Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

highplainsdem

(60,486 posts)
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 07:43 PM Yesterday

NASA is about to send people to the moon -- in a spacecraft not everyone thinks is safe to fly

https://www.cnn.com/2026/01/23/science/artemis-2-orion-capsule-heat-shield

When four astronauts begin a historic trip around the moon as soon as February 6, they’ll climb aboard NASA’s 16.5-foot-wide Orion spacecraft with the understanding that it has a known flaw — one that has some experts urging the space agency not to fly the mission with humans on board. But NASA remains confident it has a handle on the problem and the vehicle can bring the crew home safely.

The issue relates to a special coating applied to the bottom part of the spacecraft, called the heat shield. It’s a crucial piece of hardware designed to protect the astronauts from extreme temperatures as they’re descending back to Earth during the final stretch of their moon-bound mission called Artemis II.

This vital part of the Orion spacecraft is nearly identical to the heat shield flown on Artemis I, an uncrewed 2022 test flight. That prior mission’s Orion vehicle returned from space with a heat shield pockmarked by unexpected damage — prompting NASA to investigate the issue.

And while NASA is poised to clear the heat shield for flight, even those who believe the mission is safe acknowledge there is unknown risk involved.

-snip-



Much more at the link.

From Futurism:
https://futurism.com/space/experts-warn-moon-rocket-nasa-heat-shield

“What they’re talking about doing is crazy,” former NASA astronaut and heat shield expert Charlie Camarda told CNN.

Camarda has since teamed up with several other NASA research scientists, calling on the agency to heed their warnings.

“We could have solved this problem way back when,” he told the broadcaster. “Instead, they keep kicking the can down the road.”

-snip-

“The reason this is such a big deal is that when the heat shield is spalling — or you have big chunks coming off — even if the vehicle isn’t destroyed, you’re right at the point of incipient failure now,” thermal protection materials expert and NASA veteran Dan Rasky told CNN. “It’s like you’re at the edge of the cliff on a foggy day.”

12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
NASA is about to send people to the moon -- in a spacecraft not everyone thinks is safe to fly (Original Post) highplainsdem Yesterday OP
This reminds me of the submarine that took 5 people to see the Titanic even when it was deemed unsafe Deuxcents Yesterday #1
I have a few suggestions for crew members... Ocelot II Yesterday #2
Trump for one. Kaleva Yesterday #6
Trump, Vance, Miller and Musk. highplainsdem Yesterday #8
Holy shit DavidDvorkin Yesterday #3
No kiddin. If this administration manages to kill 4 American Heros by the end of next month, Volaris 22 hrs ago #12
Good grief, Disaffected Yesterday #4
Heard several astronauts speak as a science teacher...this sounds like the USSR JT45242 Yesterday #5
Has anyone checked the o-rings? Xavier Breath Yesterday #7
Won't TRUMP GO WITH THEM? "Like no President has done before", blah blah blah! Jack Valentino Yesterday #9
Chief astronaut says it safe SocialDemocrat61 23 hrs ago #10
This was a grand adventure in 1968. hunter 22 hrs ago #11

Deuxcents

(25,733 posts)
1. This reminds me of the submarine that took 5 people to see the Titanic even when it was deemed unsafe
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 07:53 PM
Yesterday

They all died because of malfunctioning equipment

Volaris

(11,437 posts)
12. No kiddin. If this administration manages to kill 4 American Heros by the end of next month,
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 10:21 PM
22 hrs ago

There will be hell to pay like they haven't seen YET.

Disaffected

(6,211 posts)
4. Good grief,
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 07:57 PM
Yesterday

heat shields are decades old technology - why are they having issues with it. Same for leaky valves.

JT45242

(3,888 posts)
5. Heard several astronauts speak as a science teacher...this sounds like the USSR
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 08:00 PM
Yesterday

They all said that the largest difference between NASA and the Soviet space agency is that was cautious with human life and valued it. They knew everything would be on live TV and a catastrophic failure or death could mean the end of the agency. They were valued as scientists and people.

In the Soviet Union, cosmonauts were treated as expendible crew members like red shirts on original Star Trek. If they died, no one cared.

This sounds dangerously close to that reality.

Jack Valentino

(4,509 posts)
9. Won't TRUMP GO WITH THEM? "Like no President has done before", blah blah blah!
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 08:19 PM
Yesterday

Maybe the aliens camped on the dark side of the moon would
'take care of a problem' which we have been unable to solve.....



hunter

(40,407 posts)
11. This was a grand adventure in 1968.
Fri Jan 23, 2026, 09:57 PM
22 hrs ago

Now it's just "Hold my beer."

My grandfather was an Apollo Project engineer. He made a few bits of metal for those spacecraft and I've got his Apollo 8 medallion and other memorabilia.

Nevertheless, I think robots are sophisticated enough these days that there is no good reason to send humans into space and probably never will be.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»NASA is about to send peo...