Ukraine May Mark a Turning Point in Documenting War Crimes

[Nevilledog]

Link to tweet

Tweet text:

Alice Speri
@alicesperi
"The reality that prosecutions cannot succeed without evidence drives those doing the work."

A fascinating look at how Ukraine may mark a turning point in documenting war crimes (with lessons learned in Syria, Yemen, Myanmar).

by @justinhendrix

justsecurity.org
Ukraine May Mark a Turning Point in Documenting War Crimes
Interviews start with local Ukraine researchers who have been documenting Russian war crimes over many years before now.
10:10 AM · Mar 30, 2022

https://www.justsecurity.org/80871/ukraine-may-mark-a-turning-point-in-documenting-war-crimes/

Last week, the United States government announced its formal determination that Russian troops have committed war crimes in Ukraine. Secretary of State Anthony Blinken said the assessment was made on the basis of a “careful review” of public and intelligence sources. “We are committed to pursuing accountability using every tool available, including criminal prosecutions,” his statement read.

Accountability, though, requires evidence. The collection and preservation of digital media and other evidentiary material in Ukraine is a massive undertaking. It is being met by brave Ukrainian officials and local civil society groups operating in besieged cities and towns, as well as by an international coalition of human rights, open source intelligence and digital forensics researchers. This loose coalition is drawing strength from relationships formed with one another and lessons learned while investigating past conflicts, including in Syria, Yemen, Myanmar and elsewhere.

The ongoing effort in Ukraine, then, can be seen as part of an evolution – or a maturation – of an expanding community of volunteers and professionals gathering user-generated evidence and open source intelligence. It may also represent a crucial test of whether the evidence produced by these methods can play a substantial role in securing convictions.

What follows is a snapshot of the effort in progress, based on interviews with more than a dozen individuals representing a sample of organizations. It reveals some of the key challenges facing this growing field: the reliance on volunteers working in the midst of a conflict; security threats and coordination problems flowing from the over-collection of material; and the centrality of social media platforms that were never designed with atrocity documentation in mind. Still, the reality that prosecutions cannot succeed without evidence drives those doing the work.

*snip*