General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCharter Schools
Anybody have kids in charter school?
we'll soon have a grandchild there and am curious about what you think...
villager
(26,001 posts)The college counselor there was absolutely instrumental in helping him get to the college he's in now.
Between two sons, that's been our only "charter," and a lot of the folks that made that school good "back then" -- like that counselor -- have since moved on.
So the specific staff, along with whatever "mission" the school may have have, matters a lot too....
HassleCat
(6,409 posts)Some charter schools are wonderful, and some are more like the detention center at Guantanamo. You have to be careful. Some states have let the charter school situation get out of control.
Smarmie Doofus
(14,498 posts)Turn the neighborhood schools into underfunded failure factories. Charge them w. educating all sp ed, all ELL and all kids w. behavior challenges.
Send the rest to privately backed $$$$, lavishly funded, quasi private schools. They hire their own ( non-union.... are ya shocked?) teaching staff , expel kids who lag behind despite being screened as the best and the brightest in their screening process.
It's basically a boilerplate cheap-labor capitalism scheme w. lots of pols in on the gravy train. ( Look at Cuomo's fundraising in last year's NYS gov election, for instance. Outraised the GOP conservative candidate by a factor of 10. A great deal of it from people also in on the $$$ aspects of the CS industry. Cuomo then leaned on the legislature to increase the number of charters issued.
Consumer then faces a choice: do they want to send their kid to a low-performing, community school, w. behavior problems (often VIOLENT behavior problems) or enroll in a lottery to get into a charter school. ( Usually spanking new bldg , new tech, better infrastructure, carefully screened classmates.)
Which would YOU pick? I took my kid out of local ps in 2007 ( 5 years into Bloomberg's "transformation" of the ps system from problematic to complete academic incoherence) but found a private ( NOT charter) school which met his needs. I sued the ps system for the tuition and they settled.
Do what's best for your kids. But the pols have contrived to make that choice the kind of choice one makes w. a gun to one's head. In other words: not a choice at all.
That's what I think.
Maedhros
(10,007 posts)are re-purposed to provide low-cost or even free facilities for charter schools. Our education dollars at work, helping to lift up the privileged and undermine the rest.
hack89
(39,171 posts)excellent school with excellent results.