navy-commander-fired-over-vaccine-refusal
hlthe2b
(102,378 posts)Lochloosa
(16,069 posts)Midnight Writer
(21,803 posts)COL Mustard
(5,928 posts)This guy failed. The Navy will win on these types of cases, every time.
calimary
(81,507 posts)I dont give a damn WHAT your excuse is for not getting vaccinated. Shut the fuck up and take the shot, Dammit. Whether you like it or not, Dammit! COVID kills. Whether you choose to believe it or not.
Response to calimary (Reply #3)
Name removed Message auto-removed
Zorro
(15,749 posts)lapucelle
(18,350 posts)Demovictory9
(32,475 posts)Hes vaxxed to the max, and that might not be a good thing.
An unidentified man in New Zealand may have been vaccinated as many as 10 times in a single day, according to Stuff.
The popular kiwi publication reports that its believed the multi-vaccinated man may have been paid to get shots under the names of other individuals, who want the privileges extended to those protected against COVID-19, but dont want to get the jabs.
New Zealand Ministry of Health vaccine program manager Astrid Koornneef told Stuff that officials were aware of the issue and taking it very seriously.
Health officials are also working with law enforcement to investigate the situation. Its unclear where exactly the individual got his multitude of shots, but Koornneef recommends that he visits a doctor again as soon as he can.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/man-vaccinated-up-to-10-times-in-the-same-day/ar-AARHzlD
PatSeg
(47,609 posts)10 shots in one day? That cannot be healthy.
aggiesal
(8,924 posts)are going to track 10 people simultaneously.
PatSeg
(47,609 posts)MFM008
(19,820 posts)told us what to do- where to go..live...etc.
I remember standing in the cafeteria to get a shot or two.
No choice.
No protest.
If today's military is afraid of a needle they need to go from commanders to enlistees.
If you dont want it get out with out the benefits.
Its just the way it goes.
duhneece
(4,118 posts)I can only imagine how many vaccinations this man had to rise to the rank of Commander; I believe this man has been 'brainwashed' into the Q/Trump cult.
We'll see...or not. Lol
Mandatory vaccines in the military have been accepted for many decades. This commander even refuses to be tested for COVID. This is hardly the kind of person you would want in charge of others in the military. If he refuses this order, what other orders would he disobey. Such a leader needlessly puts lives at risk.
Response to PatSeg (Reply #22)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
PatSeg
(47,609 posts)pandr32
(11,617 posts)oldsoftie
(12,614 posts)Nobody refused.
Orangepeel
(13,933 posts)Yeah, a person believes junk they read about fertility or what have you or is taking a misguided stand against government requiring an injection into their bodies. I don't get it, but I kind of see how someone else might get sucked in. But I don't get refusing to get tested at all.
oldsoftie
(12,614 posts)Some say it GIVES you Covid. Others have other ridiculous claims about it. I'd bet most of this crap comes from Russian or Chinese accounts. Like the Rittenhouse verdict tweets; most were Russians
Response to oldsoftie (Reply #14)
Chin music This message was self-deleted by its author.
liberalla
(9,264 posts)! ! ! WTF?
It is especially critical for military commanders to not be susceptible to horseshit conspiracy crap. If he believes this stuff, he is not fit to lead others. He's more of a threat and danger to his crew.
These leaders need to be grounded, stable, of sound mind and having good judgement.
*** However, it may be valuable to study him and learn how to deprogram him from cult beliefs.
oldsoftie
(12,614 posts)The clip (here) was posted to YouTube on Nov. 10 and shared numerous times on Facebook with captions reading: Dont get tested the tests ARE the problem and people are genuinely getting sick now. I know many. And they have ALL gotten sick IMMEDIATELY after the damn test.
iemanja
(53,072 posts)Fuck them. Let them go jobless.
PatSeg
(47,609 posts)It is dangerous to have such a person in charge of military personnel. How can he be trusted to make important decisions?
wnylib
(21,615 posts)Military are always getting shots. What would make him think that the covid shot is an exception?
VGNonly
(7,510 posts)The US Navy has 68 of the Arleigh Burke class, 2 of the Zumwalt class.
dlk
(11,578 posts)Getting his way was apparently more important than the health and safety of those under his command. Living in this selfish, alternate reality is truly a pathology.
kairos12
(12,875 posts)Aviation Pro
(12,188 posts)Those who know, know.
mountain grammy
(26,655 posts)Farmer-Rick
(10,212 posts)He was giving a lawful order and he refused to follow it. Someone who was enlisted would be sent to Captain's mast. I have been at Captain's Mast where refusal to follow a lawful order was the only charge.
Did he expect his CO would pat him on the back and say good job ignoring orders and setting an example for all onboard. He's lucky he wasn't court-martialed. Now his retirement is at risk and he's never going to become a CO or even be an XO again.
All because he didn't want to get a simple shot. 5 years from now NO One is going to care.
Owl
(3,644 posts)CaptainTruth
(6,602 posts)I understand demoted, relieved of duty, discharged (either honorably, less than honorably, or dishonorably), but what is "fired"?
Is this another case of a journalist using incorrect terminology?
COL Mustard
(5,928 posts)You're not escorted to the door and off the payroll that afternoon, like you might see in the movies. Military members have due process rights and the services have processes and procedures in place to protect those rights. This former XO will still be on the payroll, but his evaluation from this position will be career ending. He'll never be promoted, he'll never be selected for anything significant (think counting spoons in the mess hall), and he may be processed for administrative discharge if he's not retirement eligible. And while normal processing for retirement can take up to a year (permissive TDY, medical exams, job hunting assistance, etc.) if this guy is retirement eligible his retirement will be expedited. The Navy will want him gone soonest.
madville
(7,412 posts)And probably wasnt likely to make Captain regardless. Hell be removed from his ship, spend a few months or maybe a year processing out, physicals, admin, VA evaluations, etc. Then hell retire with his retirement pay and full benefits and the self satisfaction that he became a martyr in his own mind.
COL Mustard
(5,928 posts)He graduated from USNA in 2004. So, nope...not retirement eligible. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. What a dick. He'd been to Senior Service College too, so yet another expensive, taxpayer funded school, thankyouverymuch!
madville
(7,412 posts)Towards retirement for commissioned officers. Will be interesting to see how they handle it, if he resigns on his own, etc. Either way, doesnt really matter, no one is irreplaceable especially in the military, next one up off the bench, youre in! Lol.
ashredux
(2,609 posts)Its hard to understand why someone would throw their career away on this.
Refuse to even be tested? Just damn crazy
Tanuki
(14,922 posts)but isn't that really what we have here? Why would any one in the military think they could get by with this type of blatant and dangerous insubordination? It can't he tolerated.
piddyprints
(14,648 posts)I grew up in the Army and remember getting poked with vaccinations at every turn. Dad was stationed in Germany and then we came back to the states. Guess what? Jabs before we got on planes.
When my daughter went in to the Air Force, she had to get flu shots and such, even though she didn't want them. Yeah, she got side-effects. Then she knew what to expect next time. We'd kept all her childhood vaccinations up, so at least she was up to date on all of them.
You don't get to refuse orders in the armed forces. If vaccine mandates were good enough for George Washington, they're good enough for us. Glad to see there are consequences for these dopes.
Zambero
(8,971 posts)More than enough to warrant dismissal. I'd wager that the "aggrieved" has already been booked onto the Hannity show.
gab13by13
(21,408 posts)It would also send a message to others in the military. I hope he goes on Fox.
Wounded Bear
(58,719 posts)any officer with that attitude needs to be culled from the service.
ejbr
(5,856 posts)All those years of work to get where he got. He got about 17 vaccinations to join but wouldn't get 1 more to remain. Brain worms.
samplegirl
(11,502 posts)Not much of a commander!
halfulglas
(1,654 posts)He must have been under the impression that he was high enough up in rank to refuse it. And it's not like he can isolate. On a ship you're trapped. Like nothing would even get me on a cruise ship in the foreseeable future.
bluestarone
(17,058 posts)Did the 4 starer get HIS shots? Even if he did REMOVE HIM NOW!