General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe abhorrent power of the photograph of a 5-year-old held by ICE
An image like this could once change history. Can one still?
School officials in Minnesota say that the prekindergarten student was used as bait by ICE, in an apparent attempt to gain access to the adults inside the private house where he once lived. That act, the use of a boy too young to understand the political game in which he became a pawn, mirrors in a perverse and deeply disturbing way the power of the photograph. The photograph stirs empathy and compassion, the same emotions that ICE agents apparently used to entice adults into making themselves vulnerable to capture.
...
A universal moral image works because at some level we share a universal moral conscience. There are certain things that, when seen, compel us to action in a way that transcends all other concerns.
It is universal because the suffering of a child cuts across race, nationality and ideological divisions. It is universal because it takes precedence over all other concerns. A child in distress demands action now. The world stops for a moment, and decent people do what is absolutely, immediately necessary.
Among the most deeply distressing things this image represents is the instrumentalization of compassion. ICE didnt place a box of candy or a $100 bill on the front stoop of the house, hoping to tempt people out. They used a child to appeal to the most innate and essentially human impulse to show care, concern and protect to capture those who care for him. They weaponized decency, the last incorruptible defense we have against absolute misery and evil.
https://archive.is/LwbMg#selection-227.0-227.65
No words...

littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)SAID NO ONE EVER.
Cherokee100
(441 posts)This picture, should be the rallying flag, for us all. (I know I didn't phrase that well but I hope you get my drift). It should be on all posters, t-shirts, caps, etc:.
Mr. Evil
(3,444 posts)and so sad all at the same time.
Conjuay
(2,937 posts)Wait until people like Liam hits their twenties.
-And I cant blame him for whatever he becomes
Blue Owl
(58,339 posts)PatSeg
(52,342 posts)I've made his image my profile pic on Facebook. There but for fortune people.
littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)He is being such a good boy. Just look at his little face! He doesn't seem to be wearing any gloves. I can't stand it!
brer cat
(27,404 posts)would deport every ICE agent along with the puppy killer.
littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)I wish I knew how to help him and his family.
PatSeg
(52,342 posts)I just want to pick him up and comfort him.
Posting it as my profile pic has generated some discussions though.
malaise
(293,502 posts)They live among us
littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)Goonch
(4,300 posts)
FakeNoose
(40,419 posts)I'm so sorry Liam! When I was 5 years old in the 1950's, our country was nothing like this...
We used to be the "good guys."
littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)malaise
(293,502 posts)littlemissmartypants
(32,029 posts)GiqueCee
(3,500 posts)... both he and his father are legal residents of this country, yet they are still being detained somewhere in Texas.
The magnitude of ICE's evil can only be measured in astronomical terms. I wish every soulless scumbag associated with this travesty a slow, agonizing death, alone and despised by everyone who ever had the misfortune to meet them. Especially Miller, Homan, Noem, and Bovino.
Johnny2X2X
(23,728 posts)They are legal asylum seekers who entered the country through a legit port of entry and have a case pending.
We are dealing with pure evil and when/if the country returns to sanity, every single one of these monsters needs to face justice.
Dwild
(15 posts)Emile
(40,958 posts)Skittles
(169,906 posts)there are people who call themselves Christian who look at him and think illegal
gulliver
(13,760 posts)It's especially bad now that images are so easy to create and manipulate.
You can't look at the image of this child and not have your heart tell you, "Whatever this is, it's no good." Then, a lot of people will look for a narrative that makes it look as bad as possible. A lot of people will look for a narrative that makes it as good as possible. "Fact" sources oblige by providing evidence of varying reliability and slant.
Best bet is to just have a good solid world model and model of human nature.
usonian
(23,795 posts)These two people, merged into one, are the cause of all this woe.
To hide their crimes, they unleash hundreds of other crimes.

Trumpstein.
orangecrush
(28,846 posts)I can take much more of this.
North Coast Lawyer
(237 posts)Just when you thought Trump/MAGA/ICE couldn't get any lower they do. Today I'm ashamed to be an American.
AverageOldGuy
(3,429 posts)The time for comments is done. It's time to shoot.
JT45242
(3,879 posts)How could anyone not look at that and not SHOUT... THIS IS WRONG!!
California Kid
(60 posts)Forking iceholes...
intheozone
(1,132 posts)picture and let it go viral! All of this deranged, inhuman behavior is being driven by his adolescent wet dreams of an only white america. The man needs to get the fuck out of our government!
Ocelot II
(129,466 posts)(I'm pretty amazed that he has any, considering what had to be done to create them.) But if you're a true Nazi you don't care about kids. Miller is a dead ringer for Josef Goebbels; his wife is said to have poisoned her own six children in Hitler's bunker.
FakeNoose
(40,419 posts)I don't believe a photo has been published with his kids, and they're all under 5 years old.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katie_Miller
Katie Miller has taken the name of her husband Stephen, so she wouldn't be allowed to vote according to the Repukes. Neither would Melania Trump, for that matter. When they figure out that they'd be disenfranchising nearly ALL of their own women, I think it will put the kibosh on that stupid plan.