General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAre Jewish Americans leaving the Democratic Party?
It is no secret that anti-Israel, anti-Israeli and anti-Jewish sentiment has been on the rise on the Left aisle of the political spectrum for several years now. Much of this sentiment traces its roots back to Netanyahu's military response to Hamas' murder of 1200+ Israelis and kidnapping of another 250+ Israelis on October 7th, 2023. Justifiable enmity towards Netanyahu crept quickly towards unjustifiable hatred of Israel, Israelis and eventually of Jews. The resulting physical, violent and terrorist attacks on Jews not just here in the U.S. but worldwide has been well documented. What has not been nearly as well tracked is the response of Jewish American voters here in the U.S. - Specifically, whether such voters are remaining aligned with a Democratic Party they increasingly see as not having their best interests in mind. Numbering 7.5 million in the U.S., the loss of any significant number of Jewish voters historically inclining toward the Democratic Party either to the Republican Party or merely to Independent status could prove the difference between Democratic electoral victory and defeat. Something to think about when some of us interchangeably reference Netanyahu, Israel, Israelis and Jews.
More U.S. Jews shield identity in public amid antisemitism fears, Post poll finds
A Washington Post poll finds large majorities distrust Trumps efforts to fight anti-Jewish bias on campus. Faith in Democrats has also declined.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2025/10/15/us-jews-poll-safety-antisemitism/
U.S. Jews increasingly say they are hiding their identity in a country where they believe they continue to face significant antisemitism and where slightly fewer than 1 in 5 feel very safe, a Washington Post poll finds.
Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)WarGamer
(18,542 posts)Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)Posting that Donald Trump murdered 175 little children?
WarGamer
(18,542 posts)Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)Murder.
WarGamer
(18,542 posts)Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)WarGamer
(18,542 posts)they're speaking in broad terms, not specific to the IRGC/School strike
a kennedy
(35,828 posts)🤬 🤬 🤬 🤬 🤬
Polybius
(21,820 posts)ret5hd
(22,459 posts)i have no clue as to whether they are leaving or not there isnt even a synagogue in my small burg but im pretty damn sure no one believes the RW is a safe haven for them.
LearnedHand
(5,377 posts)Exactly where does the notion come from that antisemitism is rising on the left side of the aisle?
LeftInTX
(34,154 posts)He's not a Zionist. His dad is Jewish. He was not raised Jewish and attends a Methodist Church.
The whole Gaza gang accused him of genocide because his dad is Jewish. (How can a mayor commit genocide against Gaza?)
He won his primary, but I saw the hate.

Scrivener7
(59,340 posts)Or Democrats exclusively?
Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)Candace Owens, Nick Fuentes, Marjorie Taylor Greene.
But no---it's another Bad Things About Democrats.
Jedi Guy
(3,464 posts)You know, it's entirely possible to have a conversation about problematic behavior on our side of the fence without defaulting to, "Yeah but the Republicans..."
As it turns out, that's really not a helpful or useful response if we're interested in making things better.
rogue emissary
(3,345 posts)See the lies about Jasmine Crockett that helped sink her Senate run.
fujiyamasan
(1,613 posts)I think theres a growing consensus that theyre representing another countrys interests (and I would argue a specific party in another country) with no regard to whats actually best for the US.
Ill admit Im having a tougher time supporting democrats that take their money too.
Polybius
(21,820 posts)Since they aren't exactly "right."
marybourg
(13,621 posts)Green Party members and sympathizers.
Melon
(1,469 posts)marybourg
(13,621 posts)is aimed at destroying Israel. Destroying Israel will kill millions of Jews. Millions of American Jews have family or emotional ties to Israel. This is so obvious as to amount to gaslighting to even ask that question.
fujiyamasan
(1,613 posts)But it is about time to question what supporting Israel even means. If it means billions in military aid yearly, Im sorry Im out.
sarisataka
(22,591 posts)Remember their celebration of Hamas great victory?
SocialDemocrat61
(7,478 posts)comes from Green Party supports who attack democrats for being funded by AIPAC.
Response to SocialDemocrat61 (Reply #7)
Post removed
SocialDemocrat61
(7,478 posts)Dont care. They have attacked AOC and Jasmine Crockett despite neither being funded by AIPAC.
LeftInTX
(34,154 posts)But this Maureen chick is in a Democratic runoff and ActBlue is with the Democratic Party.
I saw Democrats complaining about Jasmine and Israel in one of the "mom's groups". The group is for Democrats. And someone said about this race, "Oh I can't vote for the Johnny Garcia guy if he took AIPAC money". Even our party secertary is vehemtly against AIPAC.
SocialDemocrat61
(7,478 posts)not Maureen chick.
Celerity
(54,238 posts)Scrivener7
(59,340 posts)Kingofalldems
(40,223 posts)LeftInTX
(34,154 posts)Get real!!!
And is promoting woo-candidates who don't have a chance of winning smart????
karynnj
(60,916 posts)From this 2024 source, all the Democrats from Clinton thru Obama 2008 got nearly 80 percent. It fell for Obama 2012 and stayed at that lower level ever since. I suspect that can be attributed to Netanyahu and AIPAC anger over Obama not doing everything Netanyahu wanted. Note 2012 is before the Iran deal.
https://manhattan.institute/article/survey-analysis-of-political-and-policy-preferences-of-2024-jewish-electorate
One other factor that may come into play is that over time the Orthodox with higher birth rates and lower assimilation will mean a higher percent Republican.
biocube
(203 posts)It hasn't helped us with the share of black and latino votes. There was no army of angry women to save us from Trump in 2024. I don't really care if some Jews are upset Democrats think Netanyahu has gone too far with his war. Heck Mamdani won a majority of Jews under 40. Democrats will win with class-first populism, not trying to pander to identitarian grievances.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,245 posts)It is the republicans who use identity politics the racist, homophobic, anti immigrant and anti woman base eats it up. Donald Trump was supposedly populist he promised bs to idiots and they believed him. I find many white men want us to talk about what matters to them and everyone else F O . Which is an extension of the I only want to talk about what affects me.
betsuni
(29,004 posts)Pisces
(6,212 posts)Autumn
(48,937 posts)feel free to join them.
Nanjeanne
(6,557 posts)firmly in the anti Israel camp. Even my relatives in Israel that are still there are still protesting their government. My closest family have relocated to France from Israel and they left in 2025 when Israel was bombing Lebanon before.
Not one single left leaning person I know has expressed any anti Jewish sentiment. Not in person. Not in any protest Ive been at. Not at any Democratic Party organizing event. So Im not sure that I have had the same awareness as the OP has expressed.
SunImp
(2,696 posts)By using antisemitic phrases & language to not only attack Israel, but Jewish people. On Reddit, threads, bluesky it gets downvoted & gets called out most of the time. Like recently Ana Kasparan used "Goyim" in a tweet & rightful got back lash for it from other leftists. Unfortunately you can't control everyone so if it happens expect rightwingers to blow it out of proportion & make a big deal about it
Sogo
(7,166 posts)nt
SunImp
(2,696 posts)But there are actual left wingers who are truly antisemitic like Badempanada youtuber or zesquirl on twitter. I don't want these leftwingers to be used against legitimate leftwing grievances n protestors
The Wizard
(13,692 posts)Who normalized bigotry?
harumph
(3,215 posts)Even if the "frying pan" in this case is the equivalent of occasionally getting a botched restaurant order. But people are individuals and we shouldn't stereotype or characterize otherwise. Accordingly, if certain individual Jews feel an urgent need to leave the Democratic party, then it's a free country (sort of). I see no other viable or remotely ethical political home. I'm not going to the whole sackcloth and ashes thing and beg them to stay.
Adios
Johonny
(26,051 posts)Because it's not filled with people saying good things...
Iggo
(49,884 posts)As usual.
Skittles
(171,228 posts)not one fucking bit
fujiyamasan
(1,613 posts)Antisemitism isnt an ideological thing. Its just an age old pathological and idiotic hatred and scapegoating of a people. Its not something that can easily be defended.
If this about Israel though, were definitely seeing a sea change. Recent polls are showing that support for Israel has fallen drastically over the last two years. Thats overall. Democrats were already shifting away.
Even immediately after 10/07, I was a staunch supporter (recognizing that Israel had the right to defend itself) until its never ending bombardment and starvation in Gaza. Labeling anyone that dared to give a shit about kids dying there antisemitic or a Hamas supported was the last straw. And of course now this war with Iran
HesNotHere
(5 posts)Imagine the cool parties that could fit in such a huge tent, althuogh acoustics would be sacrilege to Wagner.
ecstatic
(35,049 posts)our values we can get past it. A true liberal or progressive is not going to look at what BB is doing in Gaza / the Middle East and use that as a basis to attack Jewish Americans or even Israeli citizens. That is disgusting and not something anyone here should support, condone or tolerate.
At the same time, in my opinion, a true liberal or progressive is not going to support what bb and trump are doing in the Middle East right now. It's not about gatekeeping, it's just a common collection of values. Most of us do not support pointless wars and we definitely don't support (or try to justify) the mass elimination of innocent men, women and children.
From my understanding, most Jewish Americans do NOT support what bb is doing. I also heard that most Israelis do not support him either. He's making all of us less safe.
questionseverything
(11,755 posts)So I call bullshit
fujiyamasan
(1,613 posts)Bibi was simply not popular before the attacks. He was facing massive protests over the judicial overhaul. It was looking hopeful that he would be forced out. He was also under criminal investigation.
After 10/07 I understand there was a real sense of paranoia. It shook the country to its core and sadly in normal citizens eyes, it seems to have justified some truly terrible and morally reprehensible policy choices. For Bibi the attacks were a godsend, and he has milked it for all its worth.
Its not unlike 9/11 and bush and the republicans exploiting it afterward, but of course Israel is a much smaller country so the attacks were even deeper felt.
All that said, its no longer tenable for the US to simply cover for them at every stop. We shouldnt look away when they commit atrocities with our tax money. It makes no sense to subsidize a country that constantly keeps making such terrible choices.
Blue Full Moon
(3,398 posts)Scrivener7
(59,340 posts)than Irish or Hispanic or Black voters.
C) The article talks about distrust of Cankles, so what's with that headline?
D) Anti Netanyahu is not Anti Jewish any more than Anti Trump is Anti American.
muriel_volestrangler
(106,069 posts)...
Rubin, who works at the Bronx housing development, said she used to vote Democratic but has shifted right in recent years because some of that partys leaders have intensely criticized Israel. Now she identifies as Republican and voted for Trump last year.
Ive seen the Democratic Party become less and less supportive of Israel and now it seems to have escalated to the point where I dont feel confident the Democrats are protecting us against antisemitism, Rubin said. Im tending towards feeling safer with Trump and the Republicans. Its just a gut feeling.
If those who have dropped support of Democrats are the ones who "interchangeably reference Netanyahu, Israel, Israelis and Jews", what can you do?