Slate: William Barr Has Failed America
Observers of the Justice Department will spend the rest of our lives talking about Attorney General William Barrs jaw-dropping and horrifically inappropriate address on Thursday morning, which attempted to spin special counsel Robert Muellers report in Donald Trumps favorbefore the public has seen it. In just a few minutes, Barr managed to throw Mueller under the bus, mount a Fox Newsstyle defense of Trump, and further obscure his dubious decision to absolve the president of obstruction of justice. It is hard to convey just how appalling Barrs performance was, and it will take a while to assess the extent of the damage Barr just inflicted on the Department of Justice and the office of the attorney general. But let me take a first crack: This was Pravda-style propaganda, pure and simple, a grotesque display of spineless fealty to the president, and a confirmation that Barr views the Mueller investigation as fundamentally illegitimate.
The first half of Barrs address was essentially a reiteration of his earlier summary of Muellers report, which the attorney general helpfully summed up in Trumps two favorite words: no collusion. Mueller, Barr explained, found that the Russian government did unlawfully attempt to influence the 2016 election; both Russian military officials and the Internet Research Agency, a troll farm affiliated with the Russian government, meddled in the race. But the special counsel found no evidence that any Americansincluding anyone associated with the Trump campaignconspired or coordinated with the Russian government or the IRA in carrying out this illegal scheme.
We do not yet know if Barr used this oddly narrow language to conceal attempts by the Trump campaign to collude with Russian agents, or to disseminate stolen material; to obscure possible coordination with Russian nationals not formally connected to the Russian government; or to obfuscate an extremely cramped definition of conspiracy and collusion. The report itself should help us understand just how candid or dishonest, this segment of Barrs address was. And hopefully, Barr did not redact portions of the report that might clear up any sleights of hand the attorney general may have performed to gloss over legally troubling conduct by the president and his associates.
What we do know is that the presidents national security adviser, Michael Flynn, spoke with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak the same day that President Barack Obama issued retaliatory measures in response to Russias interference in the 2016 election. And that Mueller later prosecuted Flynn for lying to FBI agents about his contacts with Russian officials. And that Flynn pleaded guilty to this felony charge and cooperated with the probe. And then Trump asked thenFBI Director James Comey to end the investigation into Flynn.
We also know that Trumps former lawyer, Michael Cohen, pleaded guilty to campaign finance violations committed in an effort to cover up Trumps extramarital affaira crime allegedly committed at the presidents direction, and one that was prosecuted by the Southern District of New York after the special counsels office provided it with information about Cohen. And we know that Cohen pleaded guilty to lying to Congress about the Trump Organizations attempts to build a new property in Moscow during the presidential campaign. Cohen, in fact, admitted to this crime as part of a plea deal with Mueller.
This information is important to keep in mind when considering the second half of Barrs address, pertaining to obstruction of justice. Barr once again reiterated that he does not believe in Muellers legal theory of obstruction. He didnt elaborate, but his views here are well-known: Barr believes obstruction of an investigation cannot be committed unless there is an underlying crime (which is wrong) and that the president cannot commit obstruction by exercising his executive powers, even if done with a corrupt motive (which is dubious). But leave that aside for now. Whats truly astonishing is that after briefly attempting to exculpate Trump of obstruction, Barr launched into a vigorous and gratuitous defense of the presidents highly unusual and suspect behavior throughout the probe.
-more-
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/william-barr-has-failed-america/ar-BBW4t4C?li=BBnb7Kz
ScratchCat
(1,990 posts)"Thats not legal analysis, since righteous anger is not an actual defense against obstruction. Its political spin. Its propaganda. Its running interference for the president who appointed Barr to do precisely thisto exonerate him in public before Americans can read Muellers report. "
"It was a galling performance for an audience of one, the president. And Trump must be pleased. In fact, the moment the presser ended, the president posted a Game of Thronesthemed tweet telling the haters and the radical left Democrats that it was Game Over. Barrs performance and Trumps tweet seemed almost coordinated. It is an extraordinary embarrassment for DOJ."
Timmygoat
(779 posts)He looked like he had been drugged to stand there, he had a vacant expression on his face, of course he must have know he was
acting as a backdrop for a liar.
duforsure
(11,885 posts)And ignored the oath he took , and lied to Congress knowing what he was going to do. He will regret this hopefully when the system of justice prevails , and he's sent to prison. Barr will regret this if Mueller has any say about all this. Mueller won't let this injustice stand , so he'll be next trump starts suggesting he be criminalized by the dotj , Department of trump Justice where he is the judge , jury, and executioner.