Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Demovictory9

(32,467 posts)
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 08:09 PM Dec 2021

ER doctor's observations - differences in patients based on vax status

Twitter thread..

I’ve seen a lot of Covid in the ER recently.

With so many people getting infected recently, some folks may wonder what’s the point of getting vaccinated at all?

And is there really any value to a booster dose if I’ve had two Pfizer/Moderna or a shot of J&J?

My observations: 🧵

============

Most patients I’ve seen that had 2 doses of Pfizer/Moderna still had ‘mild’ symptoms, but more than those who had received a third dose.

More fatigued. More fever. More coughing. A little more miserable overall.

But no shortness of breath. No difficulty breathing.

Mostly fine.


==========
Every patient I’ve seen with Covid that’s had a 3rd ‘booster’ dose has had mild symptoms.

By mild I mean mostly sore throat. Lots of sore throat. Also some fatigue, maybe some muscle pain.

No difficulty breathing. No shortness of breath.

All a little uncomfortable, but fine.

======%

Most patients I’ve seen that had one dose of J&J and had Covid were worse overall. Felt horrible. Fever for a few days (or more).

Weak, tired. Some shortness of breath and cough.

But not one needing hospitalization. Not one needing oxygen.

Not great. But not life-threatening.

====%%%%====

And almost every single patient that I’ve taken care of that needed to be admitted for Covid has been unvaccinated.

Every one with profound shortness of breath. Every one whose oxygen dropped when they walked. Every one needing oxygen to breath regularly.



45 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
ER doctor's observations - differences in patients based on vax status (Original Post) Demovictory9 Dec 2021 OP
I wish he added observation with age range and underlying conditions (or lack of) Grasswire2 Dec 2021 #1
Also he's only talking to the ones who felt bad enough Mr.Bill Dec 2021 #2
Sounds like a lot of the vaccinated people should never have even gone to the ER. beaglelover Dec 2021 #3
Then why are they in the ER? BlackSkimmer Dec 2021 #4
Lack of testing right now? SergeStorms Dec 2021 #5
Damn, I think you're spot on. BlackSkimmer Dec 2021 #6
Spot on. We vax because we're concerned. They dont vax because they're NOT oldsoftie Dec 2021 #10
But by God, as soon as they get sick, they want MEDICINE RIGHT FUCKING NOW YOU FASCISTS Rabrrrrrr Dec 2021 #25
I heard a terrible story about an ICU doctor on the news recently Rhiannon12866 Dec 2021 #42
Yes, I've read that story. Goddamn GQP. Rabrrrrrr Dec 2021 #44
Going to the er doesn't mean you really needed to go to the er. unblock Dec 2021 #8
People who do that are a huge part of the hospital overcrowding issues. beaglelover Dec 2021 #9
I don't disagree, but I understand why the problem exists unblock Dec 2021 #13
Exactly right greenjar_01 Dec 2021 #21
Some people's thinking(?) Jimbo S Dec 2021 #17
Yes, but the probably vast majority of the time you intheflow Dec 2021 #22
+1 uponit7771 Dec 2021 #37
Let's go Darwin! NurseJackie Dec 2021 #7
I see what you did there. FailureToCommunicate Dec 2021 #15
I stole it, actually... 🤣😜 NurseJackie Dec 2021 #23
Someone at the grocery called me a sheep because I wore a mask ... sarchasm Dec 2021 #28
Ha! NurseJackie Dec 2021 #32
THIS !!!! ☝🏾☝🏾☝🏾 ... and they'll have no idea who Darwin is !! uponit7771 Dec 2021 #38
I know. Isn't that sad. And funny. But mostly sad. NurseJackie Dec 2021 #40
You Too !!! uponit7771 Dec 2021 #41
Why is this news not the first thing covered by every network? deelee Dec 2021 #11
This is helpful for people who think they might have Covid FakeNoose Dec 2021 #12
I can only speak to my own experience Savoir Faire Dec 2021 #14
welcome to DU gopiscrap Dec 2021 #45
To those who have responded "Go to your PCP" left-of-center2012 Dec 2021 #16
We have an urgent care facility but the waiting room is TINY and by definition most are sick. CTyankee Dec 2021 #24
Post removed Post removed Dec 2021 #18
Get help Hav Dec 2021 #19
Really? PJMcK Dec 2021 #20
Dammit I always miss these! oldsoftie Dec 2021 #27
It was the poster's second post PJMcK Dec 2021 #29
You too! The way this one has flown by, in about 3 weeks it'll be Easter! oldsoftie Dec 2021 #30
This is interesting but.. tiredtoo Dec 2021 #26
Are there any MD's here? wryter2000 Dec 2021 #31
DIL works at a local hospital. Aussie105 Dec 2021 #34
I do not blame her wryter2000 Dec 2021 #36
Personal Experience of a Vaxed and Boosted 62 Year Old Overweight Male Burma Jones Dec 2021 #33
Pretty much the same here. Aussie105 Dec 2021 #35
Darwin Wins Again... GB_RN Dec 2021 #39
Difference is unvaccinated die and vaccinated live! Emile Dec 2021 #43

Grasswire2

(13,571 posts)
1. I wish he added observation with age range and underlying conditions (or lack of)
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 08:48 PM
Dec 2021

And those who've had two J&J will do better than just one.

Mr.Bill

(24,310 posts)
2. Also he's only talking to the ones who felt bad enough
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 08:54 PM
Dec 2021

to go to the ER. He doesn't see the ones who don't even feel that bad or have no symptoms at all.

beaglelover

(3,487 posts)
3. Sounds like a lot of the vaccinated people should never have even gone to the ER.
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 08:59 PM
Dec 2021

I would never think of going to an ER for a sore throat, or fatigue. No wonder the ERs are so crowded if people are going there for such minor illness.

 

BlackSkimmer

(51,308 posts)
4. Then why are they in the ER?
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:00 PM
Dec 2021

This makes no sense.

I had Covid in August 2020. Fever spiked nightly to 104, body aches as though beaten with a bat, chills, sweats. Never been that sick in my life.

I never had breathing difficult though terrified I would, and I never went to the ER.

SergeStorms

(19,204 posts)
5. Lack of testing right now?
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:18 PM
Dec 2021

There is an extreme lack of testing available at the moment.

It's a known fact that people who've been vaccinated have far more fear of contracting COVID than people who are unvaccinated. Those who take the most precautions are far more afraid of getting COVID. Of course the anti-vaxxers aren't scared of it because it's all a hoax, right? They're the numbskulls who are clogging up the hospitals and dying now.

Counterintuitive, right? That's the United States we live in right now. Makes absolutely no sense to me either.

Rabrrrrrr

(58,350 posts)
25. But by God, as soon as they get sick, they want MEDICINE RIGHT FUCKING NOW YOU FASCISTS
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 12:03 PM
Dec 2021

assholes talk a mean game about not being afraid to die and Covid is just a hoax, "Gotta live our lives, man!" and "stop being a snowflake" but as soon as they get sick, they go clog up the hospitals for all that fake-science medicine they were shitting on a few hours before and getting angry about how the goddamn medical fascists can't make their Covid go away.

Or, also we've seen around here, the shitstains that go to the hospital because they have Covid but when the doctor tells them it's Covid, they get angry and belligerent - sometimes even a bit violent - because there's no way they could have Covid, it's something else.

I'm just so at the point now that hospitals should have a simple first step entry process: "Are you vaccinated? No? Then we have a tent in the front yard with a big ol' warm fire and a giant screen TV playing It's A Wonderful Life on loop and all the chocolate you want to keep you comfy while you die, while we reserve the medicine in here for people who 'believe' in it. You made your choice months ago. Personal responsibility, rule of law, blah blah blah, etc. etc. etc. Oh, and there's a phone in there you can use to call your family and tell them what a fucking dumb piece of shit you are and that they can come get your body in six days."

Rhiannon12866

(205,665 posts)
42. I heard a terrible story about an ICU doctor on the news recently
Thu Dec 30, 2021, 07:14 AM
Dec 2021

He was treating a 37-year-old man hospitalized with Covid, had a wife and two kids. Of course the patient asked to be vaccinated, but the doctor said it was too late. And his wife and family didn't visit since masks were obviously required and the wife refused. But she was called when her husband was dying, but was removed from the hospital when she refuse again to wear a mask. So the doctor went to the parking lot to tell her that her husband was gone and the doctor had remained with him when he passed away. And that's when she lost it, called him "a murderer" because he hadn't given the husband Ivermectin, I think it was, lashed out and struck him in the face, knocking him down and breaking his nose. That was the doctor's story and he's giving up medicine, that was finally it for him.

Rabrrrrrr

(58,350 posts)
44. Yes, I've read that story. Goddamn GQP.
Thu Dec 30, 2021, 08:53 AM
Dec 2021

and sadly some of the loony crystals-and-granola left, too, refusing masks and vaccines; though I've not heard of any of them getting violent or belligerent.

It's heart breaking how many medical folks are quitting; and the number of the ones who haven't quit who are holding on by a thread from overwork, over worry, abuse from patients and family, and just being really goddamned tired.

unblock

(52,274 posts)
8. Going to the er doesn't mean you really needed to go to the er.
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:30 PM
Dec 2021

Many people still use the er as primary care, and many people go to the er simply because they're afraid it might be something worse than it is.

beaglelover

(3,487 posts)
9. People who do that are a huge part of the hospital overcrowding issues.
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:34 PM
Dec 2021

Go to a damn urgent care or call your PCP. Don't go to the ER because you have a sore throat! SMDH!

unblock

(52,274 posts)
13. I don't disagree, but I understand why the problem exists
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:53 PM
Dec 2021

Seeing a pcp first might mean one more medical bill because of our messed up medical financing system, so some people skip that step.

Pcps run the range from excellent to useless, so again, some may skip that step.

Plenty of people don't even have a pcp, especially younger people who think they're immortal. This is more men than women because an ob/gyn often doubles as a pcp in practice. But then there are women who don't even have an ob/gyn....


Finally, people going to the er unnecessarily doesn't clog up the hospital as a whole, only the er itself. The er is well trained in triage, so hopefully the right cases get handled first. People who don't need to be admitted don't get admitted. In the current crisis, it's the overcrowded icu that's the real problem.

Still, point taken, the er doesn't not need to be overburdened with cases that a pcp could easily handle. Better health financing policy and education would help with this.

 

greenjar_01

(6,477 posts)
21. Exactly right
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 10:19 AM
Dec 2021

This whole "don't go to the ER" thing doesn't jibe with the "Holy shit you're gonna die" thing. We've absolutely scared the shit out of people for two years, then they pull a positive antigen and freak the fuck out. And then they start getting what they would generally interpret as moderate chest congestion for any cold or flu prior to 2019, but we've been telling them they're going to go into goddamn cardiac arrest and their lungs will fail for the last two years, so they think they're going into cardiac arrest and their lungs are failing.

The "guidance" from my hospital system says to treat "mild shortness of breath" at home, while to go to the ER for "trouble breathing." How the fuck is the average person supposed to interpret the difference between those two states of affairs, especially if they're layering a panic attack over the mild shortness of breath?

It's really easy for somebody who hasn't had COVID and who is sitting on a message board to say, "Oh, if you just have cold or flu symptoms, treat them at home. Don't go to the ER!" People are experiencing these things in their bodies, not as casual observers, and they're doing so in the context of an absolutely relentless saturation of fear tropes in the public sphere.

Jimbo S

(2,958 posts)
17. Some people's thinking(?)
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 10:02 AM
Dec 2021

A lot of people have a mindset to go to ER for anything, including a cold or flu. For private business that insures their employees, that drives them crazy since they are the ones who end up paying the bills.

intheflow

(28,484 posts)
22. Yes, but the probably vast majority of the time you
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 10:49 AM
Dec 2021

felt sick wasn’t during a pandemic where 3/4 of a million fellow citizens died horrible deaths.

NurseJackie

(42,862 posts)
23. I stole it, actually... 🤣😜
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 11:05 AM
Dec 2021

I'd recently seen someone else write the same thing, and I thought it was clever (and appropriate).

sarchasm

(1,012 posts)
28. Someone at the grocery called me a sheep because I wore a mask ...
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 12:44 PM
Dec 2021

I said, "Well that must make you a wolf then, right?"
When they responded yes, I said "Well, then Eat Me!"

deelee

(41 posts)
11. Why is this news not the first thing covered by every network?
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:49 PM
Dec 2021

I really don't understand the lack of media coverage of the importance of and benefits of the vaccines. it's well past time for the pussyfooting to placate the anti-vaxxing Trumpsters. Let's get a vaccine passport. Electronic and plastic wallet sized card - with hologram. Only those with the cards can dine in, can fly, can shop in stores, can attend concerts/sports.
Those of us vaccinated - and especially boosted, are looking at nothing more than a cold, and perhaps a slight flu. Why are we cow towing and living like this when we shouldn't have to? I'm really sick of it.

FakeNoose

(32,679 posts)
12. This is helpful for people who think they might have Covid
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:51 PM
Dec 2021

... but can't (or won't) get tested. Thanks I just sent this to my sister.

 

Savoir Faire

(10 posts)
14. I can only speak to my own experience
Tue Dec 28, 2021, 09:57 PM
Dec 2021

And, I don't know that I had Covid. But, I had something starting last weekend, (Fatigue earlier than that) but I attributed that to eyestrain and a long commute. However, starting Christmas day I had a headache (severe for me as I don't often get them). Bodyache (which I attributed to not getting out of bed. Nasal and chest congestion which subsided to runny nose and cough. Pretty much where I am now. Though it has subsided considerably over the day. I am fully vaccinated and boostered. But, there is no testing in Santa Cruz right now.

left-of-center2012

(34,195 posts)
16. To those who have responded "Go to your PCP"
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 09:50 AM
Dec 2021

It takes me 3 months to get in when I call for an appointment.

As for the local urgent care facilities those which take my insurance receive very poor ratings from previous patients.

I can understand those who would go to an emergency room when they have a very severe sore throat and fear it might be something worse.

You know that old saying "Walk a mile in their shoes".

CTyankee

(63,912 posts)
24. We have an urgent care facility but the waiting room is TINY and by definition most are sick.
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 11:50 AM
Dec 2021

"Wait in the car and we'll call you" isn't the advice I want to hear when all I want is my vaccine shot.

I went to my Stop and Shop pharmacy and got every shot I needed.

Response to Demovictory9 (Original post)

PJMcK

(22,038 posts)
20. Really?
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 10:17 AM
Dec 2021

I think you’ve stumbled into the wrong place.

Democratic Underground is a fact-based website.

Take your bullshit elsewhere.

PJMcK

(22,038 posts)
29. It was the poster's second post
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 12:47 PM
Dec 2021

It was titled BULLSHIT. It made the unfounded claim that the deaths were due to the vaccines. Totally right – wing garbage.

You didn’t miss much! Have a happy new year.

tiredtoo

(2,949 posts)
26. This is interesting but..
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 12:24 PM
Dec 2021

The remaining unvaccinated will consider it fake news. Unfortunately we are going to have to do what is needed to save ourselves and let them just die off.

wryter2000

(46,074 posts)
31. Are there any MD's here?
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 01:18 PM
Dec 2021

The way this doctor describes symptoms for a boosted patient (3 shots) it doesn't sound as if they need to go to an emergency department. They could possibly be handled via a telephone visit. Am I wrong?

If I had those symptoms, I sure wouldn't head to the hospital. I'd probably have instacart get me some things from a pharmacy.

To others up-thread who discuss difficulty getting a pcp appointment and cost, etc., let me explain I have Kaiser. If I can't get my pcp on the phone, I for sure can get an advice nurse pretty much immediately or another MD. Also, our urgent care clinic is excellent, but I wouldn't want to go there if I didn't have to. In general, I don't want to go to the hospital during a covid spike.

wryter2000

(46,074 posts)
36. I do not blame her
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 05:13 PM
Dec 2021

I retired from a large medical center. I was a secretary in the legal department, situated in one of the medical office buildings, not in the hospital. I'm still glad I don't have to go there for work. I do go there for medical care.

Burma Jones

(11,760 posts)
33. Personal Experience of a Vaxed and Boosted 62 Year Old Overweight Male
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 04:53 PM
Dec 2021

Because Anecdotal Evidence is what some people prefer


Got the J&J in March and a Moderna Booster in late October.

Had a runny nose, elevated heart rate (not serious), slight headache and slight sore throat Sunday, no fever. I was fatigued.

Took a home test - came out positive.

Had a very stuffy nose Monday, slight sore throat, minor cough, no fever. Still fatigued, slept about 14 hours.

Less stuffy nose, no sore throat, a little sneezing, no fever on Tuesday.

Am asymptomatic today.

I did email my PCP on Monday and she offered to send in a request for me to receive Monoclonal Antibodies but she also said it appeared as though I didn't need them. I said sure go ahead and send in the request in case this gets worse. The folks who do the infusion called, and determined since I wasn't all that sick, I would not receive the infusion due to them being in short supply. And, now, I'm feeling fine.

Aussie105

(5,412 posts)
35. Pretty much the same here.
Wed Dec 29, 2021, 05:00 PM
Dec 2021

I find getting good and angry, and venting - even if just on DU - gets the adrenalin flowing and improves breathing.

Highly recommended!

Not in public though, some people are unpredictable, stupid, potentially violent and possibly armed.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»ER doctor's observations ...