Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:29 PM Jul 2018

Bernie Sanders' campaign strategist Tad Devine turns up 16 times in evidence against Paul Manafort

Source: Raw Story

The chief strategist for the Bernie Sanders campaign was in contact with Paul Manafort and a Russian alleged spy also indicted in the special counsel probe, according to new court filings.

Tad Devine, who helped run the Vermont senator’s Democratic primary campaign, shows up 16 times in a list of nearly 500 evidence exhibits published Wednesday evening by prosecutors in the Manafort case, reported the Washington Post.

The former campaign chairman for President Donald Trump and Devine worked together nearly a decade ago for former Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych and his pro-Kremlin Party of Regions, and the pair remained in contact until at least 2014.

According to the new court filing, Manafort and Devine communicated by email through June 2014, about five months before he joined the Sanders campaign that November.

Read more: https://www.rawstory.com/2018/07/bernie-sanders-campaign-strategist-tad-devine-turns-16-times-evidence-paul-manafort/

133 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Bernie Sanders' campaign strategist Tad Devine turns up 16 times in evidence against Paul Manafort (Original Post) herding cats Jul 2018 OP
Rut-Roh! n/t Mr.Bill Jul 2018 #1
Very Interesting louis c Jul 2018 #2
It's sad but can't say I didn't feel uncomfortable.... FarPoint Jul 2018 #61
rawstory is not a news source nt msongs Jul 2018 #3
Oh i think i get it Fullduplexxx Jul 2018 #22
Usually it's an aggregator but sometimes it publishes its own stories, pnwmom Jul 2018 #42
Screaming 'fake news" doesn't make this go away, Donald Adenoid_Hynkel Jul 2018 #74
There is this GemDigger Jul 2018 #77
Was Jill stein also in this loop? kimbutgar Jul 2018 #4
Putin used everyone to attack his enemy...HILLARY! BigmanPigman Jul 2018 #43
100% Skid Rogue Jul 2018 #122
Other people were influenced by the polls and assumed Hillary would win BigmanPigman Jul 2018 #124
according to a report on vote suppression WhiteTara Jul 2018 #130
I'm a Democrat. What's bernie? Crutchez_CuiBono Jul 2018 #5
+1000 Pachamama Jul 2018 #109
Just tired of being responsible for him all the time. Crutchez_CuiBono Jul 2018 #118
Why leave out Al Gore and John Kerry? dogman Jul 2018 #6
Probably because of this. herding cats Jul 2018 #7
And he worked on their campaigns also. dogman Jul 2018 #9
that was before he joined manafort JI7 Jul 2018 #14
So what? dogman Jul 2018 #17
its not a conspiracy theory that he worked with manafort JI7 Jul 2018 #19
No, and that is nothing new. dogman Jul 2018 #21
The new information is that he worked with Manafort and Kilimnik through 2014 Maven Jul 2018 #31
This message was self-deleted by its author KPN Jul 2018 #102
But the insinuation that he did anything wrong, anywhere, ever RandomAccess Jul 2018 #78
If Bernie were a Democrat... SergeStorms Jul 2018 #90
I was talking about Devine RandomAccess Jul 2018 #91
You were talking about "Bernie hatred".... SergeStorms Jul 2018 #92
Yes, but not Bernie himself -- RandomAccess Jul 2018 #95
Right -- Bernie's obviously guilty by association here. Do we even know what Devine is guilty of? KPN Jul 2018 #104
Post removed Post removed Jul 2018 #106
But "the emails"! Why does that sound so familiar? KPN Jul 2018 #114
That broadbursh is simply not true. There are many bernie supporters who are Wwcd Jul 2018 #119
Who is making this into a conspiracy theory? All I see are facts that have been presented. George II Jul 2018 #25
You're choosing to ignore all the innuendo? RandomAccess Jul 2018 #79
Best thing to do is pretend any accurate news story is simply hatred and bias. LanternWaste Jul 2018 #94
Are you not a little bothered that he worked for Yanukovich? Adrahil Jul 2018 #121
They predate his involvement with Russia and Manafort. herding cats Jul 2018 #15
Yes, but if Tad is bad, how does that involve Bernie? dogman Jul 2018 #20
Tad Devine is named by Mueller. herding cats Jul 2018 #24
By Mueller. dogman Jul 2018 #28
This is a DU post, not a twitter thread. herding cats Jul 2018 #30
Right. dogman Jul 2018 #33
To address late your edit. herding cats Jul 2018 #93
Precisely Sherman A1 Jul 2018 #36
Lol. Nary a peep from that side, but Woo Boy would the other side be howling! Wwcd Jul 2018 #38
That's just it, he would never have even been asked "another candidate", so "nary a peep".... Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #48
Would Clinton have hired him? dawg day Jul 2018 #126
No she wouldn't. He would've been vetted, and his associations would have prevented him from EVER.. Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #127
Exactly. A lot to do about nothing. It all KPN Jul 2018 #115
That's inconvenient for the Bernie haters. rainin Jul 2018 #56
That was years earlier. George II Jul 2018 #13
What is the time frame for conspiracy theory? dogman Jul 2018 #23
Conspiracy theory? How has this suddenly become a conspiracy theory? George II Jul 2018 #27
Read the thread. dogman Jul 2018 #29
Of course they do. herding cats Jul 2018 #32
Not discussing it intelligently. dogman Jul 2018 #35
Bernie is going to be mentioned because his Chief Strategist was mentioned by Mueller herding cats Jul 2018 #37
Buckle up. This is going to get very bumpy for the Sanders campaign. We already know that Russia.. Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #54
Yes, a great conspiracy theory. dogman Jul 2018 #57
Because Devine lied about when he quit working with Manafort? If it was 2010, why was he still... Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #59
And Gore lost an election he won, and Kerry lost an election he should have won. dogman Jul 2018 #62
2000 & 2004. We're talking about 2014. Please try & keep up. n/t Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #67
I think the invoice was from June while RandomAccess Jul 2018 #80
Bernie is involved because Devine was in touch with Kilminick, the intelligence officer, pnwmom Jul 2018 #45
So what exactly is your theory? dogman Jul 2018 #60
My theory is that Manafort's trial will start next week and we'll know more. pnwmom Jul 2018 #63
Agreed. dogman Jul 2018 #66
He was involved with them in 2000 and 2004, prior to getting mixed up pnwmom Jul 2018 #70
Just a buzzword to try Cha Jul 2018 #52
Because 2000 and 2004 were both BEFORE 2006, the first time pnwmom Jul 2018 #44
That doesn't serve the purpose of rehashing the 2016 campaign. n/t QC Jul 2018 #98
They're not too relevant here- did they work w Manafort too? bettyellen Jul 2018 #101
From the Hoarse Whisperer Gothmog Jul 2018 #8
Not just "in contact", they worked together for years, and communicated most recently in 2014. George II Jul 2018 #10
Washington Post story that was the source for this RawStory post csziggy Jul 2018 #11
I'm trying not to say I told you so. Anon-C Jul 2018 #12
Political operatives (or analysts/pundits/whatever) are probably the slimiest critters erronis Jul 2018 #16
I have been waiting for the books telling the story about this campaign! yallerdawg Jul 2018 #18
Uh oh RandySF Jul 2018 #26
This is why folks should be cautious about supporting Alexandria underthematrix Jul 2018 #34
What's to be cautious about? theaocp Jul 2018 #71
I was just given my third notice for bigotry and insensitivity underthematrix Jul 2018 #73
K&R Scurrilous Jul 2018 #39
I'm cool with the idea that Bernie The_jackalope Jul 2018 #40
Grief. Et tu? Duppers Jul 2018 #47
Guilty by association? left-of-center2012 Jul 2018 #41
Thank you!! Duppers Jul 2018 #49
Not analogous. Devine worked for Gore and Kerry in 2000 and 2004, BEFORE pnwmom Jul 2018 #50
Sounds like Tad may have "evolved" after so many losses. He clearly lied about his association.... Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #55
Did he? WHere? RandomAccess Jul 2018 #81
Apparently he got paid in 2014, when he was already talking to Sanders. Scary. bettyellen Jul 2018 #103
I was asking about where he lied -- RandomAccess Jul 2018 #105
Apparently he said they hadn't worked together since 2010- yet four years later, he cashed checks bettyellen Jul 2018 #108
Thanks RandomAccess Jul 2018 #117
There appears to be a bit of overlap for Devine w Manafort and the Russian and his bettyellen Jul 2018 #120
Does this mean that,,,,, Cryptoad Jul 2018 #46
A useful... comradebillyboy Jul 2018 #129
Put some of that dunder towards November. If there's anything to it Mueller's got it ... marble falls Jul 2018 #51
As a Sanders supporter in the primary..... Boomer Jul 2018 #53
You're ruining the moment. There are people who want us all to draw one conclusion... rainin Jul 2018 #58
Jill Stein IS a Putin troll. she is spewing the Clinton uranium one bs JI7 Jul 2018 #84
Yes, she is. I don't think Bernie is. Sorry I was unclear. rainin Jul 2018 #86
I trust Bernie on this. His campaign was very genuine and he's honorable mvd Jul 2018 #96
That's basically how I feel, too. nt pnwmom Jul 2018 #64
The voice of reason LiberalLovinLug Jul 2018 #68
I think the issue is, was his chief political strategist aware of it? George II Jul 2018 #69
That's it in a nutshell. herding cats Jul 2018 #76
We also have to accept that threads like this -- RandomAccess Jul 2018 #82
Putin wins either way Boomer Jul 2018 #87
Bernie has cast some curious votes re: Russia, and totally out of synch with his Dem colleagues.... Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #85
So I looked up this statement Boomer Jul 2018 #99
And it's been going on here for a long time no less. Magnitsky Act, Magnitsky Act, KPN Jul 2018 #111
Cool cover story if you believe his reasons for not voting with Democrats on two Russia bills. Tarheel_Dem Jul 2018 #125
I wouldn't be surprised rockfordfile Jul 2018 #97
Russia's goal is to divide Democrats. tiredtoo Jul 2018 #65
Oh, it doesn't really matter DavidDvorkin Jul 2018 #72
I really don't think it affected the campaign mvd Jul 2018 #75
He is the only Senator to vote against both the Magnitsky Act and Russia Sanctions. George II Jul 2018 #83
Not weighing in on the main issue of this thread cause it is just shit slinging GulfCoast66 Jul 2018 #88
I disagree all around - except the trouble these threads cause mvd Jul 2018 #89
More disinformation against Sanders? Boomer Jul 2018 #100
Despite being repeatedly corrected on this, AtomicKitten Jul 2018 #133
Wow..Devine worked on both Gore and Kerry's campaign and then with Manafort Power 2 the People Jul 2018 #107
That he is a whore? Pachamama Jul 2018 #110
I think you're right Pachamama Power 2 the People Jul 2018 #112
Much to do about absolutely nothing. Did anyone here actually look at the evidence list KPN Jul 2018 #113
Tad & his company is STILL working for bernie. btw. Wwcd Jul 2018 #116
Never cared much for sanders... Maxheader Jul 2018 #123
Somebody should have told Bernie that nobody was allowed to run against Hillary Power 2 the People Jul 2018 #128
Excellent advice. NurseJackie Jul 2018 #131
Interesting. (nt) ehrnst Jul 2018 #132

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
42. Usually it's an aggregator but sometimes it publishes its own stories,
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:03 PM
Jul 2018

which is what happened this time.

They went through the court document and reported on it.

BigmanPigman

(51,584 posts)
43. Putin used everyone to attack his enemy...HILLARY!
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:03 PM
Jul 2018

The fucking moron, Bernie, Stein were all tools in her defeat. OOPS! I am wrong. HILLARY was NOT defeated, she WON the popular vote!

Skid Rogue

(711 posts)
122. 100%
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 07:07 PM
Jul 2018

I remember marveling at all the weird Russian connections, on the left and the right, during the election. The tragic thing is, segments of the left fell for the lies against Hillary hook, line and sinker. I feel most sorry for the young liberals. The media attack was so well coordinated that many of them, with less political experience and no true memories of the Clintons, had no real way to sift through the lies. I don't even think it crossed their minds that they were being used.

BigmanPigman

(51,584 posts)
124. Other people were influenced by the polls and assumed Hillary would win
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 09:18 PM
Jul 2018

so they voted third party or wrote in "Bernie" as a form of protest. I know someone who is a life long Dem and fol.owed the BS polls. BAD IDEA! My dad always taught me to "ignore polls and studies". They are not a litmus test nor are they accurate. Any poll or study can be skewed. A lot of people, including Obama...who has admitted it, made decisions and choices based on polling and assumptions and this is what happens...TRUMP'S DESTRUCTION OF THE COUNTRY!

Crutchez_CuiBono

(7,725 posts)
118. Just tired of being responsible for him all the time.
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 04:18 PM
Jul 2018

Do your thing dude. He caucuses w the Democrats bc he benefits from it as well. Glad he does, but, let's get real about the whole Independent thing.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
17. So what?
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:49 PM
Jul 2018

We are doing conspiracy theory and using guilt by association here. It worked for Limbaugh for years.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
21. No, and that is nothing new.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:54 PM
Jul 2018

What is the significance of that fact beyond speculation and conspiracy theory.

Maven

(10,533 posts)
31. The new information is that he worked with Manafort and Kilimnik through 2014
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:08 PM
Jul 2018

The same year he joined Bernie's campaign.

Four years after he said he had stopped working with them.

Response to Maven (Reply #31)

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
78. But the insinuation that he did anything wrong, anywhere, ever
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 07:19 PM
Jul 2018

(in the absence of information to the contrary, which I've not seen) most certainly IS in the realm of conspiracy theory. And it's pretty unattractive.

But I'm not surprised, given the Bernie hatred that exists and is allowed here at DU.

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
95. Yes, but not Bernie himself --
Fri Jul 20, 2018, 12:07 PM
Jul 2018

I can see the misunderstanding. The Bernie hatred extends to anyone who ever associated with him or supported him, basically.

KPN

(15,642 posts)
104. Right -- Bernie's obviously guilty by association here. Do we even know what Devine is guilty of?
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:40 PM
Jul 2018

Having worked with Manafort or having done something criminal?

Response to KPN (Reply #104)

 

Wwcd

(6,288 posts)
119. That broadbursh is simply not true. There are many bernie supporters who are
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 04:24 PM
Jul 2018

respected & indeed true in their political beliefs.

They are not hated at all, they are respected.





 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
94. Best thing to do is pretend any accurate news story is simply hatred and bias.
Fri Jul 20, 2018, 11:34 AM
Jul 2018

Otherwise, we may end up seeing our sacred cows for what they are, regardless of your nap-time.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
15. They predate his involvement with Russia and Manafort.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:46 PM
Jul 2018

This is an investigation into Russian involvement in the 2016 election and the agents who helped spread their influence here in the US. Devine appears to be linked to that in some capacity in Manaforts investigation.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
20. Yes, but if Tad is bad, how does that involve Bernie?
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:52 PM
Jul 2018

Since their is no real information here, we can speculate forever. Self-reinforcement is fun. T_Rump is addicted to it.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
24. Tad Devine is named by Mueller.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:57 PM
Jul 2018

That he worked for Bernie Sanders in the same year as he is mentioned in an investigation into Russian involvement in our elections is a fact. Are the optics bad? Yes, definitely.

That's not speculation. It's a fact that needs to be addressed.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
28. By Mueller.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:03 PM
Jul 2018

Speculation based solely on optics is a tactic used by T-Rump. This twitter thread is filled with ridiculous, non-productive divisive rhetoric.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
30. This is a DU post, not a twitter thread.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:06 PM
Jul 2018

I'm confused. Are you equating Mueller's investigation to Trump's tactics?

dogman

(6,073 posts)
33. Right.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:14 PM
Jul 2018

Last edited Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:40 PM - Edit history (1)

Same sentiments on some posts on this thread were on a Twittter link posted earlier. Forgot where I was. I'm not challenging your post but the speculation about what it means.

added: see post #8 for twitter link.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
93. To address late your edit.
Fri Jul 20, 2018, 04:49 AM
Jul 2018

I'm sorry, I missed it for a long time.

See this reply to you by me after our exchange here. It covers this part, but I'll expound below.

https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1014&pid=2114158

I can't understand the head in the sand strategy I keep reading. To me, it's like everyone is so busy fighting amongst themselves they can't think clearly anymore.

Maybe I should be more clear here myself. I'm not fighting with anyone. We just need to be on our toes and smarter in 2018 and beyond. We need to think bigger and broader and be better citizens. We need to accept that we could be vulnerable to interference, too. We are, but I'm not not saying Devine is compromised, because we don't know yet. However, he is a weak link per this evidence he was still involved on some level with Manafort after previous claims he saw Ukraine being influenced by Russia and had removed himself after his 2010 work ended. His surrogates who spread this information weren't being honest. That's something to pay attention to now.

We do know Putin did try to exploit Bernie's campaign to weaken Hillary. That was reported back in February of this year (I think?) in the previous round of indictments. We need to be smart now. Then we need to recognize Putin's dealings and stop it before it destroys us all.

Most of all, we need to make sure no one with ties to Russia sinks their hooks in any of our candidates. I believe that will be a final death rattle of a Democratic political career now.

tldr version: we need to not be stupid and hire people like Tad Devine who have ties to helping Putin, and we shouldn't waste our time defending people like him. That's Devine's job and he actually knows the debth, and details. We don't. Oh, and we need to stop being tribal to the point we're dancing around and making excuses for Putin's interferences in our democracy.

Sherman A1

(38,958 posts)
36. Precisely
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:25 PM
Jul 2018

but, guilt by association works well for those who choose to accept the tactic. Had he worked for another candidate me thinks there would be nary a peep.

 

Wwcd

(6,288 posts)
38. Lol. Nary a peep from that side, but Woo Boy would the other side be howling!
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:45 PM
Jul 2018

Works both ways.

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
48. That's just it, he would never have even been asked "another candidate", so "nary a peep"....
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:10 PM
Jul 2018

was needed. I'm assuming when you say "another candidate", you mean the Clinton campaign?

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
127. No she wouldn't. He would've been vetted, and his associations would have prevented him from EVER..
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 10:42 PM
Jul 2018

joining the Clinton campaign.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
32. Of course they do.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:12 PM
Jul 2018

As I said the optics are bad. Actually, they're terrible. This doesn't negate anything, and if anything it creates all the more reason why it needs to be discussed intelligently.

Which doesn't mean dismissing it out of hand as a Trump tactic. This happened. This is real.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
35. Not discussing it intelligently.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:20 PM
Jul 2018

T-Rump would never do that. To talk intelligently we need to go beyond a Kevin Bacon game. Bernie is not named in these lists. Why shouldn't we look at all of Tad's previous employers?

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
37. Bernie is going to be mentioned because his Chief Strategist was mentioned by Mueller
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:27 PM
Jul 2018

Devine also was apparently still involved with Manafort in 2014, not 2010 as previously claimed. Which removed a layer of deniability. 2014 is the same year he went to work for Bernie. Now Devine is involved in the investigation into the Russians involvement in 2016. This. Looks. Bad.

People are naturally going to connect the dots as they appear. This needs to be addressed not ignored.

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
54. Buckle up. This is going to get very bumpy for the Sanders campaign. We already know that Russia..
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:20 PM
Jul 2018

was doing its best to aid all of Hillary's competitors. That's just a fact. What's uncomfortable for you is that the campaign managers for two of those competitors were in business together, and this smells to high heaven of collusion. Tad Devine is probably a Russian asset just like Manafort, and they happened to manage the campaigns of DJT & BS. Hmmmmm......

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
59. Because Devine lied about when he quit working with Manafort? If it was 2010, why was he still...
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:31 PM
Jul 2018

invoicing in 2014 when he was managing the Sanders campaign?

dogman

(6,073 posts)
62. And Gore lost an election he won, and Kerry lost an election he should have won.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:36 PM
Jul 2018

Why? Seems Devine was up to something. Maybe Bernie got to close to the Democratic Party by hiring him?

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
80. I think the invoice was from June while
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 07:25 PM
Jul 2018

Devine joined Sanders in November. Read back upthread to make sure I've got that right. But I don't think there was the overlap you suggest.

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
45. Bernie is involved because Devine was in touch with Kilminick, the intelligence officer,
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:07 PM
Jul 2018

asking for "talking points," just months before he officially hired on with Bernie in November.

And Politico wrote in March 2016 about a campaign brainstorming meeting Devine had had with Bernie and others around March 2014.

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
63. My theory is that Manafort's trial will start next week and we'll know more.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:39 PM
Jul 2018

I personally doubt Bernie was complicit, but it's harder for me to believe Devine was in the dark. He was the one who sent the email asking the Russian, Kliminick, for "talking points" between a March 2014 pre-campaign meeting with Bernie and getting hired officially in November.

If Devine is involved, then his Old Towne Media company is probably getting looked at. Devine made a lot of money during the campaign through there.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
66. Agreed.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:47 PM
Jul 2018

But Devine was involved in other failed Democratic Presidential campaigns. If he is corrupt, how corrupt is he? And if it's guilt by association, we have to remember he was a long time Democratic operative, so that seems a slippery slope.

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
70. He was involved with them in 2000 and 2004, prior to getting mixed up
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 06:05 PM
Jul 2018

with the Putin bunch, which seems to have started in 2006.

And yeah, it's a slippery slope, but we can't ignore it if/when it happens on our side of the hill.

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
44. Because 2000 and 2004 were both BEFORE 2006, the first time
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:04 PM
Jul 2018

Devine seems to have worked for the Ukrainian.

George II

(67,782 posts)
10. Not just "in contact", they worked together for years, and communicated most recently in 2014.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:43 PM
Jul 2018

Devine Mulvey Longabaugh, mentioned several times in the exhibit list (including invoices to Manafort) was the 9th highest recipient of funds from the Sanders campaign (about $5.2M)

csziggy

(34,136 posts)
11. Washington Post story that was the source for this RawStory post
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:44 PM
Jul 2018
Special counsel has nearly 500 pieces of evidence for Paul Manafort trial
by Rachel Weiner July 19 at 11:50 AM

Pictures of Paul Manafort’s homes, cars, $21,000 watch and high-end clothing may be displayed for jurors at his trial beginning in Alexandria federal court next week, according to a list of nearly 500 potential exhibits published by prosecutors Wednesday evening.

<SNIP>

There will also be email communication between Manafort, President Trump’s former campaign chairman, and Tad Devine, a Democratic consultant who worked for the same Ukrainian politician.

It is the work Manafort did for Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych and his political party that is at the center of the criminal charges against him in both Alexandria and D.C. federal court.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/special-counsel-has-nearly-500-pieces-of-evidence-for-paul-manafort-trial/2018/07/19/31686cb2-8b68-11e8-a345-a1bf7847b375_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.75e63b6d5a98


The New York Post has even more information on the Manafort-Devine linkage:

Evidence against Manafort includes emails to Bernie’s top strategist

By Bob Fredericks
July 19, 2018 | 3:16pm

Special counsel Robert Mueller has released a list of 500 potential exhibits for Paul Manafort’s upcoming trial, including photos of his homes, cars, a pricey watch — and emails between Manafort and Tad Devine, Bernie Sanders’ top strategist in the presidential campaign.

Devine, a veteran political strategist, worked for Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych and his pro-Kremlin Party of Regions at the time, as did Manafort, the Washington Post reported.

Their email exchanges continued until the spring of 2014, and Devine went to work for Sanders later that year.

Devine — who worked for Sanders in the 1990s and also worked as an aide to Al Gore, John Kerry and Michael Dukakis on their campaigns — also communicated with Rick Gates, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy and making false statements in the Mueller probe, according to the filing.

His name appears 16 times in the documents.

More: https://nypost.com/2018/07/19/evidence-against-manafort-includes-emails-to-bernies-top-strategist/

erronis

(15,228 posts)
16. Political operatives (or analysts/pundits/whatever) are probably the slimiest critters
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:48 PM
Jul 2018

After the congressional ones. And even worse than new/old car salespeople (new and old ones.)

When a politician chooses an operative he/she is knowingly entering into a relationship that might help and can hurt their cause. It's too early to cast aspersions on Bernie but I'd really like to know the background. (Same for the Podestas and Rahm Immanuel and the sleezebags that follow the repuglcons everywhere.)

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
18. I have been waiting for the books telling the story about this campaign!
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 03:49 PM
Jul 2018

Now I'll have to read testimony from a trial?

That explains why no books!

underthematrix

(5,811 posts)
34. This is why folks should be cautious about supporting Alexandria
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:17 PM
Jul 2018

because Russia doesn't care which side we're on. Their goal is to take down the US

I'm not saying go negative about any first time DEM candidate. All I'm saying is be cautious.

underthematrix

(5,811 posts)
73. I was just given my third notice for bigotry and insensitivity
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 06:20 PM
Jul 2018

So I'm going to reply in a way that I hope will make you happy.

I like her. I congratulated her. I've retweeted some of her really great tweets. I'm just saying she's spreading her wings wide and fast and in that sense we should be careful about helping her nationalize her campaign. We don't know where her money is coming from. We don't know who's advising her.

I think she's a great candidate and a winnable one for her district.

The_jackalope

(1,660 posts)
40. I'm cool with the idea that Bernie
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:53 PM
Jul 2018

is a Russian agent of influence. Same goes for Jill "Red is the new Green" Stein. There are too many coincidences swirling around both of them for me to believe otherwise.

Hillary was clean.

Duppers

(28,117 posts)
47. Grief. Et tu?
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:09 PM
Jul 2018

We don't know the details yet?

I'll wait before I stomp but if there is damaging information, I shall scream.


left-of-center2012

(34,195 posts)
41. Guilty by association?
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 04:55 PM
Jul 2018

"Devine and Sanders had worked together on campaigns in the 1990s,
and the Democratic strategist has also worked as a campaign aide to Al Gore, John Kerry, and Michael Dukakis."

pnwmom

(108,974 posts)
50. Not analogous. Devine worked for Gore and Kerry in 2000 and 2004, BEFORE
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:13 PM
Jul 2018

he started work in the first Putin guy's campaign (2006.)

None of the evidence Mueller included in his list involved either Gore or Kerry.

It did however show emails involving Devine and Manafort, Gates, Kilminick in April and June of 2014. In the June meeting Devine asked KK for "talking points."

Politico wrote in March 2016 about a campaign brainstorming meeting Devine had with Bernie about March 2014. He officially joined the campaign in November 2014.

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
55. Sounds like Tad may have "evolved" after so many losses. He clearly lied about his association....
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:23 PM
Jul 2018

with Manafort.

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
105. I was asking about where he lied --
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:46 PM
Jul 2018

those may be facts you've cited, but as written it doesn't describe a lie. Can you be more explicit?

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
108. Apparently he said they hadn't worked together since 2010- yet four years later, he cashed checks
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:55 PM
Jul 2018

And sought advice on talking points from Ine of the Russians (while beginning work for Sanders). The overlap there looks pretty damning. I doubt Sanders has any idea.

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
117. Thanks
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 02:39 PM
Jul 2018

I'm still unclear on the timeline - and therefore the true facts -- but at least I understand what the allegation is all about.

 

bettyellen

(47,209 posts)
120. There appears to be a bit of overlap for Devine w Manafort and the Russian and his
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 06:14 PM
Jul 2018

Early meetings w Bernie. I’d not be shocked if they found some common ground.

marble falls

(57,073 posts)
51. Put some of that dunder towards November. If there's anything to it Mueller's got it ...
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:17 PM
Jul 2018

under control.

Didn't Jimmy Carter at one time or another monitor elections there, too?

Boomer

(4,168 posts)
53. As a Sanders supporter in the primary.....
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:19 PM
Jul 2018

I would not be surprised to learn that there were Russian operatives in the campaign because it appears the Russians were infiltrating any political crevice where they could get a grip and chip away at Clinton's campaign.

I would not be surprised to learn that the operatives influenced decisions in the Sanders campaign because that was the whole point, right? To get into positions of influence and destabilize our nation.

I WOULD, however, be surprised to learn that Bernie Sanders was aware of that infiltration and the Russian agenda within his campaign. But if evidence emerges that this was the case, I'd listen. Because I expect Trump and the GOPers to listen. We have to accept that the tentacles of this assault on our democracy run far and dive deep. Now it's a matter of finding them all.

rainin

(3,011 posts)
58. You're ruining the moment. There are people who want us all to draw one conclusion...
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 05:28 PM
Jul 2018

that Bernie and Jill Stein colluded with the Russians to defeat Hillary Clinton. It won't matter than there is no evidence that Bernie did anything of the sort. He was a candidate who ran a strong campaign against Hillary and was defeated in the primary. There are many Bernie supporters here at DU who supported Hillary in the general.

The Bernie haters never stop.

JI7

(89,246 posts)
84. Jill Stein IS a Putin troll. she is spewing the Clinton uranium one bs
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 07:48 PM
Jul 2018

and she was in the meeting with putin and other Russians along with flynn.

mvd

(65,172 posts)
96. I trust Bernie on this. His campaign was very genuine and he's honorable
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 02:48 AM
Jul 2018

Bernie has always been a moderate on Russia. And I agree to an extent. They are an adversary and the meddling must be strongly responded to. But we do not want war.

herding cats

(19,559 posts)
76. That's it in a nutshell.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 06:25 PM
Jul 2018

It's even possible, at this point, Devine was an unwitting asset to Putin. If he was one at all. All that remains to be seen as this unfolds. In any case, a little forewarning isn't ever a bad thing.

We need to address the situation head on and learn from it. I don't want to see any Democrats falling prey to Russia ever again. Wittingly, unwittingly or as targets. One way we avoid that is by learning from what took place in 2016.

 

RandomAccess

(5,210 posts)
82. We also have to accept that threads like this --
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 07:42 PM
Jul 2018

SO divisive, SO eager to paint our own, our friends, our allies as dangerous political enemies or traitors, serves Putin's agenda very, very well.

TBH, I don't know if Devine is dirty, but I don't think so -- certainly not from what I've learned so far, which isn't much. AFAIC, that Devine invoiced Manafort means nothing without a lot more context and detail. MANAFORT's the one on trial. Let's wait to damn and condemn Devine until we have some actual dirt on him. Just showing up as a Manafort vendor doesn't get us there IMO.

Let's see, for example, if he shows up as one of those getting immunity for testifying against Manafort. Let's see if he gets indicted or pleads.

None of that has happened yet -- that we know of. And, in the meantime, Putin wins.

Boomer

(4,168 posts)
87. Putin wins either way
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 08:11 PM
Jul 2018

Let's say, just for the sake of argument, that Devine is NOT under Russian influence, directly or indirectly. His association with Manafort undermines his credibility, there's no denying that, and the debate over his guilt or innocence divides one faction of voters. His influence wanes.

Let's say, just for the sake of argument, that Devine IS acting with Russia's interests in mind. The debate over his guilt or innocence rages, but he still continues to maintain some credibility with people who steadfastly believe in his innocence.

My inclination was to extend the benefit of the doubt, just on principle, until someone on DU or Twitter (losing track, events are moving so quickly) posted some of the absolutely vile and vicious things Devine has said about Clinton. And that did give me pause. If he's not a Russian tool, he's just as bad as one.

Boomer

(4,168 posts)
99. So I looked up this statement
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:26 PM
Jul 2018

And was quite relieved to find that Bernie Sanders DID vote for a stronger version of the Magnitsky Act. Now I'm wondering why someone is trying to spread the disinformation that he was against it.

KPN

(15,642 posts)
111. And it's been going on here for a long time no less. Magnitsky Act, Magnitsky Act,
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 01:06 PM
Jul 2018

Magnitsky Act with no consideration of actual facts. You are not the first to make this point.

Strikes me as all about fealty frankly.

Tarheel_Dem

(31,232 posts)
125. Cool cover story if you believe his reasons for not voting with Democrats on two Russia bills.
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 10:05 PM
Jul 2018

I don't believe his reasons, and if you do, more power to you.

mvd

(65,172 posts)
75. I really don't think it affected the campaign
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 06:25 PM
Jul 2018

Bernie was never weak on Russia at all. Still, it shows how their connections have been everywhere. With Trump of course the biggest one!

George II

(67,782 posts)
83. He is the only Senator to vote against both the Magnitsky Act and Russia Sanctions.
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 07:44 PM
Jul 2018

Those votes were 92-4 and 98-2, respectively.

GulfCoast66

(11,949 posts)
88. Not weighing in on the main issue of this thread cause it is just shit slinging
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 08:48 PM
Jul 2018

But you are wrong about Bernie and Russia. He has been very weak. One of 4 votes against the Magintsky act and one of 2 against increased sanctions to punish them for attacking our election system.

We already know that Russia actively supported Bernie in the primary and after. It was in the initial report. It is only a matter of time till we learn the details. Even though Bernie was not aware the details will not be pretty.

Fuck Russia.

mvd

(65,172 posts)
89. I disagree all around - except the trouble these threads cause
Thu Jul 19, 2018, 08:53 PM
Jul 2018

He has never been weak on Russia. Agree with it or not, he wanted to protect the Iran deal with his sanctions vote. He has had plenty of votes against Russia. Have to look at the whole record. And I expect no more bad details on Bernie to come out.

Boomer

(4,168 posts)
100. More disinformation against Sanders?
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:30 PM
Jul 2018

These allegations against Sanders motivated me to dig deeper and what I found was that Sanders voted against weak versions of the Magnitsky Act and FOR the stronger version.

So yeah, we're all being played in every way possible.

 

AtomicKitten

(46,585 posts)
133. Despite being repeatedly corrected on this,
Tue Jul 24, 2018, 12:53 PM
Jul 2018

some just ignore this fact and continue to repeat the narrative that was crafted to damage Bernie by any means necessary. I am amazed/appalled by the dis/misinformation being peddled here where truth has been rendered irrelevant.

Pachamama

(16,886 posts)
110. That he is a whore?
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 12:57 PM
Jul 2018

That he goes where the money and opportunity is to make it.....

The real question is - Who was paying?

Power 2 the People

(2,437 posts)
112. I think you're right Pachamama
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 01:09 PM
Jul 2018

Maybe he is just a hired gun who works on any campaign that will hire him. It would appear that his loyalty is to a paycheck rather than an ideology. Looks like the Gore,Kerry and Sanders campaigns were just hiring an employee who knew the logistics of running a presidential campaign.

I guess a perfect example would be Kelly Ann Conway. She butchered Trump for Cruz in the primaries. Once Trump hired her he could do no wrong. Political operatives like this serve only one person - themselves.

KPN

(15,642 posts)
113. Much to do about absolutely nothing. Did anyone here actually look at the evidence list
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 01:13 PM
Jul 2018

submitted by Mueller? I did (link below to article with pdf). Likely this is simply about clearly connecting Manafort to the laundered money. The emails go to show what work was being done for whom and by whom.

Nothing incriminating re: Devine at this point. Seems like there would have been an indictment of him as well had there been a reason for doing so.

Meh.

 

Wwcd

(6,288 posts)
116. Tad & his company is STILL working for bernie. btw.
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 01:24 PM
Jul 2018

Figures.
We see it everywhere.
That little Devine/Manafort connection needs to be blown wide open.
Thank you Robert Mueller.

Power 2 the People

(2,437 posts)
128. Somebody should have told Bernie that nobody was allowed to run against Hillary
Sat Jul 21, 2018, 11:21 PM
Jul 2018

Would have saved us,the DNC and the Russians a lot of time and aggravation.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Bernie Sanders' campaign ...