Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
27 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Ukraine rejects Russia's demand to surrender Mariupol by 5 am (Original Post) Yorkie Mom Mar 2022 OP
Brave folks in Ukraine, like other heroes in history..."nuts"...nt wcmagumba Mar 2022 #1
Nuts! lpbk2713 Mar 2022 #2
Truly terrorism & insanity of leadership by Russia. delisen Mar 2022 #3
As Brig. Gen. McAuliffe said... Ocelot II Mar 2022 #4
Російські військові, ідіть нахуй L. Coyote Mar 2022 #5
If they can stop Russia's forward movement they can survive. BootinUp Mar 2022 #6
Rusians haven't been trustworthy anyway, have been firing on "humanitarian corridors"...nt Wounded Bear Mar 2022 #7
As one would expect. Threats to kill the hostages don't work Wingus Dingus Mar 2022 #8
Slava Ukraini. TomSlick Mar 2022 #9
We shall never surrender. nycbos Mar 2022 #10
Thx for posting..a powerful speech...loved the movie PortTack Mar 2022 #11
If they surrender, they know their fate will be that of the 1,000+ that were taken to Russia PortTack Mar 2022 #12
"would only establish humanitarian corridor if Mauripol surrenders" Azathoth Mar 2022 #13
🌻🌻🌻 Hekate Mar 2022 #14
I wish there was a way to help these people in a way that doesn't trigger WWIII. Gore1FL Mar 2022 #15
I think that is the wrong question Lithos Mar 2022 #16
If Russia was more successful, I'd be more inclined to agree. Gore1FL Mar 2022 #18
I'm afraid bullies do not work like that... Lithos Mar 2022 #21
At some point, the bully looks like the black knight in Monty Python. Gore1FL Mar 2022 #22
Not quite how it works Lithos Mar 2022 #23
NATO is ridiculously stronger. Gore1FL Mar 2022 #24
Maybe, maybe not. Lithos Mar 2022 #25
Your argument assumes several 2-year-from-now unlikelihoods Gore1FL Mar 2022 #26
Given our politics Lithos Mar 2022 #27
Apparently, the Deputy Mayor of the city ... relayerbob Mar 2022 #17
It's not like Russia would honor their promise of a safe corridor, anyway. Goodheart Mar 2022 #19
I sing my daily chant...Fuck you, Putin, fuck you! BigmanPigman Mar 2022 #20

delisen

(6,042 posts)
3. Truly terrorism & insanity of leadership by Russia.
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 08:10 PM
Mar 2022

That we are not able as a world to stop this madness of maiming,murdering, and total destruction is a huge wake-up call to our world

Wingus Dingus

(8,052 posts)
8. As one would expect. Threats to kill the hostages don't work
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 08:21 PM
Mar 2022

after you've already spent three weeks...uh, killing the hostages.

Azathoth

(4,607 posts)
13. "would only establish humanitarian corridor if Mauripol surrenders"
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 09:32 PM
Mar 2022

You can't really get a more explicit admission of war crimes than that.

Gore1FL

(21,098 posts)
15. I wish there was a way to help these people in a way that doesn't trigger WWIII.
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 09:51 PM
Mar 2022

I do think such a conflict is avoidable given the military and diplomatic failures of Russia. The human expense in the meantime in maddening.

Lithos

(26,403 posts)
16. I think that is the wrong question
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 09:58 PM
Mar 2022

The question is not if WW III will happen, but has it already started and we're just too foolish to see?

Gore1FL

(21,098 posts)
18. If Russia was more successful, I'd be more inclined to agree.
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 10:30 PM
Mar 2022

Ukraine has stopped Russian ambitions in it's tracks. If Russia could leave with Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk, they would. I hope they don't. I think Ukraine could ultimately have peace without giving up any territory.

After that, Russia doesn't have the strength to occupy a Denny's.

Lithos

(26,403 posts)
21. I'm afraid bullies do not work like that...
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 11:01 PM
Mar 2022

Bullies like him lose many times, but double down each and every time to prevent consequences. Think Trump. Putin has already started moving population into Russia as hostages. He will use them to squat on any gains he makes, refusing them to go back to their homes, effectively creating a Ukrainian diaspora hauntingly familiar with the Holodomar where the Ukrainian populations of Donetsk and Lukhansk were starved en masse and them driven out in favor of ethnic Russian settlement.

This will repeat for countries such as Georgia, Moldavia would topple like dominos.... And once NATO is shown as effectivel toothless, then it will be easy to carve out smaller states.

Ukraine is the second largest country in Europe. Putin only needs to rebuild enough of his army to handle the smaller ones - maybe down for a year or two. He's not interested in rebuilding what he conquers, only in that it is his.

Gore1FL

(21,098 posts)
22. At some point, the bully looks like the black knight in Monty Python.
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 11:05 PM
Mar 2022


Right now, we are around 2 limbs in.

Lithos

(26,403 posts)
23. Not quite how it works
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 11:49 PM
Mar 2022

TBH, Putin has just lost 15,000 men and a few generals, but the army has learned lessons which can only be learned only after seeing the elephant a few times.

Tanks, planes and the like can be rebuilt in a year or two. 15,000 men can be replaced in a year or two. In that time, they can and likely will restructure their military. This fits with the current pattern of Putin being involved in a war every couple of years. It would behoove Putin during this time to go back to influencing elections and see if he can get another weak-kneed GQP person back into the White House - one who might damage NATO yet again.

The world is watching. You can't tell me Xi is not studying things and playing both sides - rearming Russia would be in his interests as Russia would serve as a useful idiot in Chinese strategic planning. Modi has already reached his own conclusions and given us the middle finger.

Gore1FL

(21,098 posts)
24. NATO is ridiculously stronger.
Mon Mar 21, 2022, 12:32 AM
Mar 2022

The top three air forces in the world in terms of aircraft are the U.S. Air Force, the U.S. Army, and the U.S. Navy. Russia can't manage to fend off 60 aircraft, much less find their car keys. This is a disaster for Russia. Putin won't see 2023 in all likelihood.

I am sure Xi is watching. At this point, I can only imagine any plans he might have had to Taiwan are now ash.


There is no reason to escalate to WWIII. Russia does not have the ability to sustain this, much less widen it.



Lithos

(26,403 posts)
25. Maybe, maybe not.
Mon Mar 21, 2022, 01:07 AM
Mar 2022

Trump came within a whisker of taking us out of NATO - all it would take is his re-election and/or one of his disciples to win and we're out. The US is turning into one of the world's most fickle allies. In this case, the next GQP president would do a "Chamberlain" - which is sell out our allies for peace in our time.

This would leave Russia against a fragmented NATO. Germany disarmed themselves a few years ago leaving only really France and the UK to pick up the pieces. I would not count on the UK either given their wishy-washiness as well. The only thing which would save Estonia, Lithuania, and Latvia would be more direct coordination with Poland, Czechia, and Slovakia - maybe even Finland.

As stated, the two-three year traditional gap between wars would put us into the next presidential term.

China plays the long game - they are waiting for a time when the US policy is back to being weak. China's current interest is in developing the Silk Road which is building up their internal trade with all of Asia and doing so in a way which prevents any interference by both the US and by India. I think their interest in Taiwan is mostly sabre rattling and testing at the moment as their is no advantage in taking Taiwan at this time. That will come when Taiwan is no longer important for the world to care enough to do anything more than "hopes and prayers".

As for Taiwan, Taiwan is not NATO, so even if the US comes to Taiwan's aid, NATO is not coming in. The only guaranteed ally would be Japan, or maybe not. S. Korea and the Philippines are only maybes. China is developing just enough of a Navy and just enough of a missile force that they will make the US think twice about supporting Taiwan should and when they enter into the fray.

L-

Gore1FL

(21,098 posts)
26. Your argument assumes several 2-year-from-now unlikelihoods
Mon Mar 21, 2022, 01:28 AM
Mar 2022

It requires:

1> An Anti-NATO GOP presidential candidate
2> That Anti-NATO GOP presidential candidate winning
3> That Anti-NATO GOP president having enough support to withdraw from NATO

Each step is predicated on the previous.

As far as Taiwan, NATO isn't relevant; Taiwan isn't located in the North Atlantic. What matters is the world's response to Russia over it's assault on Ukraine. The world won't take lightly to a Chinese assault on Taiwan, either. Not even getting into the military challenges in attacking an island, it's safe to assume they aren't going to risk it.

If I am wrong, we have two years to worry about it. To me, it seems like peace is worth the wait.



BigmanPigman

(51,567 posts)
20. I sing my daily chant...Fuck you, Putin, fuck you!
Sun Mar 20, 2022, 10:59 PM
Mar 2022

every time I hear news like this.

Putin will continue to manipulate mankind with nuclear threats until the day he dies. Hopefully that will be sooner than later but you never know. Really evil bastards somehow live very long lives, no Karma for them. Therefore, we must stop allowing him to wield this power of a possible nuclear war. That is BS and I think we need to nip Putin in the bud ASAP. He will use this again and again until we draw our own red line and say Fuck Off. He doesn't want a nuclear war and is full of shit. A very, very small eunuch is what he is, not a strong manly man as he thinks he is. I bet his mushroom is about the same size as Donny's is. TINY.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Ukraine rejects Russia's ...