Image test

[sarisataka]

Based only on the photo, select who is a good person

A
B
C


-Only A is a good person
-Only B is a good person
-Only C is a good person
-Only A & B are good people
-Only A & C are good people
-Only B & C are good people
-All of them are good people
-None of them are good

[Shandris]

1. As a point of fact, most people are not good.

You could answer 'None' and be right almost 98% of the time or so. It all depends on what you mean by 'good'.

That little nitpick aside though (and I don't believe you can select even 'decent' people simply from stills), I'll play and say all three are good people/none are good people (depending on your definition).

[Newest Reality]

2. None of the above...

I would not jump to any conclusion about those pictures without the context and relationships involved.

The problem of "good or bad" is also at issue because the value judgment is contingent and relative to my bias and the particulars of the situation. Useful, constructive, destructive and other terms come to mind and a moral presupposition is not necessary to evaluate that.

[Newest Reality]

10. In addition...

To make a blanket, "isness" statement about a person is most often an error in any case.

It rests on the assumption that one act or interaction determines the entire character of a person and that does not usually apply in any personality.

I won't provide examples, but it is not easy to ascertain how that works and how generalizing affects our judgements and views.

[HappyPlace]

3. All are good.

Nothing presents as a reason not to assume that each is a good person.

[Xipe Totec]

4. There should be 8 possible choices 2x2x2. All are good is missing. nt

[sarisataka]

6. Proof reading oversight

and corrected
Thank you

[Xipe Totec]

9. It's all good... It's all good. ..

[Dr. Strange]

5. Why can't they all be good?

[sarisataka]

8. Error- has been corrected n/t

[MineralMan]

7. They all have sinned and come short of the Glory of God.

None are righteous. No, not one.

[sarisataka]

15. I am not without sin

So I shall not cast the first stone

[HappyPlace]

11. First Asian LEO, Male Model, Safe Shooter.

Rosa Park is Baltimore County's first Asian office, that's good.
Middle shot is a young man modeling camo shorts, that's good.
Third picture is a man firing a handgun, wearing protective eye and ear wear, that's good.

The knee jerk stereotype reactions many would have against any of these is easy to imagine: bad cop, gang banger, gun nut.

[sarisataka]

12. .

[sarisataka]

14. Not to say

I know any of them IRL. They could be walking saints or obnoxious bastards.

Yet many people (many who call themselves progressive) will judge the value of the person's life on such simple information.

[Solly Mack]

13. Me

I'm the only one I'm absolutely certain about and I could be wrong.