Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

panader0

(25,816 posts)
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:26 AM Feb 2014

The Environmental Cost of Salting Roads

I got to thinking about this. I found this article @ www.popsci.com/environment, the web site of Popular Science.


The Environmental Cost of Salting Roads


Why cost to the city's coffers outweighs cost to the Earth

By Matt Ransford





Municipalities are always weighing cost against environmental concerns and quite often, cost wins out at great expense to the environment. Residents of New York City will remember the summer of 2002 when the Bloomberg administration ceased recycling glass and plastic, citing budgetary concerns. It was cheaper for the city to dump tons of reusable refuse into landfills than to continue its recycling program. After a year of no plastic recycling and two years of no glass, the city determined the savings were negligible and resumed recycling both. Salting roads during the winter is another source of environmental concern weighed against cost. Now that Spring is finally rounding the corner, let's look at the consequences of spreading millions of tons of salt on our roads.

Keeping roads safe in the winter is a high priority for cities throughout the country. Salting the pavement is the cheapest way to do that. When a salt crystal dissolves, it releases its component ions—sodium and chloride—which both bond with water molecules, making it more difficult for them to join to each other and thereby freeze. The problem comes from all that chloride and salt run-off. The chloride gets into our water supply and poisons fish. The salt burns vegetation and contaminates soil, as well as corroding cars and bridges. But it's cheap. Ten times cheaper than effective alternatives. And when a city of 2.5 million people needs 135,000 tons of it, that's a significant cost difference.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Environmental Cost of Salting Roads (Original Post) panader0 Feb 2014 OP
Here's the link. Wilms Feb 2014 #1
Thanks panader0 Feb 2014 #4
It also corrodes cars. former9thward Feb 2014 #2
I've had less problem with that in recent years...plastic doesn't rust, paints are better... HereSince1628 Feb 2014 #9
not really LOL, Pisser makes his living off RUUUUUSSST! snooper2 Feb 2014 #12
Inside OUT liberal N proud Feb 2014 #28
Is this correct? Orrex Feb 2014 #3
You're right. There is no breaking up of NaCl in water. MineralMan Feb 2014 #5
No you're wrong. GeorgeGist Feb 2014 #16
I stand corrected: MineralMan Feb 2014 #17
I'm so disillusioned Orrex Feb 2014 #21
See, that's where you're wrong. MineralMan Feb 2014 #22
Well, that's good enough for me. Orrex Feb 2014 #23
I think they're mostly wrong - it's not that the ions bond with water, just that they petronius Feb 2014 #6
Salt dissolves in water into sodium and chlorine ions Blues Heron Feb 2014 #10
Yes, NaCl breaks up and "bonds" with water mathematic Feb 2014 #13
Forgive me, but I simply don't believe that's correct Orrex Feb 2014 #14
Yes, it's correct. mathematic Feb 2014 #15
DAMN YOU AND YOUR SCIENCE!!!!!1! Orrex Feb 2014 #19
Haha, no prob (nt) mathematic Feb 2014 #20
I'm pretty sure that on balance, salting the roads saves lives, Nye Bevan Feb 2014 #7
Beet juice on roads? Pennsylvania looking at alternative to zap ice LiberalEsto Feb 2014 #8
My city salts the roads almost liberally and we're next to the Mississippi River. Vashta Nerada Feb 2014 #11
Don't get me started :) Holly_Hobby Feb 2014 #18
how about a chat with the head of public works? anasv Feb 2014 #24
Sent an email to him this morning, Holly_Hobby Feb 2014 #25
They use sand in Colorado... SomethingFishy Feb 2014 #26
They don't salt the roads as much or HappyMe Feb 2014 #27

former9thward

(32,016 posts)
2. It also corrodes cars.
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:29 AM
Feb 2014

Last edited Thu Feb 6, 2014, 12:27 PM - Edit history (1)

Look at a 10 year old car from the NE or Mid West and look at that same car in Arizona. The Arizona car looks brand new compared to cars from the snowbelt. That said there really is no alternative.

HereSince1628

(36,063 posts)
9. I've had less problem with that in recent years...plastic doesn't rust, paints are better...
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 11:09 AM
Feb 2014

My 16 year old escort wagon is somewhat remarkably free of body rust...

The body of my previous car...a Camry wagon...was well rusted thru (including a few places on the floor) at age 9.

 

snooper2

(30,151 posts)
12. not really LOL, Pisser makes his living off RUUUUUSSST!
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 11:36 AM
Feb 2014

Fords especially......one of my favorite YouTube channels

Look at this truck...Crunch Crunch Crunch




Orrex

(63,213 posts)
3. Is this correct?
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:34 AM
Feb 2014
When a salt crystal dissolves, it releases its component ions—sodium and chloride—which both bond with water molecules, making it more difficult for them to join to each other and thereby freeze.

I'm not a chemistry guy, but that sounds about 100% incorrect to me.

Here's a discussion of how to break NaCl into its constituent elements, and it has nothing to do with dumping it on a snowy road.


I'm happy to recant if I'm wrong, of course.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
5. You're right. There is no breaking up of NaCl in water.
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:46 AM
Feb 2014

Instead, the salt goes into solution in the water. It remains NaCl. Saline solutions have a lower freezing point than pure water.

When salt is put onto roads, the points of contact with the salt and water melt, with the salt going into solution, which lowers the freezing point, producing more melting and more solution. But the NaCl remains NaCl.

To lower the freezing point even further, ice melting chemicals also include Magnesium chloride and Potassium chloride. Those two salts lower the freezing point of the solution even further.

The harm is done by having higher salinity of the water that flows into lakes and rivers. Saline solutions also can damage concrete and accelerate rust development on steel.

But the author of this thing wasn't paying attention in his Chemistry class.

Orrex

(63,213 posts)
21. I'm so disillusioned
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 01:43 PM
Feb 2014

I'm guessing that the perpetual motion machine that you sold me doesn't work, either.

MineralMan

(146,317 posts)
22. See, that's where you're wrong.
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 01:45 PM
Feb 2014

While most perpetual motion machines don't really work, mine does. Trust me. I only need another million or so dollars to go into production.

{DONATE NOW!}

petronius

(26,602 posts)
6. I think they're mostly wrong - it's not that the ions bond with water, just that they
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:47 AM
Feb 2014

take up space in the mixture and reduce the rate of freezing onto the ice surface, disrupting the melt/freeze equilibrium and lowering the melting temperature of water. This link looks pretty good.

But they're correct that dissolving salt does break it into its constituent ions: Na+ and Cl-. Your link seems to relate to dividing salt into the (uncharged) basic elements, sodium (Na) and chlorine (Cl)...

(Note: I'm not a chemist either, so I'll echo your caveat.)

Blues Heron

(5,936 posts)
10. Salt dissolves in water into sodium and chlorine ions
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 11:27 AM
Feb 2014

When you dissolve salt in water the sodium chloride dissociates in Na+ ions and Cl- ions, which may be written as a chemical equation:

NaCl(s) → Na+(aq) + Cl-(aq)


http://chemistry.about.com/b/2011/06/06/is-dissolving-salt-in-water-a-chemical-change-or-physical-change.htm

mathematic

(1,439 posts)
13. Yes, NaCl breaks up and "bonds" with water
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 11:39 AM
Feb 2014

NaCl is an ionic compound. It breaks up into Na+ and Cl- ion in water. It might help to think of water as a magnet with a positive and a negative end. The positive end attracts the Cl- and the negative end attracts the Na+. This "bond" is called an ion-dipole force.

The freezing point of a solution is lower than that of the freezing point of the pure solvent (water, in this case). To me, "making it more difficult to join together" is as acceptable a lay explanation as "the randomness of the molecules increase." Neither really does much to illuminate the specifics of what's going on and both give a correct sense of what's happening.


Orrex

(63,213 posts)
14. Forgive me, but I simply don't believe that's correct
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 11:54 AM
Feb 2014

It was my impression that dissolving NaCl into water is principally a physical reaction rather than chemical, in much the same way that making Kool-Aid is not chiefly a chemical reaction.

You seem to be suggesting that when I drink salt water I am drinking a mixture of NaOH and HCl.


No?

mathematic

(1,439 posts)
15. Yes, it's correct.
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 12:20 PM
Feb 2014

The Na+ and the Cl- are floating around in the water, loosely attached to H2O molecules.

NaOH and HCl do not exist like that in solution. They are Na+, OH-, H3O+, and Cl-. Since we're dealing with equal molar amounts here, you just get a neutral solution of Na+, Cl- and H2O. In other words, if you put equal parts NaOH and HCl into water and drank it you would, in fact, just be drinking salt water.



Orrex

(63,213 posts)
19. DAMN YOU AND YOUR SCIENCE!!!!!1!
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 01:18 PM
Feb 2014

I'll take this as a useful lesson both in grade-school chemistry and a lesson in not being too sure of one's ideas.


DAMN YOU!

Nye Bevan

(25,406 posts)
7. I'm pretty sure that on balance, salting the roads saves lives,
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:48 AM
Feb 2014

notwithstanding the environmental impact.

 

LiberalEsto

(22,845 posts)
8. Beet juice on roads? Pennsylvania looking at alternative to zap ice
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 10:49 AM
Feb 2014

From the Star-Ledger/ nj.com

Mike Frassinelli/The Star-Ledger
on February 05, 2014 at 12:00 PM, updated February 05, 2014 at 12:02 PM

"Mom always said beets were good for you.

Now neighboring Pennsylvania is experimenting with beet juice as a way to treat icy roads during extreme low temperatures.

With road salt in short supply this harsh winter, the Department of Transportation in that state is testing the juice on roads in Butler County, about 20 miles north of Pittsburgh, as part of a pilot program.

In a report on KDKA-TV, a CBS affiliate in Pittsburgh, PennDOT officials explained that chemicals in the juice help melt the ice during extreme low temperatures."

More:
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2014/02/beet_juice_on_roads_pennsylvania_looking_at_road_salt_alternative.html#inc

Holly_Hobby

(3,033 posts)
18. Don't get me started :)
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 01:07 PM
Feb 2014

I spent 20 min. on the phone with our street dept. this morning asking them to please stop.

I live on a residential street 2 blocks long with a speed limit of 25mph. The salt truck has been back and forth spewing salt 7 times already today. It's 12 degrees - too cold for salt to work. Our city is nearly out of salt, time to conserve. We're way past the city budget for salt.

We don't have sidewalks, so I have to walk my dogs in the salted street if I want them to get their daily exercise. Salt and paws don't mix.

We have an extremely high water table of about 22". All that salt gets into our ground water.

I sold road salt to municipalities and private contractors for 6 years, I'm well aware of the environmental impacts.

We are used to not having our street salted. Plowed, yes. Salted, no. In 21 years on this street, there has never, ever been a car accident due to snow. We know how to drive in it, it's NW Ohio.

Children don't walk home from school on the road, their parents pick them up either at the school or at the bus stop. We don't have sidewalks.

I'm going to stop right there before I blow a gasket.

Holly_Hobby

(3,033 posts)
25. Sent an email to him this morning,
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 02:32 PM
Feb 2014

as well as our city council rep.

I was told by a neighbor today that our new neighbor next door to us has a brother that works for the street dept. and he's the driver of the salt truck. Now it all makes sense.

I'm not going to stop complaining until it stops. I'm going to stop short of talking to the new neighbor about it, I don't want to get started out on the wrong foot, they just moved in Feb. 1st and I haven't met him yet.

SomethingFishy

(4,876 posts)
26. They use sand in Colorado...
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 02:36 PM
Feb 2014

Problem is once the snow melts and the weather clears the sand gets kicked up into the air and we end up with the "brown cloud" that hovers over Denver...

There has to be a better solution that salt or sand...

HappyMe

(20,277 posts)
27. They don't salt the roads as much or
Thu Feb 6, 2014, 02:39 PM
Feb 2014

as often as they used to.

I would rather they salted instead of sand. Sand doesn't do a damn thing.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Environmental Cost of...