Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A wild Civil War story for you all (Original Post) AntivaxHunters Aug 2023 OP
Thank you for your service John. Hotler Aug 2023 #1
9 year old in the line of fire of artillery shells?? Child labor laws have advanced a tad, now the Alexander Of Assyria Aug 2023 #2
Different realities. In those days parents lacking means Hortensis Aug 2023 #17
Powder Monkeys Doc_Technical Aug 2023 #31
Right. Drummer boys accompanying infantry into battle. Hortensis Aug 2023 #32
"Life is hard" stuck in the middle Aug 2023 #22
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_soldiers_in_the_American_Civil_War FYI Playingmantis Aug 2023 #23
I had already known this, but thanks for posting facts. Article txwhitedove Aug 2023 #27
Some recent good news stuck in the middle Aug 2023 #24
160 years, plus or minus a few Warpy Aug 2023 #33
I know a descendant of another Shiloh drummer boy and have seen the drum. Liberty Belle Aug 2023 #3
I shared with my niece in Temecula/Hemet duhneece Aug 2023 #8
What an interesting find.Thanks. The Wielding Truth Aug 2023 #30
1+ keithbvadu2 Aug 2023 #4
That look says: "Yeah. You want to secede and keep your enslaved people? Aristus Aug 2023 #5
Interesting story. I don't think I have heard this one before. Thanks for posting. LoisB Aug 2023 #6
Wow! Faux pas Aug 2023 #7
Thank you for this fascinating information. niyad Aug 2023 #9
I'd heard of him before, for a library program I put together called Kid History. intheflow Aug 2023 #10
Yeah, his parents should have gone on the internet and... bif Aug 2023 #13
I read a little more and his mother was killed in a train accident. intheflow Aug 2023 #35
Johnny be good! Bluethroughu Aug 2023 #11
Child soldiers are an abomination. WhiskeyGrinder Aug 2023 #12
Damn, that brought a tear to my eye. CaptainTruth Aug 2023 #14
Then there is the movie about the 12 year old who enlisted in the navy during We2. 3Hotdogs Aug 2023 #16
My grandfather went into the army at 15. carpetbagger Aug 2023 #18
Wow! 3Hotdogs Aug 2023 #21
It was made into a movie! Staph Aug 2023 #25
The last Civil War widow died in 2020. We are probably down to a handful of people brewens Aug 2023 #15
Pretty crazy she married a 93 yr old Tree Lady Aug 2023 #19
Some vets also wanted to pass along their pension which could have been of help, just sayin. appalachiablue Aug 2023 #34
General Clem Kennah Aug 2023 #20
I really don't know whether a child should be in combat. Martin68 Aug 2023 #26
Nobody is saying children should be fighting in wars! robbob Aug 2023 #28
The Civil War was 40-50 years before anyone thought seriously about child labor laws. intheflow Aug 2023 #36
Shiloh and Chickamauga were two of the most savage battles Martin Eden Aug 2023 #29
An entire life... Snackshack Aug 2023 #37
 

Alexander Of Assyria

(7,839 posts)
2. 9 year old in the line of fire of artillery shells?? Child labor laws have advanced a tad, now the
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 10:17 AM
Aug 2023

children can die less violently in meat factories!

Parents, where?

Don’t salute military service??… of any child in a civil war hundreds of years ago.

Not ok then, not now.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
17. Different realities. In those days parents lacking means
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:35 AM
Aug 2023

to support children could give them away to other families or employers with the agreement that they'd work to earn their support, which could be very minimal. Ships, including war ships, often had small children as crew members. Separated families often never saw each other again, and dreadful exploitation of the helpless was common. (So was decent people having to act.)

In fact, it was a very poor and harsh world compared to today's high level of prosperity and wellbeing. And everyone lived much closer to death then than now, especially babies and children. Though average life expectancy was only 39, it was that low above all because so many died very young.

Different realities. I'll go ahead and respect the officers who treated this boy kindly and fairly for the times. There were plenty who wouldn't.

 
22. "Life is hard"
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:56 AM
Aug 2023
A Former Girl Soldier in Colombia Finds ‘Life Is Hard’ as a Civilian

The New York Times

April 27, 2016

CALDAS, Colombia — Mélida was only 9 when guerrilla fighters lured her away with the promise of food as she played on the floor. For the next seven years she was held hostage by the rebels, forced to become a child soldier.

Her family thought she had died in battle. Then Mélida suddenly returned to her village at 16, carrying a pistol and a grenade. Only her grandfather recognized her — from a birthmark on her cheek.

The very next day, the military surrounded her house, called by an informant seeking the bounty on her head.

“I found out my own father had turned me in,” she recalled.

snip---— (video at link)

(Gifted article, no subscription necessary)

Link to article

Leonor González Mina - Violencia (en vivo) - Teatro Colón



Fragmentos (english subtitles)

Museo Nacional de Colombia


Playingmantis

(141 posts)
23. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_soldiers_in_the_American_Civil_War FYI
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:57 AM
Aug 2023

Throughout the American Civil War, approximately 250,000–420,000 males under the age of 18 were involved in both Union and Confederate forces.[1] It is estimated that 100,000 Union soldiers were 15 years of age or younger.[2] By one estimate, approximately ten percent of Union soldiers were underaged (it is likely the Confederate army had a similar proportion of underage soldiers)

txwhitedove

(3,933 posts)
27. I had already known this, but thanks for posting facts. Article
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:28 PM
Aug 2023

notes Clem "ran away from home", tried to join more than one Regiment, and then tagged along with one. They finally took him in, fed and paid him. Times were hell and desperate.

I remember seeing a young boy with a wagon tied to his bike, hauling water, etc, home the week after Hurricane Katrina in Bay St. Louis, MS. We had NO services, missing roads, houses, obstacles and destruction everywhere. I could tell his mama must have had babies at home. He was on a mission.

 
24. Some recent good news
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:18 PM
Aug 2023


The New York Times

June 13, 2023

Colombian Children Rescued in Jungle Had Been Fleeing for Their Lives

The father of two of the survivors said the family had feared the children would be recruited by a violent armed group.

snip——(more at link)

(Gifted article, no subscription necessary)

Link to article



The New York Times

June 27, 2023

The Unexpected Rescuers Who Found Colombia’s Missing Children

Colombia’s Indigenous Guard has long had to fight for a space in the national narrative. Today, it is at the center of the country’s biggest story.

snip——(more at link)

(Gifted article, no subscription necessary)

Link to article


The Beatles - Revolution



Warpy

(111,419 posts)
33. 160 years, plus or minus a few
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 01:01 PM
Aug 2023

They had laws against child soldiers back then, but the kid was stubborn as hell and wouldn't leave. I guess they figured handing him a drum and keeping him in the rear would keep him out of the way and safer than just having him anywhere near the front. He was likely more mascot than anything else until he'd been wounded by shrapnel, issued a cut down gun so he could defend himself.

He most likely got a special enlistment when it finally happened, a kid who had been wounded twice having earned his place. Besides, he just wouldn't quit and go home.

I know it's hard for us to wrap our heads around, but that's how a lot of poor kids found their professions, they just showed up and wouldn't leave. Child labor was the norm and some children wanted to choose something besides dangerous mining and factory work.

Don't blame the parents, they likely had so many mouths to feed that when one disappeared into work, they were grateful, especially if the kids sent them some of his/her income.

Liberty Belle

(9,538 posts)
3. I know a descendant of another Shiloh drummer boy and have seen the drum.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 10:20 AM
Aug 2023

It has a peephole in it with Civil War scenes inside. That drummer boy was named Philo Case.

The descendant,now about 90, owns Hatfield Creek Winery in Ramona. Every Fourth of July and Memorial Day, he takes the drum out of his case and plays it. Amazing.

https://www.eastcountymagazine.org/memorial-day-remember

Aristus

(66,509 posts)
5. That look says: "Yeah. You want to secede and keep your enslaved people?
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 10:24 AM
Aug 2023

I got something for your asses!..."

Tough little guy.

intheflow

(28,516 posts)
10. I'd heard of him before, for a library program I put together called Kid History.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:16 AM
Aug 2023

What I find disturbing about this is, where were his parents or guardians? A 9-year-old runs away and his family didn't search for him? I'm guessing he was able to be so ruthless and such a fighter at such a young age because he was severely abused at home.

intheflow

(28,516 posts)
35. I read a little more and his mother was killed in a train accident.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 01:08 PM
Aug 2023

But you act like no one ever reported a missing person before the internet, or most grieved parents would have joyfully reunited with their kid when the kid became famous, so they finally knew where to find him.

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,492 posts)
12. Child soldiers are an abomination.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:26 AM
Aug 2023

Also some misinformation in that tweet; most sources agree he wasn't at Shiloh.

3Hotdogs

(12,456 posts)
16. Then there is the movie about the 12 year old who enlisted in the navy during We2.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:35 AM
Aug 2023

When his age was found, he was court martial end and tossed in the brig.

carpetbagger

(4,392 posts)
18. My grandfather went into the army at 15.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:42 AM
Aug 2023

Got kicked out when they found out his age. The next week he enlisted in the Navy. When he died, we had to decide what to put on his grave marker, since he was army, navy, wartime merchantarine, and wartime coast guard.

Staph

(6,256 posts)
25. It was made into a movie!
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:23 PM
Aug 2023

Or, technically, into a two part show on the Wonderful World of Disney, back in 1963. "Johnny Shiloh" stared Kevin Corcoran, one of Disney's reliable and capable child actors. I remember watching it as a child.


brewens

(13,646 posts)
15. The last Civil War widow died in 2020. We are probably down to a handful of people
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 11:29 AM
Aug 2023

that actually knew Civil War veterans. Some more might remember meeting one when they were a little kid.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War_widows_who_survived_into_the_21st_century

Martin68

(22,945 posts)
26. I really don't know whether a child should be in combat.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:25 PM
Aug 2023

If so, why do we have labor laws to protect children?

robbob

(3,539 posts)
28. Nobody is saying children should be fighting in wars!
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:49 PM
Aug 2023

This is a story that happened. And a remarkable one at that. I don’t think anyone here is presenting this as a model of how we could restructure our combat units.

intheflow

(28,516 posts)
36. The Civil War was 40-50 years before anyone thought seriously about child labor laws.
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 01:11 PM
Aug 2023

Back then, they thought "infants" (children under 8) were children, and then everyone older were just kind of mini-adults. This is before compulsory public schools became the law of the country, and many in some places the only schooling you could get had to be bought or was through a religious lens, and often both.

Martin Eden

(12,882 posts)
29. Shiloh and Chickamauga were two of the most savage battles
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 12:49 PM
Aug 2023

Little "Johnny" Clem was a very valiant young man!

Snackshack

(2,541 posts)
37. An entire life...
Thu Aug 3, 2023, 01:17 PM
Aug 2023

Devoted to the service of country and others. I don’t get the impression he viewed it in any other way.

I have read about him before. It is an amazing story. How at his age he was able to stand his ground inside the maelstrom of chaos war is and play his drum is incredible.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»A wild Civil War story fo...