Appeals court dismisses GOP megadonor's lawsuit against Beto O'Rourke
A state appeals court dismissed Republican megadonor Kelcy Warrens defamation lawsuit against Beto ORourke, ruling Friday that statements by the 2022 Democratic nominee for governor were protected by the First Amendment.
The Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals said a district court judge in San Saba County mistakenly denied ORourkes motion to dismiss in July 2022. Warren, a Dallas pipeline billionaire, had sued ORourke for defamation after the candidate repeatedly invoked Warren while criticizing Gov. Greg Abbott for the 2021 power-grid collapse.
We hold that an examination of the statements and their context from the position of a reasonable person shows they are non-actionable opinions and fall within the bounds of protected speech, a three-judge panel said in its ruling.
Fridays ruling came seven months after oral arguments on the motion to dismiss and can be appealed to the Texas Supreme Court. Warren's lawyer did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The legal journey kicked off more than a year ago, when ORourke opened his campaign with intense criticism over Abbotts handling of the grid failure amid a severe winter storm. Warrens pipeline company made a huge profit as demand for gas spiked, and ORourke seized on a $1 million donation Warren later made to Abbott, arguing it was effectively a bribe to go easy on Warrens industry after the storm.
https://www.texastribune.org/2023/06/09/kelcy-warren-lawsuit-beto-orourke/