Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 12:22 AM Yesterday

Best analysis of Ross' video: He switched hands with the cell phone to get his gun BEFORE he got to the front of car.

From a Threads post:


Post by @its_ilene_with_an_i
View on Threads




As he lapped her car, Jonathan switched hands with the cell phone from his right hand to his left hand so he could get his gun with his right hand. He is obviously right handed, and wanted to use his right hand for his gun. As his video shows, he did that BEFORE he ever got to the front of the car and could claim he feared for his life. He was getting his gun out to stop her from leaving, since she had started her 3 point turn to leave. She was not under arrest, she was free to leave. He had no right to even draw his gun at her, let alone shoot her 3 times in the face.

BTW, notice how the two shots he made through her driver window, point blank to her face, are edited out of his video. Did Ross make that edit? Did JD Vance?

Oh, and here's another video that points out Renee, after waiving one ICE vehicle to go past her, audibly tells the ICE guys coming at her from the silver truck, "I'm pulling out." That is when Ross freed his right hand to grab his gun. He wanted to stop her from leaving, he was not fearing for his life.


Post by @mikehootner
View on Threads


20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Best analysis of Ross' video: He switched hands with the cell phone to get his gun BEFORE he got to the front of car. (Original Post) SunSeeker Yesterday OP
This was a flat out premeditated murder. RockRaven Yesterday #1
Premeditated Murder.. Jonathan Ross is Cha Yesterday #2
Yes, I just can't get over it, and the gaslighting by Trump world about it! SunSeeker Yesterday #3
I can't either... I read most reports Cha Yesterday #5
When I watched the Ring clip earlier I thought it was odd that his upper body was leaning in toward the hood of her car JudyM Yesterday #4
He murdered her. sheshe2 Yesterday #6
And ICE emptied his house of all evidence--probably taking it to the burn pit with the Epstein files. SunSeeker Yesterday #8
Yup, watched that. sheshe2 Yesterday #10
It appears to me he had his gun hand free before getting near the car Kaleva Yesterday #7
No, the reflection shows he is holding it in his RIGHT hand, before he gets around the car. SunSeeker Yesterday #11
At the 8 sec mark, it appears to be in his left hand Kaleva Yesterday #12
No. Do you see where his left hand moves across the frame and takes the phone from his right hand? SunSeeker 23 hrs ago #13
You are correct. I was thrown off by the mirror effect. Kaleva 20 hrs ago #18
I think he was planning on this since he allegedly Tribetime Yesterday #9
Yeah. And for someone who 'was previously dragged', he doesn't seem to have any fear of crossing Mc Mike 17 hrs ago #20
"Hell is empty, and all the devils are here" Woodycall 23 hrs ago #14
More likely... Hope22 22 hrs ago #15
She was even told to go Figarosmom 22 hrs ago #16
Yes, another illegal command by ICE. And that one got her killed. SunSeeker 22 hrs ago #17
Thank you. Kid Berwyn 17 hrs ago #19

RockRaven

(18,739 posts)
1. This was a flat out premeditated murder.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 12:48 AM
Yesterday

And that psycho was making a snuff film as a trophy.

Cha

(316,891 posts)
2. Premeditated Murder.. Jonathan Ross is
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 12:51 AM
Yesterday

an ICE Cold Blooded Killer.. and now he's running Scared like a chicken livered Rancid Rabid Rat.

Mahalo for this, SunSeeker

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
3. Yes, I just can't get over it, and the gaslighting by Trump world about it!
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:03 AM
Yesterday

Hopefully people will start to believe their own eyes and ears.

Cha

(316,891 posts)
5. I can't either... I read most reports
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:28 AM
Yesterday

that are here on DU. I won't read what the Homicidal Maniacs have to say, though. I'm overwhelmed with grief enough.

I want justice for Renee Nicole Good. Truth in Action!

JudyM

(29,570 posts)
4. When I watched the Ring clip earlier I thought it was odd that his upper body was leaning in toward the hood of her car
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:24 AM
Yesterday

with feet back as she started to pull forward; this explanation of leaning in to get a shot at her is just horrific, but seems to match up. Personally, I think he got pissed at the uppity lesbians and acted out ... wouldn't be surprised if they all chatted about that before exiting their vehicles... it seems like the other ice agents got out of their vehicle ready to physically pull her out of the car... there was no "would you please exit the car," he just started pulling the door open. And with this cretin gang, that would scare me enough to try to drive away, too.

The "f'ing bitch" comment as he walks away (and then proceeds to drive away from the scene) is evidence of his state of mind being depraved indifference, at a minimum, more likely animus.

Would be hard, maybe impossible, to prove that this was homophobic violence, but it feels that way to me. I feel bad for her wife... probably suffering about having talked that way to him, trusting she was safe from a violent reaction. But these dudes are unhinged and primed for aggression by the dictator..

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
8. And ICE emptied his house of all evidence--probably taking it to the burn pit with the Epstein files.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:52 AM
Yesterday
Federal agents, some wearing balaclavas and half-face masks, were seen removing belongings from the empty home of ICE agent Jonathan Ross following the fatal shooting of Renee Good in Minneapolis. The items taken included a computer tower and personal items packed into large plastic storage bins.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-15449879/federal-agents-guns-swarm-jonathan-ross-home-hiding-minneapolis.html#:~:text=Wearing%20balaclavas%20and%20half%2Dface,husband%20opened%20fire%20on%20Good.

Looks like they took his Gadsden flag too...anything that would reveal him to be the murderous right wing nut bag that he is.

Kaleva

(40,202 posts)
7. It appears to me he had his gun hand free before getting near the car
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:51 AM
Yesterday

One can see his reflection on Renee’s vehicle holding his phone in his left hand as he begins his walk around the SUV

One thing that is clear in Ross’s video is that Renee was turning the steering wheel to her right before moving forward. If it had been her intention to run over Ross, she would have kept the steering wheel straight or turned it towards the left. Also, I can’t say for sure but it appears to me that Renee was looking to the right as she started moving foward. I would think that Renee would have focused on Ross if she had intended to run over Ross.

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
11. No, the reflection shows he is holding it in his RIGHT hand, before he gets around the car.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:58 AM
Yesterday

Watch the video again. Remember, the reflection is like a mirror.

Kaleva

(40,202 posts)
12. At the 8 sec mark, it appears to be in his left hand
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 02:05 AM
Yesterday

Based on what I see from his reflection At the 17 sec mark, one clearly sees that the phone is in Ross’s left hand

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
13. No. Do you see where his left hand moves across the frame and takes the phone from his right hand?
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 02:27 AM
23 hrs ago

Last edited Sat Jan 10, 2026, 04:11 AM - Edit history (1)



That was after you see the reflection. I don't have a seconds stamp in the video I'm watching in the OP, so I'm not sure what you're talking about. I'm looking at the post by @its_ilene_with_an_i on Threads.




But here is the reflection:



Sure looks like the mirror image of the right hand to me.

And here is a Youtube video from Jen Psaki, which has seconds marks.

Look at the 0:13 mark. That is his left hand dangling by his side as he is reflected in the side of the car walking towards the back. Remember, when looking at a reflection, what is looking back at you is a reverse image, like in a mirror.





Regardless, that is definitely his left hand passing in front of his camera eye to grab his cell phone out of his right hand before he turns to go in front of the car. Here it is at 0:24 of the Jen Psaki video. Now that is not a reflection but the actual direct image of his left hand as it enters the camera frame from the left to grab the phone.






You see that, correct?

Kaleva

(40,202 posts)
18. You are correct. I was thrown off by the mirror effect.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 05:53 AM
20 hrs ago

Which you told me about in your previous post.

Tribetime

(7,063 posts)
9. I think he was planning on this since he allegedly
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 01:53 AM
Yesterday

Was dragged six months ago , and he thought in his mind , if this ever happens again , he would do something like this to justify what he did

Mc Mike

(9,251 posts)
20. Yeah. And for someone who 'was previously dragged', he doesn't seem to have any fear of crossing
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 08:57 AM
17 hrs ago

in front of this vehicle, very close to it, TWICE, on his own footage.

Hope22

(4,478 posts)
15. More likely...
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 03:24 AM
22 hrs ago

We are already in hell! What is more hellish than a country ripped into madness by ignorant hateful souls. It feels like we are in line at the furnace. I’ve thought this before but to be clear we can’t get carried away with the idea. There’s still a bit of hope that things could change.

SunSeeker

(57,592 posts)
17. Yes, another illegal command by ICE. And that one got her killed.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 03:33 AM
22 hrs ago

She had every right to be there, it was her neighborhood and she was not blocking ICE vehicles. But she decided to comply with that command and leave, which triggered nutbag Jonathan Ross.

Kid Berwyn

(23,011 posts)
19. Thank you.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 08:45 AM
17 hrs ago
She was not under arrest, she was free to leave. He had no right to even draw his gun at her, let alone shoot her 3 times in the face.
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Best analysis of Ross' vi...