General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsEmail from Michael Moore -- The Forced Birth Ruling
One hundred seventy million American women and girls were suddenly informed on Monday that they have been removed from the ranks of full citizenship, and that their rights are now diminished so severely they will heretofore be commanded to give birth, whether they want to or not.
Once pregnant, the government will now make all women prisoners of their wombs, automatically forced for the full nine months to carry the fetus inside them to term, whether they intended to be pregnant or not, a 21st century version of house arrest.
And when its time to give birth, the woman who didnt want to be pregnant in the first place is either virtually or physically held down until that fetus is forcibly removed from the incarcerated vessel that was ordered to carry it.
This Order by the Supreme Rulers gleefully violates the very first pronouncement of our Constitutions First Amendment which clearly states, without equivocation, that Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. The Ruling this week forces all Americans to now follow the strict religious beliefs of the Catholic Church and much of Christianity which has concocted a fantasy that a fertilized egg is a human being even though their own founder and God, Jesus Christ, never said any such thing. In fact, the word abortion appears absolutely nowhere in the New Testament. This Supreme Ruling, from a Court consisting of a majority of Catholic Justices, has ordered the citizens of the United States of America to now obey a major tenet of the Catholic Church or be found guilty of a crime.
This Supreme Ruling removes the right of all women to be equal citizens to men men who will retain full 100% control over their own reproductive organs. Both men and women have five main bodily systems. Women will now be allowed to maintain control of only four of their top five bodily systems: their circulatory system, respiratory system, digestive system and their muscular/skeletal system. But not their reproductive system. That power now belongs to the government. Which makes women 4/5 of a citizen. The State of course exercises no legal control over whatever it is men want to do with their bodies, and no man is forced to reproduce or deal with any of its consequences as women are.
Our Supreme Robed Rulers have relegated women and girls to permanent second-class citizenship. The pretending that women are legally equal can now thankfully stop. The truth is they were always 2nd class citizens, thanks to unequal pay, no paid maternity leave, domestic abuse, etc. The fake mask of our American system of equality has been ripped off, no more pretending now, because the real slippery slope has begun. This Forced Birth decision is only the beginning. If these fascists are not removed from office, as President Biden has warned us this week, they will be emboldened and they will be on a rampage to undo other freedoms that are an affront to the State Religion they have now shoved down our throats in the Dobbs Case.
Next up: ending same sex marriage. After that: the removal of the Plan B pill, aka the morning after pill. They have already eliminated the Violence Against Women Act and they will make that permanent. They have invaded school board meetings with threats of violence if the schools continue to teach that white Americans kidnapped, raped, lynched and enslaved Black Africans to build this country. They will continue to gerrymander, suppress the vote, and keep Black Americans on the lowest rung of the economic ladder. Your child will be forced to start the school day, every day, by standing and praying aloud to this Christian God Jesus Christ who never once condemned homosexuality, never once forced anyone to pray. They have made up this fake god to suit their totalitarian political agenda, to force women into the maternity ward, to send Black Americans to the back of the new bus where they are imprisoned by the millions along with other people of color.
Welcome to the New America. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss, only the new boss no longer has to fake-sing his praises for Democracy! and Freedom! and Equality!
The New America is about to become a much scarier place. The Supreme Wealthy are going to take everything from you and they believe theyre going to get away with it. Only November stands in their way. Only November has a chance of stopping them. And thats on you and me.
MASSIVE ORGANIZING!
EXPLOSIVE NONVIOLENT RESISTANCE!
EVERYONE BRINGS FIVE VOTERS WITH THEM TO THE POLLS!
EACH OF US PUTS A SIGN IN THE WINDOW OR THE YARD THAT SAYS VOTE THE FASCISTS OUT!
Then we might have a chance.
And I believe we do. Because theres more of us than there are of them.
(Note: The ABC News poll this week showed 70% of Americans believe abortion is a private decision between a woman and her doctor. Only 27% of the country supports what the Trump Court is about to rule! Cmon people lets beat these traitorous bastards once and for all.)
WhiteTara
(29,722 posts)he is a very big reason we are here.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)He's a very big reason because...?
AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)ancianita
(36,137 posts)After Sanders lost the 2016 primaries, Moore urged Americans to vote for Clinton[127][128] while also correctly predicting that Trump would win the election because the post-industrial Midwestern states would vote for Trump.[129] After Trump was elected, Moore called Trump a "Russian traitor",[130] saying his presidency had "no legitimacy"...
October 2019, he announced his political endorsement of Bernie Sanders in the 2020 Democratic Party presidential primaries.[146] After Sanders lost the primaries, Moore urged Sanders supporters to vote for Joe Biden in the general election.
AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)Response to AZSkiffyGeek (Reply #12)
Rebl2 This message was self-deleted by its author.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)because he's an Independent? That you'd do that just distracts from and undermines women's interests right now.
As a woman I'll take whoever can be influential in the fights against forces arrayed right now against women.
Schmice3
(294 posts)Jakes Progress
(11,122 posts)And I just don't understand why we don't win.
Steve Canuck
(45 posts)Tribalism never amounts to anything. The right is the party trying to make everyone into a like minded clone of eachother. Criticism of Democrats can't be treated with open hostility, especially of something useful can be constructed from that criticism.
getagrip_already
(14,838 posts)He did everything he could to suppress the mi vote.
He hated her, and while he probably thought she would still win, he worked to bring her down.
And that cost us 3 justices.
LymphocyteLover
(5,654 posts)notinkansas
(1,096 posts)He was her opponent in a primary race. He did not hate her. He endorsed her after the primary.
Just stop with this nonsense.
getagrip_already
(14,838 posts)Unless you mean he was supporting her by giving interview after interview saying she was a weak candidate, flawed, how the dems don't know what they are doing, how she is generally wrong on positions and dwelling on republican attacks.
He kept repeating those rw talking points. If anything, he damned her with weak praise.
A perfect way to suppress the vote and prove yourself right.
We don't his voice now.
Kid Berwyn
(14,964 posts)Cha
(297,692 posts)AntivaxHunters
(3,234 posts)We start means testing who is going to be our allies in the fight against Roe v. Wade then we're royally fucked!
He has a MASSIVE following and we NEED everyone we can get.
Dorian Gray
(13,501 posts)And if he wants to be an ally, he can earn our trust back by fighting for this cause while withstanding criticism.
AntivaxHunters
(3,234 posts)ShazzieB
(16,529 posts)Having to live through 2016 once was excruciating. I have less than zero desire to relieve it.
Dorian Gray
(13,501 posts)But what I originally said still stands. This is more important. If he wants to be a true ally, he should listen to people's concerns.
AntivaxHunters
(3,234 posts)They're just not the same as yours or some of mine.
We need everyone we can get right now. Solidarity in full force in the name of women's rights & public health.
Magoo48
(4,720 posts)TexasBushwhacker
(20,215 posts)If Gore and Clinton had been elected, how different would America be?
NNadir
(33,556 posts)Hortensis
(58,785 posts)hypocrites who deceive and attack while posturing as virtuous would be enough to make it hell for me.
Cha
(297,692 posts)Cha
(297,692 posts)This is a dark time. Thank you for your light.
Cha
(297,692 posts)your Light, too.. and Thank You!
💙💛
dlk
(11,578 posts)Lets look ahead, not backward. Moore may not be perfect but in this battle, hes on our side.
WhiteTara
(29,722 posts)me? not so much.
dlk
(11,578 posts)In times of emergency, it makes no sense to reject support.
AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)ancianita
(36,137 posts)" theres more of us than there are of them. "
And gotta ask how that's working out for us so far.
AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)It started with "both sides are the same, vote Green!" in 2000.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)Who, if you haven't been paying attention, isn't a Democrat.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)You must have missed where he urged Sanders supporters to vote Clinton and Biden, though.
You know that primaries are where Democratic Party DU'ers promote their favorite candidates, right? That included Bernie. Mine was Gov Jay Inslee. I don't think you can claim he's not a Democrat because of his primary promotions.
That said, anyone of his influence who supports women right now is worth paying attention to.
MrsCoffee
(5,803 posts)The high profile hold outs hurt in the end.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)The whole hate-on here is about his PAST behavior, when right now women need allies.
Emile
(22,925 posts)We're suppose to be a forward looking community and not rehashing the past.
MrsCoffee
(5,803 posts)You really believe we don't have the right to be pissed off at public figures that we feel came around a little too late after the damage they helped cause was already done?
What you call hate, is righteous ANGER. We can be pissed off about the past and try to embrace his efforts now. But you don't get to just call us haters as if we just decided one day to pick on Michael Moore.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Sympthsical
(9,120 posts)These lines of logic defy common sense at this point. Here's how 2016 went:
"Hey, guys? Trump could win this thing. You need to pay attention to the Rust Belt."
"Noooo, we got this!"
"So, Trump won."
"How could you have done this to us?!"
Six years later, still no self-reflection. How we are in the situation we are this week becomes less a mystery.
AZSkiffyGeek
(11,070 posts)For non-Democrats enabling a fascist.
Or did you forget that Hillary predicted this exact outcome and people still couldn't be bothered to vote for the e-mail lady?
I'm sorry, but if someone can look fascism in the face and still decide to vote third party, their traitorous ass can fuck off.
Sympthsical
(9,120 posts)I understand people have that switched around out of personal preference, but I'm not one of them. So the 8,234th refrain of, "But Bernie's not a Democrat!" is the same thing as telling me it's 64 degrees outside. I'm aware. Not sure what it has to do with anything though. But sometimes you end up talking to that one neighbor who is just intensely interested in these things. So you make a note of it and move on.
How did someone warning about the Rust Belt "enable a fascist." The thing is, at some point we need to start saying true things instead of bending narratives to suit whatever the argument at hand is. Michael Moore isn't how we got Trump. He campaigned for Hillary. That is a true statement. Any intimation he somehow did this is not. It's a narrative whose sole purpose is the airing of a grievance that should be dead in the grave.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/michael-moore-s-october-surprise-new-pro-hillary-clinton-film-n668791
Here. Let me quote:
In "Michael Moore in TrumpLand," Moore takes center stage in a way like he never has before. The film is a one-man show extolling the virtues of Clinton's political career and her potential for greatness as a president before an audience largely composed of skeptics. It takes places in the largely conservative community Wilmington, Ohio -- the birthplace of the banana split, and located in Clinton County.
"I wanted to do something subversive here, something that wasn't expected," he told reporters at a press screening Wednesday. "That I, of all people, would be making the case for Hillary."
"Nobody needs a film to tell you that Donald Trump is full of s--t and an awful human being, who would come to see that movie?" added Moore. "What I thought would be interesting is what if I wrote this one-man show and then perform it in hostile territory."
Moore's film -- which he hopes will reach Clinton haters; voters who are leaning toward Trump or a third party; or perhaps are thinking of not participating this November at all -- suggests that much of the antipathy toward Clinton is overstated and overlooks the barrage of abuse she's endured for being a feminist. The film argues that admiration for Trump is steeped largely in white male paranoia over their inevitable diminished role in society.
This sheer revisionism and constant preoccupation with past could've been glories that never came to pass needs to come to an end now. We have serious work before us. If Roe doesn't get people to let go and move on and focus on the fight that exists now, I cannot stop them from counterproductively going full Miss Havisham, which is what it increasingly looks like.
One must never go full Miss Havisham.
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)Emile
(22,925 posts)community.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)detracts from the national ally energy for the 51%.
One must never go full Miss Havisham.
Cha
(297,692 posts)💙💛
Nixie
(16,979 posts)ammo, but reality will never be acknowledged.
betsuni
(25,630 posts)tishaLA
(14,176 posts)that this creates a new class of people: rapist dads.
It's the Rapist Dad Ruling.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)Traildogbob
(8,812 posts)Will those rapists babies be when daddy gets weekends with them at 10-18 years old?
Joenobody
(90 posts)Seems like rapist dad's would be big fans of birth control including abortion. Better to keep their raping secret.
This is the abusive husband ruling because it's easier to control the wife/keep abusing her if there are kids tying her down.
patphil
(6,212 posts)She can make the soul wrenching choice to give the baby up for adoption, or she can choose to spend the next 20 or so years of her life caring for and raising a child she didn't want to give birth to.
Isn't freedom of choice great?
KS Toronado
(17,329 posts)If she doesn't want it, the father automatically gets the baby with no child support ever, she's done her part
against her will, maybe even visitation rights with no strings attached, could also make them pay for the woman's
pain & suffering & lost wages. Time men are made to pay for not practicing birth control.
BlueSky3
(514 posts)reauthorized and signed by President Biden in March.
[link:https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/03/16/fact-sheet-reauthorization-of-the-violence-against-women-act-vawa/|
Farmer-Rick
(10,212 posts)Did I miss something?
ancianita
(36,137 posts)ancianita
(36,137 posts)state interests that enslave them for nine months and thus, are defendants and not criminals?
Amendment XIII
Section 1.
Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Section 2.
Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.
This part --
That's what your post implies to me.
JudyM
(29,279 posts)He is preaching truth, hopefully his call to action will inspire some who will pass it on.
calimary
(81,500 posts)I now find myself daydreaming about relocating to Canada.
JudyM
(29,279 posts)make that happen. This could be our opportunity if more speak out with passion like this, like Warren and several others. Making it hit home hard, find and deeply touch peoples humanity at its core. Im daydreaming about this, a real rising up and out of a collective stupor so you wont feel compelled to move.
KS Toronado
(17,329 posts)Women's votes will be calculated at 4/5's of a man's vote.
Seems the direction we're going.
Response to ancianita (Original post)
jfz9580m This message was self-deleted by its author.
colorado_ufo
(5,737 posts)to cover abortion rights? This draft ruling of the Supreme Court literally puts every woman in the United States under arrest when it comes to her reproductive rights. If a woman can be forced to give birth, would it not be a far extension until a woman is forced to become pregnant at a certain age, or to bear a certain number of children, or children of a certain sex (as in China)? Will she need to prove that she is qualified to reproduce, via genetic and other tests? Will she be required to marry only certain individuals who would best be suited to her reproductive capabilities?
The Democrats in power had better act quickly and strongly to prevent this most damaging ruling by the Supreme Court.
And one more thing: Why did this issue come up right now? I have not heard of any case before the Supreme Court that would require a review of the precedent set by Roe vs Wade. Why did they decide to pull this issue out of their Supreme butts?
dai13sy
(340 posts)What country is this - communist russia. I'm grateful I can't have babies any more because if I could, and I did become pregnant I could be under "house arrest" until the unwanted baby was born. Republicans really hate woman and kids. It's been apparent forever but this just throws it in our faces. The Republican Party is not a party of Family Values. As Michael Moore says, "One hundred seventy million American women and girls were suddenly informed on Monday that they have been removed from the ranks of full citizenship, and that their rights are now diminished so severely they will heretofore be commanded to give birth, whether they want to or not." And whether it kills them or not. I will definitely take support from Michael Moore. He has all the FACTS right here and wants to help.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)in DC and beyond.
Forced Pregnancy as a Crime Against Humanity and a War Crime
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)He also hockey-assisted in the death of Roe v. Wade with all the shit he talked about Hillary and other good Democrats who were trying their best to prevent this exact outcome from happening back in 2016.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)michaelmoore@substack.com
Right now, even as he's late, even as he couldn't have known what cases would have led us to this point, I'll still take him as an influential ally, fwiw.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)He chose to talk shit about her and help depress the vote, which led directly to this.
If he didn't see this coming, maybe he should have been watching what Republicans have been doing instead of bitching and moaning about good Democrats through the years.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)So you're saying that he (and the Comey Op-Ed) directly caused her to lose votes.
So we women are supposed to throw his support aside over Bernie and Hillary.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)Women have a lot of supporters, many of which didn't help bring about this situation directly by their actions like Moore did.
Just ignore him and amplify the voices of REAL allies that didn't help bring about this situation to begin with.
Just ignore this attention-seeking asshole and post support from the many, MANY actual allies we have. Post something from, oh, I don't know, Hillary?
notinkansas
(1,096 posts)We all do. Then when the winner is chosen, we vote for that candidate. That's how this thing works.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)And enough of that bullshit from that particular segment of the left doing just that is how a Republican got elected and started the ball rolling on the death of Roe v. Wade.
Hillary told him and everyone else and he chose to shit on her.
notinkansas
(1,096 posts)See post #9. And we did. Don't visit the results of that election on Democrats. Hillary got 3 million more votes than the former guy. The electoral college is the problem.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)...we don't have so-called "allies" depressing the vote.
lapucelle
(18,337 posts)Remember his cringe-inducing speech at the first Woman's March during which he slowly mainsplained (in list format) basic activism as if the marchers were children who needed to be instructed on the obvious?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Michael Moore enumerated this interesting item on his list:
GOD BLESS THE DEMOCRATS WHO HAVE FOUGHT WITH US.
IT IS NO KNOCK ON THEM. BUT, YOU ARE COACHING THE WOMEN'S BASKETBALL TEAM TWICE IN TWO YEARS.
WE WON, AND THEN WE LOST. WE WIN AT THE WHITE HOUSE, BUT THEY WALKED THROUGH THE DOOR.
ARE YOU GOING TO LET THIS HAPPEN AGAIN IN YOUR LIFETIME? I AM NOT.
I AM SORRY, BUT THE OLD GUARD OF THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY HAS TO GO. IT HAS TO GO. WE NEED NEW LEADERSHIP.
(Sorry about the caps, but this excerpt is directly from the C-SPAN transcript.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moore's use of pronouns is especially interesting. He makes a bewildering statement about Democrats having worked with "us" (whoever "us" is). Then he refers to Democrats as "them". He finishes off with "we", but it's unclear who the "we" refers to.
You can watch Mr. Moore's extraordinary performance here:
https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4650649/michael-moore-addresses-womens-march-washington
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)Running off people who would vote democratic
ancianita
(36,137 posts)n.
Before the debates I kept thinking, Trump has such thin skin, if Hillary just had like a comedy shiv in her hand, just to slip under that thin skin, he will implode, Moore said ...
... he texted some funny friends for help. I asked all you guys to form a Justice League of comedy, and we would write jokes and things for Hillary to say during the debates that would just make him melt, Moore said.
Schumer said she was all in but when Moore took the idea to Clintons camp, someone called Schumer dirty. (Schumer joked: Theyre not wrong.)
Moore said that the left-leaning gang agreed to do the work for free, and with no credit. We were going to do this confidentially Our only joy [would have been knowing] that the line that brought down Trump was Amys [or one of the other incognito writers]. Schumer, whos related to Democratic Sen. Chuck Schumer ...
Of Clintons team turning the professional comedic help down Moore said the decision was made by the same people who decided not to have her go to Wisconsin once during the election. The Clinton campaigns decision not to canvas heavily in parts of the Midwest is widely credited with having doomed her chances of taking over the Oval Office. Clinton made no visits to Wisconsin as the Democratic nominee, and only pushed a late charge in Michigan once internal polling showed the race tightening.
Moore called it madness, adding Clinton fell victim to the Brooklyn bubble (where her campaign was based). The way things get insulated [from] the rest of the country is not helpful.
MrsCoffee
(5,803 posts)After being one of the biggest Bernie Bros? And she turned him down? What a shocker.
He DID shit on the candidate. IT HAPPENED. I heard him say she could never earn his vote. How many people were going to take his 180 seriously three weeks before the election? And even while urging people to vote for her at that point, he sure repeated over and over again that it was gonna be really hard for them to hold their nose and do it.
Let's let people be angry about that and have their feelings instead of pretending it didn't happen.
That said, I do appreciate his efforts now. Even if I'm still super pissed off.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)MrsCoffee
(5,803 posts)I can't really believe you typed that out.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)You want to hate all over a pro-Roe and women's ally. Trifling.
MrsCoffee
(5,803 posts)Pretty much the only reason for me jumping into this thread.
Michigan is Moores home state and he voted for Sanders. In fact, hes never voted for Hillary Clinton before, or any Clinton for that matter.
He has been on Larry King live saying he was "morally prohibited from voting for her".
Kind of how I feel about his support now. So yeah, I'm reluctantly grateful for it.
Anyway, I'm not about to do a google search for all the crap he gave her. I've heard plenty of it over the years.
Nixie
(16,979 posts)didnt have to happen and the same public players are going back to the anger well to stir up the usual umbrage. When the time came to commit to securing actual progress, they continued with their selfish and distorted self promotion. Now we see what that cost.
lapucelle
(18,337 posts)Lets face it: Our biggest problem here isnt Trump its Hillary. She is hugely unpopular nearly 70% of all voters think she is untrustworthy and dishonest. She represents the old way of politics, not really believing in anything other than what can get you elected. Thats why she fights against gays getting married one moment, and the next shes officiating a gay marriage. Young women are among her biggest detractors, which has to hurt considering its the sacrifices and the battles that Hillary and other women of her generation endured so that this younger generation would never have to be told by the Barbara Bushes of the world that they should just shut up and go bake some cookies. But the kids dont like her, and not a day goes by that a millennial doesnt tell me they arent voting for her. No Democrat, and certainly no independent, is waking up on November 8th excited to run out and vote for Hillary the way they did the day Obama became president or when Bernie was on the primary ballot. The enthusiasm just isnt there. And because this election is going to come down to just one thing who drags the most people out of the house and gets them to the polls Trump right now is in the catbird seat.
https://michaelmoore.com/trumpwillwin/
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)Thank goodness, moore realizes right now, reproductive rights are more important than refighting a primary from six years ago
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)People were claiming the same thing after Moore realized how terrible Bush was after he shit on Gore in 2000 -- and then he did it all over again, this time with Hillary in 2016.
Better to call him out on his shit now and remind people that he is not to be trusted as he was one of the many that paved this path we are on today rather than people be fooled into thinking he is an "ally" and believe his lies about the next good Democrat that stands in the way of Republican fascism and we end up with another Republican administration thanks, in part, to him.
So, once again, a hearty "fuck you" to him. Anyone that helped get Trump elected by shitting on Hillary need to sit this the fuck out. Let our REAL allies do the heavy lifting and they can support them, which, you know, if they were doing all along, we wouldn't be in this situation to begin with.
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)No thanks
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)How hard is that to understand?
Virtually all of my complaints are based on what Moore did after the primary was decided -- not before.
If you aren't willing to wholeheartedly support the WINNER of the primary and do all you can to get them elected, don't even fucking participate in the primary to begin with. That goes for both voters AND candidates (cough cough).
Response to W_HAMILTON (Reply #57)
Emile This message was self-deleted by its author.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)The only reason I commented on the primary was because the other poster kept bringing it up. My problems with Moore mostly stem from what he did after the primary was already decided.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Please stop bringing up the past.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)I would say there are far more people here that feel like me than like you when it comes to Michael Moore.
Response to W_HAMILTON (Reply #66)
Emile This message was self-deleted by its author.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)As I have said before, my problems with Moore stem from what he did AFTER the primary.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Not one mention of the primary, because the type of stuff I am referring to happened even after the primary was decided.
Now, YOU go read it.
Emile
(22,925 posts)And then show my post where you accused me of the same thing.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)I was replying to a poster that brought up the primaries on their own -- maybe you should go alert them, hmm? -- and insinuated that my opinion meant that there should be no primaries, when I didn't even mention the primary in my previous post, nor was I referring to them since, once again, most of what my problems with Moore occurred after the primary was decided.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Last edited Sat May 7, 2022, 04:15 PM - Edit history (1)
to stop. We don't need to be rehashing the past, when we need to be looking forward.
sheshe2
(83,925 posts)Biden was the winner of the last primary and went on to beat tfg.
Cha
(297,692 posts)Emile
(22,925 posts)have big fights ahead and it would be nice to be united
Cha
(297,692 posts)trump & fascism to get in the WH need to stop but they won't.
💙💛
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)questionseverything
(9,660 posts)And you have produced no evidence, just repeated bashing of a democratic ally
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)I lived through it. Google "Michael Moore Hillary" and look through the pages and pages of results of him shitting on her.
Oh, and here is one piece I actually forgot about -- taken during the infamous summer of 2016:
Democratic ally, my ass.
Might as well fucking post Susan Sarandon and Jill Stein messages of support for Roe v. Wade, for god's sake.
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)obamanut2012
(26,142 posts)I haven't listened to a word from him since.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)obamanut2012
(26,142 posts)betsuni
(25,630 posts)questionseverything
(9,660 posts)After the first machine count there were 175,000 over votes that werent counted , 2/3 of them were for gore from black precincts, where gores bubble was darkened by his name and his name was written in the write in catagory
so two votes on one race
If the state had been hand counted, these over votes would of been counted as their intent was clear.
Lance de haven smith was the one who realized it but gore had conceded after the supremes came out against not counting all counties the same way
I read both articles on the same day back then
If we only we had known then how important that hand count could have been
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)...we wouldn't have need to.
I mean, the dude fucking CAMPAIGNED for Ralph Nader in 2000. And you are defending him, here on DEMOCRATIC Underground, and calling him a fucking Democratic ally. Fuck that. Fuck ALL of that. And, just in case anyone missed it, fuck Michael Moore.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)I posted this email to show his support for Roe.
Not to diss and dismiss him for past politics. So you can knock all that off and not interpret me back to me.
If you can't get over the worst of his political decisions, and not even back him one time when he takes the pro-Roe side, that political priority is on you. And don't give me the Hillary speech; he did encourage the General turnout for her. I don't have to like him to support his support of women. Whereas your whole harangue about whether anyone's political errors can make them worthy woman allies is not helping women's need for male allies right now.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)Of course it was a political priority to get Hillary elected. You know why? To prevent disastrous outcomes like Roe v. Wade being killed off. Too bad people like Michael Moore didn't see it as a political priority when it actually mattered and now only want to rear their ugly heads now to gin up more publicity for themselves after helping bring about the thing they are acting so outraged about.
And if calling Hillary all the things he did was "encouraging the General turnout for her," well, I guess I'm being real supportive of our """ally""" Michael Moore in saying he can fuck right off as well.
obamanut2012
(26,142 posts)It's hysterical people are handwaving what Moore did.
betsuni
(25,630 posts)ancianita
(36,137 posts)Last edited Sat May 7, 2022, 09:07 AM - Edit history (1)
One year earlier, Gore had said the goal of reducing our dependence on expensive dirty oil was to save the future of civilization.
The film shows Jon Stewart, the host of Comedy Centrals The Daily Show, asking Gore, You couldnt find, for your business, a more sustainable choice?
What is not sustainable about it? responded Gore.
Because it is backed by fossil fuel money? said Stewart.
As part of the agreement, Gore reportedly received $100 million. Climate activists werent bothered by it. I dont think the community is too upset, a politically active environmentalist told The Washington Post about Gores deal with Qatar. My personal sense is he got a good deal.
No activists blamed Moore for anything about the oil money Gore took. He told the truth.
Gore took fossil fuel money, but don't think Rethugs used that to advantage. They didn't give a damn about anything but winning. So the Brooks brothers gang got John the Pirate Roberts to coach Bush's legal team on how to argue before SCOTUS -- he's the one who helped them overturn the ruling to finish the Florida vote count.
W_HAMILTON
(7,873 posts)TERRIBLE look.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)perceived PAST behavior.
obamanut2012
(26,142 posts)Plenty of blame, including Gore, but to say Moore wasn't involved in the loss is naive at best, and disingenuous at worst.
betsuni
(25,630 posts)Response to obamanut2012 (Reply #103)
Post removed
obamanut2012
(26,142 posts)He even said he fucked up and tried to spin stuff RIGHT BEFORE the election, but it was too late.
He absolutely is a real part of fluffing fucking Nader
ancianita
(36,137 posts)That's some real rational politics right there, almost like the politics of spite.
Sympthsical
(9,120 posts)Something bad happened in the past, and people just got stuck and full of spite. Time has stopped, and there is no ability to move forward beyond extending that bitterness into the present no matter how damaging and disabling doing so may be.
For what other purpose can there possibly be here? Nothing productive comes of it. It does not move anything forward. Its only object seems to be to mire the present forever in the indignities suffered in the past.
Now we have Roe being overturned. The dress is on fire.
Jesus. Even Havisham forgave in the end. How burned do people need to be before they manage it? Dickens didn't exactly write her as a guide for coping with life's disappointments.
ancianita
(36,137 posts)When we need all hands on deck for the party's fight for women, that people drag this party down with recrimination and spite politics pisses me off.
Purity police, retaliatory stances, judgy mcjudges on the worthiness of allies do not help advance women's equality; they are a drag on momentum. They imply that liberal women can never trust anyone but their own group, even as some of their women (religious, political, or just indifferent) betray women's establishment of equality.
joshcryer
(62,276 posts)The Republicans would have made that hand count last months, past the date of electors, all that.
Kathrine Harris would've still approved Bush* as President.
Shit was done before it was done. It was just too close.
The butterfly ballot had more to do with it than Nader.
But Nader definitely contributed greatly and they wanted to hurt the Democrats: https://www.democraticunderground.com/10025175397
questionseverything
(9,660 posts)What we need to do in the future is actually hand count the votes
(I do agree the repubs did illegal things to make it seem we lost)
ecstatic
(32,731 posts)with some of the millennials or zillennials out there. We need all hands on deck at this point.
Celerity
(43,532 posts)Tempus fugit.
You are the first other than myself (as I am one, born a few months before 1996 ended, and thus closing out the Millennial birth years) I have seen use the term Zillennial (or as some label it, Zennial). There is some debate (especially on Reddit) as to what the exact years of my micro gen are, but I tend to roll with those born 1992 (many say 1993) to 1998.
Reddit has many who try to drag it forward and include 1999, 2000, 2001( really getting tenuous now as 2001 is not even in the same Millennium as 2000), hell I have seen 2003, 2004 even claimed, but for me that is not a valid construct.
I base a lot of it off 9/11 (even being myself a London-raised person from the age of 2). You had to have had some, even if extremely vague, memories of that paradigm changing event, or at least the aftermath, say over the next 1 to 2 years in terms of my working definition of what constitutes a Zillennial.
I have taken multiple academic courses in demography and sociology/social anthropology and have always had a fascination about intergenerational interlocks and then outcomes born of those linkages.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Farther
(150 posts)Except he made a movie that implored people to get out and vote for her:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6163356/
ancianita
(36,137 posts)I don't post much so I haven't looked into emojis and the like. But you are right, sarcasm is sometimes hard for folks to discern. However, should the confused click on the link they would see that Moore spent considerable time and money in an effort to get Hillary elected as well as other Democrats who were running in 2016. The guy is not the villain he is often portrayed to be. It gets tiresome.
I too am further to the left of many Democrats, but have voted dem since my first vote for McGovern. We are all on the same team and may only have a couple election cycles before we no longer have a democracy. We have no time left for purity.
msfiddlestix
(7,286 posts)from the message. This message is exceedingly spot on and important way of framing the issue we should be promoting.
come on folks. why are you guys doing this?
do you disagree with the content? Is this issue not a big deal to you guys?
Are you hoping that the fascists religious terrorists on the Supreme Court will be victorious?
C'mon man... stop this distraction on the messenger. please.
JanMichael
(24,890 posts)msfiddlestix
(7,286 posts)If we can't all embrace this one, then how is it possible for us to come out of all this overwhelmingly victorious?
The way I see it, we have to win beyond "by a hair" or "a hare's breath"
I'm beyond sick and tired of the "neck and neck" horse race treatment of basic human rights vs religious/fascists and other forms of tyranny.
If we don't join together here, we're screwed and we won't have anyone to blame but our own "tribe".
mcar
(42,375 posts)Go away, Moore.
lapucelle
(18,337 posts)the Roberts Court, and the appointment of Alito. The moronic Moore's gripe against Al Gore was that he was a "corporate environmentalist".
In the aftermath of the 2000 election, the American people got the Iraq War, the Citizens United decision, and the Alito opinion. Al Gore got the Nobel Peace Prize for environmental activism.
What did Moore get? Michael Moore got richer. Moore is very good at monetizing his "activism". And as a multimillionaire with tens of millions in personal wealth and nine homes, he's very good at making sure he hangs on to it: He prevented the writers on his TV show from joining the Writers Guild and is infamous for hiring non-union workers when making the films he writes, produces, and directs.
https://abcnews.go.com/Business/michael-moore-snubs-union-workers-making-capitalism-love/story?id=8715559
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On July 24, 2016, Moore published a piece called "Five Reasons Why Trump Will Win". This was well after HRC was the Democratic Party nominee and just a few days before our convention. One of the five reasons was the following:
Lets face it: Our biggest problem here isnt Trump its Hillary. She is hugely unpopular nearly 70% of all voters think she is untrustworthy and dishonest. She represents the old way of politics, not really believing in anything other than what can get you elected. Thats why she fights against gays getting married one moment, and the next shes officiating a gay marriage. Young women are among her biggest detractors, which has to hurt considering its the sacrifices and the battles that Hillary and other women of her generation endured so that this younger generation would never have to be told by the Barbara Bushes of the world that they should just shut up and go bake some cookies. But the kids dont like her, and not a day goes by that a millennial doesnt tell me they arent voting for her. No Democrat, and certainly no independent, is waking up on November 8th excited to run out and vote for Hillary the way they did the day Obama became president or when Bernie was on the primary ballot. The enthusiasm just isnt there. And because this election is going to come down to just one thing who drags the most people out of the house and gets them to the polls Trump right now is in the catbird seat.
https://michaelmoore.com/trumpwillwin/
If Moore was unaware of how many women, true allies, and Democrats were excited to wake up and vote for Hillary Clinton on election day (not simply because of her gender, but also because of her journey, her leadership, and her expertise), he really needs to shut the fuck up and sit the fuck down
Michael Moore is not an ally. He's an opportunist. He helped bring us to this moment. He needs to take responsibility and apologize.
Just_Vote_Dem
(2,820 posts)lapucelle
(18,337 posts)for the Democratic nominee on election day? What alternative reality is Michael Moore living in?
Emile
(22,925 posts)1. How many actually read the OP email from Michael Moore?
2. Does the GOP come here to see what rips apart the Democratic party?
msfiddlestix
(7,286 posts)lapucelle
(18,337 posts)because he made a few movies about (and a lot of money from) the evils of corporations.
Moore needs to take responsibility and apologize for his hand in ushering in the Roberts Court, the Alito decision, and the Trump presidency.
His self-serving opportunism at at this moment is typical.
Emile
(22,925 posts)lapucelle
(18,337 posts)Emile
(22,925 posts)lapucelle
(18,337 posts)Emile
(22,925 posts)lapucelle
(18,337 posts)The response is directed to your post.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So what are you talking about?
Emile
(22,925 posts)Shouldn't be that hard to understand what I was saying.
You forgot this post.
Star Member Emile
156. Have you read the OP email from Michael Moore?
Star Member lapucelle
157. Yup. N/T
Star Member Emile
158. What did he say that upsets you?
Star Member lapucelle
159. What are you talking about? N/T
Star Member Emile
160. You forget what the thread is about?
Star Member lapucelle
162. Oh, glad to explain how threads and subthreads work. I was not responding to the OP.
The response is directed to your post.
lapucelle
(18,337 posts)and a response to the OP thread is.
Furthermore, there is no requirement here that posters respond in a fashion proscribed by other posters.
Michael Moore has done nothing other than to jump on a bandwagon. He needs to take responsibility and apologize for his part in enabling the Bush presidency, the Roberts' Court, and Alito's appointment. The damage he facilitated is incalculable. Why anyone here would amplify his voice here is bewildering.
Emile
(22,925 posts)Adios
kjones
(1,053 posts)A whole lot of people here eager to rehabilitate Moore.
Whenever I see someone talking about tribalism here, it feels more like projection.
If he really wants to do good, maybe he should follow his own advice, make some room for growth, and funnel his resources into some fresher voices.
Doubt he'd do that.