General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhat's your opinion of teachers who cross the picket line?
Last edited Sun Nov 25, 2012, 01:05 AM - Edit history (1)
Both the support and faculty unions at the university I attend have been going on rotating strikes these past few weeks. They have been striking on random days, giving 72 hours notice as per law. We've missed about 4 days of classes so far these past several weeks. I support teachers unions 100% but I have to say that this IS fucking up our semester, especially for those students who are already struggling.
Now the vast majority of teachers don't cross the picket line. Whether it's the support union OR teachers unions. Many join the line fact, some even in support of the support staff strikes. However I've had one teacher make it clear to us that he doesn't agree with this strike (there is nothing special about this one just asking for better pay and benefits and they AREN'T overpaid compared to other colleges) and is making a point of being at the school during his office and lab hours. Of course he isn't teaching a class because that would further penalize the students who don't show up. But he want's to make it clear he will be there to help any students who decide to come in, crossing the picket line to do so, and want help. I can sympathize with wanting to help students during this period but crossing the picket line is a real dick move IMHO.
I actually like the guy and think he's an ok teacher but I'm starting to think he may be a right winger which would be too bad. I'm not all that convinced he cares about the students because while he mentioned how unfair it is to the students he ALSO told a story about how the last time there was a strike he just went off and did some extra contract work to get extra pay during the strike.
What's your opinion?
One thing to note about this university is that they put extra emphasis on drawing teachers from industry, the school is very job / business oriented and works very closely with industry both in student placement as well as in class design. This means that many of the teachers don't necessarily have an academic background and there may be a higher percentage of right wingers.
Mothdust
(133 posts)Especially of teachers! The only people who do are the administrators. Everyone else would be shunned. Teachers or students who crossed would be a-holes and substitutes should have their tires slashed : ) I hope no one is offendedn but that's life in the big city.
Locut0s
(6,154 posts)so it surprised me this teacher said this. However from asking around, my father is a teacher, I know that some few teachers DO do it. But yeah I think most would be shunned for doing so.
Mothdust
(133 posts)Everyone knows that when they accept a union job and pay that is based upon the hard fight and work of others who came before them to secure improved working conditions and academic freedom. They know that every time they cash their paycheck. Each employee is responsible to save for possibility of a strike. Those who don't are basically selfish and irresponsible.
Shrike47
(6,913 posts)Either they can't afford not to go in or their contract requires crossing. (I had to cross at my last job because as a matter of law we were not allowed to strike and we each had professional obligations to a different authority that was not part of the strike.)
We could, however, and did go out and walk the picket line at lunch.
Edweird
(8,570 posts)Locut0s
(6,154 posts)Edweird
(8,570 posts)They shouldn't.
B Calm
(28,762 posts)When you get members like this ass kisser, it only weakens the union.
newfie11
(8,159 posts)Lightbulb_on
(315 posts)... than their personal benefits.
That is more of the "old school" stereotype though.
Riley18
(1,127 posts)because I strongly support the education of ALL students. If those teachers who think they are somehow more of a teacher because they cross a picket line had studied Labor History, they would understand that supporting the union is standing with a stronger educational system that works for every student not just for the privleliged few.
Lightbulb_on
(315 posts)However, as per the OP this specific strike isn't about educating all students.
They aren't mutually exclusive, education and personal benefit, but each individual has to choose which is most important to them.
Riley18
(1,127 posts)not teaching since all students are not present. To say this one teacher is only concerned for the students implies we know his true motive. The same could be said for the striking teachers. I can say from personal experience that if my salary was more adequate, I would be a better teacher. When teachers have to work second jobs to pay their bills there is less time devoted to planning and instruction.
Locut0s
(6,154 posts)He mentioned how unfair it is to the students BUT he also told a story about how the last time there was a strike he just went off and did some extra contract work to get extra pay during the strike.
Kingofalldems
(38,496 posts)Even lower than zombies here at DU.
Riley18
(1,127 posts)This teacher is not accomplishing anything - no students there so he is just announcing he does not respect his colleagues.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)joined us. As a matter of fact since we shut the entire university down for three days most of the department managers and the Grad Student Instructors joined us too. The construction workers refused to cross the picket lines too. One union member stood all by herself as the line at one of the off-campus construction sites for the three days and manages to convince the hard hats to honor her line.
Locut0s
(6,154 posts)things get really bad for both sides. Not sure how long ours is going to last but they are starting to escalate it slowly and there's precedent for a 2 week long strike (some years back they had one).
Sancho
(9,070 posts)faculty love their jobs and students, but the best thing to do is get a fair contract so that education can continue.
Smarmie Doofus
(14,498 posts)Except we're not supposed to say "d---" anymore 'cause it's sexist.
I think.
Chloe3
(4 posts)The unions actually have the students', teachers', and all workers' best interest at heart. The same cannot be said of those only looking at money and trying to give bonuses to a few while the rest are left to live on less and less every year.
mike_c
(36,281 posts)...and was our campus strike coordinator during the run up to a strike this fall, which was averted at the last minute by a contract settlement, so I've thought about this problem a lot. I recognize that we have colleagues who will cross the picket line for a variety of reasons, so of them admirable, some not so much. My philosophy for dealing with this was to maintain strict traffic control for campus access, and ask colleagues crossing the picket lines to join us, but to acknowledge their rights to cross the line if they wished-- just at a very slow and aggravating pace. We practiced traffic control at the CSU East Bay strike a year ago and while those wishing to cross the picket probably did so-- staff were explicitly told they MUST be at work, for example-- it took them a LONG time to get to the front of the line and make it onto campus. The traffic jams at each campus entrance were epic.
Ultimately, I was glad we settled, in part because I wasn't looking forward to dealing with the few colleagues I anticipated would insist on crossing the picket line. Like you, I think it's a dick move.
Locut0s
(6,154 posts)RagAss
(13,832 posts)They're Fucking Scum !