Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Putin's hard line on MH17 will only push Russia into an ever-tighter corner
The Russian president has several routes of retreat in the face of growing pressure. He is unlikely to take any of themAlthough visibly embarrassed and increasingly cornered by mounting evidence that rebels using missiles supplied by Moscow were responsible for shooting down flight MH17, Vladimir Putin still has plenty of ways to extricate himself and his country from the disaster.
...A clever Russian de-escalation tactic would be for Moscow to assist in the immediate creation of an international committee of inquiry into the carnage, and even grant the committee access to Russian soil.
That carries the risk that the investigation would unearth unsavoury connections between the Russian military and ethnic Russian separatists. But the risks are manageable, partly because pro-Russian rebels have already destroyed much of the incriminating evidence at the airliner's crash site, and partly because the Buk missile system involved in the Malaysian jet's destruction is manufactured in a single Russian factory and operated by both the Ukrainian and Russian military.
...An equally low-risk policy would be for Russia to accept the stationing of international observers on its border with Ukraine, to prevent the further smuggling of heavy weapons. Again, that would give little away, since ethnic Russian separatists already have all the weapons they are likely to need. And, again, western governments have offered Putin the easy way out: a team of observers from the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe stands ready to be dispatched.
The snag for Putin is that all these options would entail him accepting that, at most, Russia would now only be able to obtain autonomy for Russian-speakers in eastern Ukraine. The possibility of carving up Ukraine in order to prevent the country from slipping into the western sphere of influence would be gone, and probably for good, since the Ukrainian authorities would then be able to re-establish control in the eastern parts of their country. And that Putin is not prepared to contemplate, because it would dent his carefully nurtured domestic image as Russia's invincible leader.
...it is unlikely that the strategy of sitting out the crisis would work to Russia's advantage. International pressure to impose further sanctions on Moscow could become unstoppable. The Malaysian airliner's tragedy will embroil Russia in years of litigation. The families of the bereaved will seek compensation. Arrest warrants will be issued against individual Russian military commanders, and countries such as the Netherlands and Australia, which lost so many of their citizens, will demand satisfaction.
In his handling of the crisis, Putin has again revealed himself as a good tactician – a shrewd short-term operator. But he remains a poor strategist, and an obstacle to Russia's future wellbeing.
More at:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/19/vladimir-putin-mh17-russia-pressure
...A clever Russian de-escalation tactic would be for Moscow to assist in the immediate creation of an international committee of inquiry into the carnage, and even grant the committee access to Russian soil.
That carries the risk that the investigation would unearth unsavoury connections between the Russian military and ethnic Russian separatists. But the risks are manageable, partly because pro-Russian rebels have already destroyed much of the incriminating evidence at the airliner's crash site, and partly because the Buk missile system involved in the Malaysian jet's destruction is manufactured in a single Russian factory and operated by both the Ukrainian and Russian military.
...An equally low-risk policy would be for Russia to accept the stationing of international observers on its border with Ukraine, to prevent the further smuggling of heavy weapons. Again, that would give little away, since ethnic Russian separatists already have all the weapons they are likely to need. And, again, western governments have offered Putin the easy way out: a team of observers from the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe stands ready to be dispatched.
The snag for Putin is that all these options would entail him accepting that, at most, Russia would now only be able to obtain autonomy for Russian-speakers in eastern Ukraine. The possibility of carving up Ukraine in order to prevent the country from slipping into the western sphere of influence would be gone, and probably for good, since the Ukrainian authorities would then be able to re-establish control in the eastern parts of their country. And that Putin is not prepared to contemplate, because it would dent his carefully nurtured domestic image as Russia's invincible leader.
...it is unlikely that the strategy of sitting out the crisis would work to Russia's advantage. International pressure to impose further sanctions on Moscow could become unstoppable. The Malaysian airliner's tragedy will embroil Russia in years of litigation. The families of the bereaved will seek compensation. Arrest warrants will be issued against individual Russian military commanders, and countries such as the Netherlands and Australia, which lost so many of their citizens, will demand satisfaction.
In his handling of the crisis, Putin has again revealed himself as a good tactician – a shrewd short-term operator. But he remains a poor strategist, and an obstacle to Russia's future wellbeing.
More at:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/19/vladimir-putin-mh17-russia-pressure