Trump's case against Senator Mark Kelly faces steep hurdles under military law
Source: Reuters
November 26, 2025 6:10 AM EST Updated 3 hours ago
NEW YORK, Nov 26 (Reuters) - Threats by the Trump administration to recall Senator Mark Kelly to active Navy duty, and to prosecute him under military law for urging troops to disobey illegal orders, would face steep hurdles in a system designed to give troops strong rights to due process, according to seven military law experts.
Kelly and five other Democratic lawmakers with military or intelligence backgrounds posted videos about disobeying illegal orders that Trump called "dangerous" and "seditious." The FBI and the Department of Defense are investigating. Democrats have criticized the president's decisions to attack boats allegedly carrying drugs to the U.S. from Latin America and to deploy the National Guard to police American cities. Kelly told servicemembers in the video: "Our laws are clear: you can refuse illegal orders."
Military cases usually involve clear violations because they first have to undergo multiple rounds of investigation and legal approval before reaching a judge, who can dismiss charges that don't pass legal muster. Kelly's case is not clear-cut, and several legal experts told Reuters they did not think he broke the law.
Victor Hansen, a former military prosecutor and professor at New England Law Boston, said it was one thing for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to threaten a court-martial and another for it to take place. “It would be a mistake to assume that Pete Hegseth can by fiat say, `OK we’re going to court-martial.` That's not going to happen," Hansen said in an interview.
Read more: https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/trumps-case-against-senator-mark-kelly-faces-steep-hurdles-under-military-law-2025-11-26/
= new reply since forum marked as read
