General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsHealth savings accounts
Thats the great plan the republicans have. The crap Bush tried to sell at a Wendys in Ohio. Like someone who works at Wendys could afford to put money in one of those accounts then afford to lose the money because the claims will be denied and what is not used in a year gets to go to the company. What a scam.
madaboutharry
(40,212 posts)Like the scams he ran at Trump University and Trump Institute.
Ilsa
(61,695 posts)Here in this thread: http://www.democraticunderground.com/12512569698
Replacing the ACA with HSAs and interstate insurance won't solve cost problems, and will make regulating harder.
Democrats need to run defense and get out info on why this is terrible before the GOP tells everyone how great it is. Most people do not even make enough to live on.
Ilsa
(61,695 posts)and they are the same folks who get little or no tax benefit from it.
Hoyt
(54,770 posts)unblock
(52,243 posts)i have a "health savings account", it's mine and my employer has no access to it under any circumstances other than to make contributions into it. unused amounts (as if!) roll over to the next year.
Response to unblock (Reply #4)
Kathy M This message was self-deleted by its author.
sarcasmo
(23,968 posts)They want us to take social security and play it in the stock market. They will take every cent we have and our arms and legs.
Yo_Mama
(8,303 posts)You seem to be thinking of the FSA?
Still a bad thing. Obviously universal health care is the right way. The Gop always cries about the debt yet they are the ones who drive it up. They pay themselves with our tax money.
Travis_0004
(5,417 posts)I contributed several grand to an HSA, then used it to buy lasik (I avoid taxes by doing it that way).
Even if we had single payer, there are somethings that will always cost money. I think HSA should be opened to everybody that wants to contribute.
Bear Creek
(883 posts)A few spare thousands why not. Not practical for working middle class by that I mean under 100000 a year more like 30000 if lucky.
WillowTree
(5,325 posts)duffyduff
(3,251 posts)Bear Creek
(883 posts)In theory sounds good until try to get covered my son is out of work and does not qualify for any help. A friend at work child who was away at college ran up a huge bill that and did not tell my friend. My friend just about lost her job over it. Which is another problem.
dflprincess
(28,079 posts)(it's the Flex Spending Accounts, FSA, that don't though now you can carry over up to $500 from one year to a next - but never more than that).
in fact, once you have a few thousand dollars in one, you can invest it just like you do a 401K! (Just hope the market is up when you need that bypass.) When I heard that I realized that the high deductible/HSA plans are nothing but another Wall Street scam.
HSAs may be okay if you're young and healthy and can afford to have even more of your income stashed away for "someday". But if you have a chronic condition or you're just getting older I don't see why anyone would want one.
But what really irks me about them is, Americans are supposed to save for their kids' college (while paying off their own student loans), for a house, retirement and now for health care. We're the only "first" world country where we're not allowed to enjoy our money.
Are trash! That was forced down our throats. The man who created them is ashamed to admit he did. They are just for rich people to park money and are not for pensions or retirement. Just another GOP scam to steal your money.
Bear Creek
(883 posts)We place people in so much debt there is no way out. We pay more for less. Alot of people do not understand that regulations and law affects our daily lives. Bankruptcy laws need to be changed. That supposed consumer protection bill passed during Bush Adminstration destroyed our economy and caused the housing meltdown the economy died way before the banks could feel it. I almost quit backing Hillary over that bill. The democrats did not do anything and still have not taken care of it yet. It screwed over every working American.
dflprincess
(28,079 posts)there is a limit to how much you can put in it in a year but there is not a limit to how much you can keep in it. The drawback is that if you withdraw it for anything other than medical expense you will pay taxes and a penalty on the money you withdraw. The money that goes into the HSA is pretax.
HSAs generally go hand in hand with an high deductible insurance plan. So you may find yourself spending several thousand out of your savings (or pocket if you haven't saved enough) to cover the deductible before the insurance kicks in.
Again, HSAs are okay if you're young and healthy (or old and healthy, I have a cousin my age who started one a few years ago and has quite a lot saved and likes it. Personally, I think she's taking an awful risk and would be better off going with her employer's low deductible plan and paying more out of each paycheck. But another 2 years and Medicare will kick in for her so maybe she'll be lucky.)
The $500 carryover on the FSA was new last year and may depend on whether or not your employer is going along with it.
On edit, I just checked on what the annual limits are to what a person can put in a HSA. Strangely enough, I know people whose insurance has deductibles higher than the limit.
These are the 2016 limits, I imagine they'll go up in 2017
HSA holders can choose to save up to $3,350 for an individual and $6,650 for a family (HSA holders 55 and older get to save an extra $1,000 which means $4,350 for an individual and $7,650 for a family) and these contributions are 100% tax deductible from gross income.May 13, 2016
http://www.hsacenter.com/how-does-an-hsa-work/2016-hsa-contribution-limits/
anneboleyn
(5,611 posts)They don't get that these accounts are basically glorified savings accounts, and even someone who can afford to put away $1,000 a month (and how many Americans can do that?) would see that money eaten up very quickly if they needed any kind of serious medical attention. A few days in the hospital can run up a 10,000 bill -- WITHOUT surgery or MRIs or anything complicated. Prescriptions can easily run into the hundreds each month (and even more depending on the medications and whether generics are available). Cancer treatments? Forget it. I find it very frustrating how so many people stick their heads in the sand about insurance and illness and then are stunned and outraged to find out that they will be financially devastated.
Bear Creek
(883 posts)My sister's husband had cancer when she started to work at WalMarts which by the way is not enough to live on got all medical assisstance pulled and the case worker told her that Walmarts has $4.00 prescriptions. Maybe the problem is the health care in this country is for profit.
dflprincess
(28,079 posts)Just a few thousand around the house. No way. Don't know anyone who could afford that crap. Maybe go without food? Or maybe a place to live? Or car to get to work? Maybe wages need to be raised or maybe some jobs that are not Walmart, Family Dollar, or Dollar General.
Thinkingabout
(30,058 posts)$2000 a year on his hair and he thinks $2000 is going to handle our health care for life. FRAUD, Trump is the champion.
Bear Creek
(883 posts)No idea of reality. Reminds me of my first boss. I had bought a used car that I could buy he asked me why didn't I just go out a buy a new car. I asked him if he was going to co sign.