General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Full Story of the Sirhan Sirhan Parole Hearing
The ban on video and audio recordings at Sirhan Sirhans parole hearing on February 9 meant the world depended on the one reporter allowed inside the hearing to tell us what happened. He had to condense more than three hours of intense testimony into 854 words.
Elliot Spagats lively account of the proceeding for the Associated Press omitted one very important document that shooting victim and Kennedy family friend Paul Schrade presented to the parole board. This was a letter from Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to US Attorney General Eric Holder, dated September 25, 2012, supporting Schrades request for a new investigation of his fathers murder:
Paul was a close friend and advisor to my father. He was standing beside my father when Daddy was killed and Paul was himself wounded by a bullet. With boundless energy and clear mind, Paul continues to pursue my fathers ideas, an endeavor to which he has devoted his life. He organized with the support of my mother and my family the building of the new Robert F. Kennedy Community Schools on the former Ambassador Hotel site. Paul and his team strongly believe this new evidence is conclusive and requires a new investigation. I agree and support his request for a new investigation.
snip
When he agreed to release the 2012 letter to the parole board at Sirhans hearing, Robert Kennedy Jr. signaled publicly, for the first time, his support for a new investigation of his fathers murder. Youre doing the right thing, he told Schrade, days before the hearing.
http://whowhatwhy.org/2016/02/16/22296/
struggle4progress
(118,295 posts)11-20-07
by Mel Ayton
... Philip Harrison has worked on over one thousand such cases. Harrison analyzed the Pruszynski Tape using three different methods, both independently and simultaneously. These involved (1) listening analytically to the recording via high quality headphones, (2) examining visual representations of the recordings waveform (oscillographic displays), and (3) analyzing spectrograms (plots of sound energy across frequency over time), all using specialized computer software. Harrisons findings were confirmed by Professor Peter French, a colleague and lecturer in forensic speech and audio analysis at the University of York. They found no more than 8 shots were present on the recording.
Both the UK and US teams had independently examined the tape then Barber and Harrison consulted with each other.
Further research carried out by these two teams after the airing of the Discovery Times Channel documentary casts serious doubt on the findings of their acoustics experts. The Discovery Timess acoustics research was led by Philip Van Praag, electrical engineer and author of Evolution of the Audio Recorder.' Wes Dooley, forensic analyst and manufacturer of ribbon microphones, was brought in to independently consider the recording. Van Praag claimed that he had identified approximately 13 shot sounds on the Pruszynski Tape, whilst Dooley and his team located 10. Van Praag also insisted certainly more than 8 shots were fired.' As Dan Moldea observed after watching the documentary, Van Praag has concluded - and stated on national television - that thirteen shots were fired at the crime scene
Even the kookiest kook hasn't suggested that ...
http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/44466
From your link: ... The request for a new investigation was partly based on .. the Pruszynski recording ... After studying the tape .. Van Praag concluded 13 shots and 2 guns were fired in the Ambassador Hotel pantry on the night of the shooting ...