General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCNN: Staggering Poll Numbers from Latino Voters on Trump
Harry Enten: Latinos have turned on Trump in massive, massive numbers.
spanone
(141,609 posts)Exp
(954 posts)republianmushroom
(22,325 posts)Martin Eden
(15,626 posts)I don't want to depreciate them too much because we need every ally we can get, but really no excuse for any sensible adult to vote for The Felon in 2024.
UTUSN
(77,795 posts)Cha
(319,067 posts)the light.
Too bad they should have known better.
UTUSN
(77,795 posts)immediate subsistence (not historical introversion). But the under-awareness goes both ways: Black Americans and LBJ zeroed-in on *voting* while the standard insight is from BEGALA's (not Red) but "non-voting."
LBJ and, yes, the BUSHes "knew" them, not most of the Eastern Libs.
Cha
(319,067 posts)shocked that they changed.. and for that.
Thank you.
UTUSN
(77,795 posts)LBJ & the BUSHes are in sort of a different category from "charisma" - more like, those peeps *LIKING* them/Latinos. Down to earth, acknowledging. A smile and a hug go a long way.
Will add the personal distance within the Democratic relating to the FDR-age-old Hispanic constituency (but worse in Wingnuttiness) - during the Bill-Monica thing, Bill went to the Hispanic Caucus and was greeted by them with *WILD* yelling support, yet Bill tamped it down, told them to sit and settle down, whereas he related more to other ethnic constituencies. And in post-coup 2000 when Al GORE went on SNL, he did a skit where his peeve against campaigning was having to go on the Spanish language networks featuring stereotype Latinos mugging and jumping around and having to hold a Chihuahua dog. ----- Disconnects going on there.
Here's a pic of W. Shrub relating after Katrina when Mexicans from Mexico crossed into U.S. to provide aid - imagine the caravan crossing what they considered "their" former territory putting aside the intervening unpleasantness. The point is relating, human sincerity, acceptance.

Cha
(319,067 posts)UTUSN.. I appreciate it.
We Dems Do Need to Build Mightily on the Trust We've been shown in the latest Election from Latino Voters.
Scrivener7
(59,522 posts)jfz9580m
(17,188 posts)It is the greatest(!) of all bonds.
democratsruletheday
(1,880 posts)really like everyone I work with. But...they have blind spots politically. Some from religion and some from misogyny. Harsh, but true.
jfz9580m
(17,188 posts)Dont seem to get at first. People are the same and that cuts both ways.
If it means that racist shit about IQ etc is garbage, it also means that in all groups, self interest aside, the same tiresome Magat mentality exists - religiosity, sexism, suspicion of science along with the wish to exploit it for toys, zero concern for earth etc.
I am a non-white liberal (well more left these days than liberal). I have had the flipped white liberal syndrome at times and felt more tolerant towards Magats who are not of Indian origin (I am Indian), figuring that okay I dont know whats going on there. Whereas I can peg the Ramaswamy types easily.
OAITW r.2.0
(32,133 posts)We always have known that the Republican agenda is pitting one group of citizens against another. The smaller the group - like -sex change gender citizens - the easier to demonize.
maxsolomon
(38,718 posts)plus Abortion.
Scrivener7
(59,522 posts)maxsolomon
(38,718 posts)I hate his guts and wish he'd died 40 years ago, but he has Charisma.
Charisma is what wins elections - it persuades the low-information voters.
Scrivener7
(59,522 posts)calling it appeal to racism and misogyny. The effect on the recipient is the same.
maxsolomon
(38,718 posts)Charisma is what allows MFer to make his appeal to racism and misogyny (and corruption and cheating and cruelty) appealing.
/kəˈrizmə/
noun
1.
compelling attractiveness or charm that can inspire devotion in others.
haele
(15,399 posts)The Swaggering, Wealthy (appearing) Masculine force that supposedly can't be stopped and brings luck in love and gambling.
Cartel Leaders and *rump cultivated that appearance. But they're really just thugs.
Scrivener7
(59,522 posts)thought crime
(1,564 posts)among a bunch of Omega men.
dickthegrouch
(4,516 posts)IMHO it's much more likely Kompromat.
He could only be charming to those who are already obscenely wealthy, and jealous of keeping it.
He's only attractive to people who want to emulate his lawless and responsibility-shirking ways.
Utter degenerate, despicable, deplorable, and many other non-charismatic adjectives apply.
How can so many people be attracted to that?
Coventina
(29,731 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(2,302 posts)I will vote for Donald Trump. Doesnt sound so good and catchy now.
ffr
(23,398 posts)The way I look at it, it doesn't matter how much they've turned on tRump. Some of them were all too willing participants in getting other Latinos to vote for the felon guy over the let's put our house in order and continue Bidenomics lady in blue.
I'm all too sure that come mid-terms, they'll have another change of heart and fall in love with the GOP again. The same GOP that has never liked Latinos! But hey, I'm not Latino, so I cannot say what attraction there would ever be to such an abusive relationship as the one presented by history.
OAITW r.2.0
(32,133 posts)Problem is, you can't differentiate the Latino population by political preference, They are all targets of Trump's ICE.
orangecrush
(30,256 posts)?si=Dbvhb6X9bfC4Xuyy
Red Mountain
(2,343 posts)but they've got another 3 years+ of purgatory to endure.
I saw some Trump acceptance in undocumented (unofficially.....grandfathered in) coworkers I found odd during his first reelection campaign.....never figured out the source but it has to have been Spanish language TV, radio or the church.
They can't vote but I bet the attitudes have changed.
Susan Calvin
(2,438 posts)Moostache
(11,178 posts)I am sorry and do not wish to state racially stupid things, but how is this POSSIBLE? There was no doubt before the election last year which candidate was going to at least TRY to do more for the undocumented and the minorities in this nation. There was ZERO DOUBT which person on the ballot was a racist pig, a clown, a charlatan that actually said stupid shit like "They're eating the dogs, they're eating the cats..." AND THAT MOTHERFUCKER GOT 50% MORE support from LATINOS THAN RIGHT NOW???
Seriously, I am 100% curious and unfortunately I do not have a large Latin population or friend group to ask, but WHATTHE ACTUAL FUCK WERE THE PEOPLE WHO VOTED FOR HIM SMOKING?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?
Cirsium
(3,943 posts)The worst. "They???" "Little dudes?" "Crawling back?" They "have a lot to make up for?" "They've got another 3 years+ of purgatory to endure?"
Racist and elitist. I know this is going to kick over the proverbial beehive, but seriously folks, reconsider this FAFO crap, and stop looking at people as voting blocs based on race. People are people. The Democratic party has betrayed immigrants over and over again. The war on immigrants has always been a bipartisan affair and was going on long before Trump.
Coventina
(29,731 posts)That shit dont play.
Cirsium
(3,943 posts)What "bothsiderism?" The war on immigrants has been a bipartisan affair. The bothsiderism idea means excusing what Republicans do because "Democrats do it too!" I am not excusing anyone for the way immigrants have been and are being treated. Nor am I defending or apologizing for the reign of terror by the Trump administration. But nor will I excuse the forty-six Democrats who crossed party lines to vote for the Laken Riley Act at the outset of Trump's second term. Will you?
Coventina
(29,731 posts)And Latinos support of Trump.
A man who said he was going to be shitty to immigrants if he was re-elected. A man who was shitty to immigrants his first term. They ignored the evidence. Thats on them 100%
Cirsium
(3,943 posts)Latinos are not some monolithic group, and "Latino" does not equal "immigrant."
Coventina
(29,731 posts)Then maybe you should have started with that instead of calling DUers racist.
Cirsium
(3,943 posts)I don't think polls of population groups on specific issues are not valid topics. I think they can be misleading, too.
Yes, several of the comments are racist. That does not mean that I said that "DUers are racist." That is the trick the right wingers and white supremacists use to shut down discussions. Any criticism of racist ideas being expressed is met with "how dare you call me racist," as though pointing out racist comments was the real evil, rather than the racist comments themselves.
Beyond that, blaming the voters for the catastrophic failure by national leadership class in all aspects of society is weak. Relishing the suffering of others- "FAFO" - is distinctly illiberal.
All of that said, I think that the people who voted for Trump - we could look at white women, for example, if we want to talk ethnic groups - are ignorant, cruel, or both and I think MAGA needs to be utterly destroyed. Mass insanity rules. If we want to look at groups of people, the only sane group in the country, in my opinion, is African Americans, especially African American women. White supremacy and patriarchy have severely impacted the critical thinking skills of most people in the country. Racism distorts everything - politics, economics, social relations - and that irrationality is like a virus, infecting people's views on everything.
Coventina
(29,731 posts)Yes, white people are racist, I would never argue against that.
So are other ethnic groups as well. There actually is a lot of racism in the Hispanic community.
Hence the FAFO attitude by those who were desperately trying to get people to understand they were voting against their self-interest.
Now, we're all paying for their racism.
There is real anger and frustration that certain idiot groups (not monolithically, but significantly) did not listen and doomed all of us.
I'm not ready to make nice.
I have been put in real danger by their idiocy.
So, yeah, I'm pissed off.
Cirsium
(3,943 posts)Yes, I blame the people in power for the problems caused by the people in power. Others want to blame the people without power.
jfz9580m
(17,188 posts)I dont disagree with some of what you said. I am not much for Fafo glee. The only glee I feel is when someone like Larry Summers goes down.
But it doesnt have to be racism versus sexism. The reality is that there are a lot of sexist or machismo attitudes in non-white groups as well as white.
Just as I dont care for the Fafo stuff now,
I didnt like the Karen crap. I dont mean the odd throw-away remark. Everyone has those.
But when most of your politics is about mob piling on, thats lame. Not a fan of politics playing out like athletics.
I have faced a lot of harassment from a subset of nonwhite men with the same creepy attitudes Trump, Vance etc have. But they would probably use bs like white feminism or Western Feminism to force their cultural agendas when needed.
Look, there are a lot of assholes and creeps in all groups and racism like classism is obviously structurally built in.
But there is certainly far too much male creep solidarity and that is an unambiguous factor in Trump support along with the racist Maha momfluencers types you rightly castigate.
I myself dont like the face eating leopard stuff much. I get where you are coming from.
But there is a strain of misogyny on even the left that owes to this perception of women as the enemy.
I have been dealing with a lot of harassment (I am not in the US) from a relatively small but super creepy group of nonwhite men. They are the exceptions not the rule. But it has had the effect of tilting my attention away from racism and towards sexism and religious backwardness.
There is far too much tolerance of men like that on the left for long stretches followed by the inevitable backlash. Which then again becomes a mob spectacle. The backlash against that follows then etc. This wearisome cycle has to end.
Surely we can do better than this by now and start identifying the way divide and rule works and not throw away the rights of the consistently progressive to keep appealing to the fickle with few principles who are batted this way or that this easily.
Men disproportionately have more power in society and the men in power are fueling a cycle dispossession via tech.
For the big tent to work, womens rights have to be taken more seriously than they are. I saw this mind boggling stupid Jacobin writer Ben Wray casually refer to abortion rights as popular. As if thats all that matters.
It is blind to ignore how much misogyny or just plain backwardness there is across the board. Thats a big driver in all this.
I agree about African Americans consistently being one of the sanest demographics I have seen and that inspite of being pretty embattled.
Its actually a small subset that drives the worst dynamics, but they polarize everyone else and distort things. Its bloody tiresome.
Its also hard to explain these things so they hit the actual targets and not random people who take it personally and get creep polarized.
We are far from civilized underneath the surface which the state of the planet, factory farming and other issues we have collectively decided apparently dont matter at all attest to.
I am myself not much into herding and influence. I wonder how many cycles of this people need. We are a bit of an asshole species and that is the root problem. We bully other species and the planet and each other when we can. It forces the less conflict oriented among us to learn from Merrick Garland.
Indeed, it doesnt have to be racism versus sexism and there are a lot of sexist or machismo attitudes in non-white groups as well as white. No question. It doesnt have to be racism versus class, either.
The descendants of immigrants from Greece and Italy have been folded into whiteness, But descendants of immigrants to Latin America from Spain and Portugal have not been folded into whiteness in the US. When people talk about "Latinos" as some monolithic bloc presumed to be non-European - not white - they are ignorant of the basic history. Latin America was conquered and pillaged by Europeans and power is still largely in the hands of their descendants, while immigrants to the US are disproportionately poor people of various indigenous ethnicities. People conflated non-European with immigrant with Latino, and threw in a little "we know what is best for you" paternalism. I objected to that, and called it racist and elitist.
There are owners of bordellos, plantations, gambling casinos, sweat shops and other exploitative activities who fled to escape popular regimes and come to the US, the most obvious example being the deeply reactionary Cuban American community. Most immigrants are victims of the owners of bordellos, plantations, gambling casinos, sweat shops and other exploitative activities who fled to escape oppression and come to the US, people from Haiti, Guatemala, and Somalia for example.
jfz9580m
(17,188 posts)It should be its own post. I shall follow your posts
.
I have complicated personal and general feelings about these topics.
I am Indian, educated in the US. But I came back to the global south after a conflict with my deeply unpleasant last employer in the US-an Si Valley connected hell.
I first came across these differences when I read Marjorie Morningstar in the early 2000s when I was in grad school in the US.
Herman Wouk is pretty conservative, but I I love his writing for all that. Even from The Caine Mutiny, a work of his I read earlier while in India, I grasped in a visceral way for the first time that the Irish or Italian American immigrant experience was very different from the Jewish American experience which was different from the WASP experience. It would not stop there of course - Eastern European versus Western European, class and generational differences with each group.
Had I not been an avid reader long before the net, on the surface it would have seemed like all groups which are white, not recognizing the differences even within.
It is that way everywhere. I grapple with how people dont seem to get the double edged sword which is recognition that we are all the same viscerally.
If on the one hand it means that there are no real inferiorities and there is real injustice, it is also the sobering recognition that a built in bias projecting an inference that presently worse off groups would be any more decent to the planet or to other lifeforms (whom we brutally colonize (look at factory farming)), is almost certainly a myth.
I have always felt like the odd one out in my own community abroad- technically Indian or Indian American except I never felt it. Wherever I am, route and rote stuff aside, the person always seems to matter more than the community they are from.
If thats atomization I dont dislike it. Its a broader notion of what constitutes human kinship.
My community often is other prickly and difficult people ..lol. I was thinking with distaste while reading this vapid and awful momfluencer Jessica Kraus or another really awful moron Yoni Applebaum, how in different ways these people package dark, self-centred and vapidly evil ideas under a saccharine narrative of community in their differnt ways. Kraus is embracing neo nazis while Applebaum a sort of steely industrial Yimbyism.
Now they want to use to affordability to hijack Mamdanis success. Its something I ponder when I read the writing of people on the left whom I respect like Yasha Levine or many of the Current Affairs writers (Nathan Robinson, Samuel Miller MacDonald etc).
My own relationship with human society has had a Boo Radley quality to it. I do feel mostly like the Scary Crazy Old Catlady peering out at the world from my window. But well..I wouldnt say I am scary.
I really support solidarity where it is not coupled with an expectation of finding it heart warming that species crass trajectory over the planet disregards every other species with a fraudulent narrative of man versus nature or one with deeply conservative faux bucolic underpinnings attacking parts of modern human life that are not the issue-solitude over herding not loneliness.
Its puzzling since even with well intentioned people on the left the planet is viewed as just this lump that is a backdrop.
Anyway thank you for your posts. Thats the best aspect of discussion on DU.
Its funny. I avoid areas crowded with not so much ai slop as the slop that is very much a product of the human brain. Now that the web is losing its appeal as an ai and influencer filled fraud, I who never really saw it before as anything but a very casual entertainment tool find some use in it.
The United States 2-party system is Bipolar. It is understandable in one way-the GoP and its adherents are past hope to some extent.
Sadly that mentality exists the planet over and in groups that are nonwhite, poor and technically decent enough, but trapped in this overly herd like mindset. I dont mean it like elite patronisation so much as an expectation from all of us rich or poor to open our minds to how awful this way of life is
I consider it rather unevolved even when not the traditionally fancy arrogant oppressor to not examine assumptions about the world. There is a certain coldness to nonhuman life on the left that distresses me the same way this Fafo stuff does. You dont have to be fancy to find it gloomy making.
I find the Jacobin style rather chilling and reminiscent of Liu Cixins worldview on progress and survival of the fittest. The right is hopeless. So it is a relief that the more humane left that doesnt have this almost equally automated and asshole version of a gleaming and creepy machines future exists. Because thats a style of thinking that cheerfully would exploit immigrants like pawns.
As a species humans are currently enacting a version of dominion theology on the planet.
Sorry to ramble on. I liked your posts. I agree about the exploitation. And the patronisation.. but it is sad that the ideas disseminated even to intelligent people but early and assiduously fed by this machine are so terrible.
My own collective problem solving intuition told me to not have children ..lol.. so thats where I think the species is headed unless we change track soon.
Bristlecone
(11,111 posts)He is annoying as hell.
This is in no way a dig on the post. I click on the guy all the time in my own, but he bugs me for some reason.
writes3000
(4,824 posts)róisín_dubh
(12,336 posts)Says someone on the spectrum. I don't know where he falls, but I'm neurodivergent and I have a neurodivergent step-son; stats are his thing (for my step-son, it's every video game under the sun). Harry Enten is as neurodivergent as they come. Or neurospicy, as the youths say.
I more get annoyed at how poorly his suits fit, but I rarely watch him as I don't live in the US.