Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 03:47 PM Nov 2019

SuperGIRL? Shouldn't that be SuperWOMAN?

-

SuperGIRL? Shouldn't that be SuperWOMAN?
2019-01-20 05:54 PM PDT

BACK IN THE SIXTIES when I was just a young pup, Supergirl was my first crush. What the hell, I was just a kid, but I still like the fact that the woman could kick some ass just like her male cousin, and she's even beaten him a time or two.

Thinking about that got me wondering, why Supergirl instead of Superwoman? Why is she called a girl, while her cousin is called a man? I mean, come on, they didn't call Wonder Woman, Wonder Girl, did they? Although, I do wonder how that would've went over?

I don't follow the comic world as closely as when I was a kid, so I have no idea if they even care, but it was brought up in the first Season of the Supergirl TV series starring Melissa Benoist as my first crush come back to life.

In the series, Calista Flockhart, playing the owner of an immense Newspaper Empire, Cat Grant, is the one who names her. She also just happens to be Supergirl's boss. The idea doesn't sit well with Kara Danvers, Supergirl's secret identity, and she even ask her why Supergirl? Why not Superwoman?

Her answer was that all woman are girls, aren't they? It was pretty dramatic, but to me, it was lame.

It's interesting to note that the very first Supergirl was actually called Superwoman.

In a 1943 DC comic, Action Comics #60 (May 1943), Lois Lane dreams she's a companion to Superman. I haven't read it, so I'm not really sure how that worked, but in that comic, she's called Superwoman.

It wasn't until 1959, Action Comics #252 (May 1959), that the most familiar version was introduced, and she was called Supergirl instead of Superwoman. It was the Fifties, and woman were still considered inferior to men, and that's probably the real reason she was called a girl. I'm sure some people must've complained, but obviously that didn't change anything.

Personally, I like the fact that she's called Supergirl, and it has nothing to do with woman being inferior to men.

Every single reference in English to the opposite sex, female, woman, she, and her, all of them somehow refer back to the male, like without them, women wouldn't be able to exist. Even Lady, I think, refers to a lad, the younger version of a man, and don't get me started on Ma'am, Madam, Mrs., Miss or Ms., because they all refer back to M for Male.

I have to laugh, because that all seems so petty, but it's important none the less. It's important, because the only exception that isn't derogatory is girl. It's the only one that doesn't reference back to a man somehow, and that's what I like about it.

Another reason I like it is because it's so deceptive. She's only a girl, what can she do? Obviously, those people conveniently forget that Supergirl beat her cousin a few times, and they're also clueless about Fearless Girl too.

In case you've been living under a rock for the past decade, Fearless Girl is a small statue in New York. It was only a small statue of a girl, but what caused the uproar was that she was facing the Wall Street Bull and daring it to charge her. That's my take on it anyway, and I had to laugh again, because what were they all worried about? After all, she's just a girl, what can she do?

She can do plenty and being a girl doesn't change a thing. It's like girls are the secret identities of the Superheroes all women really are.

It's too bad men, me included, can't see and appreciate that more often.

History is replete with examples of women being called on to step it up when men couldn't. World War II is the perfect example. Women stayed home and did the jobs men left behind, and they were awesome at it.

And, did you know that when the codes for the original computers were written, almost all of it was written by women?

Today, it's mostly a male profession, and not many of them seem to remember the contribution that woman made to their own history.

As a matter of fact, not too long ago, there was a big fuss over at Google when a manifesto was released explaining why women weren't qualified to write software. The guy who wrote it obviously didn't know his history either.

Ironically, social media is doing a hell of a job in helping to change those perceptions, and the #MeToo movement is a good example. It's moving fast too, and that gives me hope that maybe I'll still be around when equality for everyone finally does go global for real.

Besides social media, another interesting trend that I've noticed are women referring to themselves as grrls, or grrrls, and if you look up Riot grrrl on Wikipedia, you'll see what I mean.

Hmm, Supergrrrl?

I like it.

-
FROM: http://www.amystrange.org/BLG-2019-01.html#201754a
I wrote this article/editorial at the beginning of this year (2019-01-20)
-


Dave,
the Real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
SuperGIRL? Shouldn't that be SuperWOMAN? (Original Post) Amy-Strange Nov 2019 OP
No. hurple Nov 2019 #1
That's the backstory I remember. Igel Nov 2019 #2
I just had a crush... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #8
I explained about Superwoman... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #7
I'm not up on my super heroes radical noodle Nov 2019 #11
Wonder Woman? Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #16
Perhaps this was just miscommunication radical noodle Nov 2019 #20
It's comics hurple Nov 2019 #14
And don't forget... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #17
On the first episode of the t.v. show, Kara makes that argument to Cat Grant. LastLiberal in PalmSprings Nov 2019 #3
I did explain that... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #6
I agree, it was lame. The writers were trying to build a lot of back story in one LastLiberal in PalmSprings Nov 2019 #15
Good question... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #18
Supergirl may be an ageist spin-off, but it is not a sexist one. Marcuse Nov 2019 #4
You might be right... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #10
Message auto-removed Name removed Nov 2019 #5
SJW? Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #9
I had to google it too. SJW means 'Social Justice Warrior'. PatrickforO Nov 2019 #13
division and intolerance... Amy-Strange Nov 2019 #19
You're obvious. n/t demmiblue Nov 2019 #12

Igel

(35,323 posts)
2. That's the backstory I remember.
Sun Nov 3, 2019, 04:13 PM
Nov 2019

She was a girl. When she was introduced, she was in high school. She may have still been in high school when I was a kid; fiction-time doesn't go in lockstep with publication time.

Once she had the name "supergirl" her change in age didn't cause the comic to change name.

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
8. I just had a crush...
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 01:35 PM
Nov 2019

-

and didn't really care about her backstory, but you're right, it has changed over the years,

Dave,
the Real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
7. I explained about Superwoman...
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 01:33 PM
Nov 2019

-

but are we talking about the same thing? Lois Lane was the original, and she was called Superwoman. Is that what you're talking about? Like I explained, I don't really follow the comic world.

The teenager aspect makes sense, but Superboy was called Superman when he grew up,

Dave,
the Real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

radical noodle

(8,005 posts)
20. Perhaps this was just miscommunication
Mon Nov 11, 2019, 11:31 AM
Nov 2019

You said:

but are we talking about the same thing? Lois Lane was the original, and she was called Superwoman. Is that what you're talking about? Like I explained, I don't really follow the comic world.


I simply said Lois Lane was the girlfriend of Superman. She wasn't called Superwoman as far as I ever knew. Or was she?

hurple

(1,306 posts)
14. It's comics
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 06:57 PM
Nov 2019

Supergirl has never really grown up. Whenever the character is aged to that level they reboot the DV universe and she's back to a teenager.

Now Power Girl on the other hand...

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
17. And don't forget...
Mon Nov 11, 2019, 03:11 AM
Nov 2019

-

she also lives in an alternate universe,

Dave,
the Real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
6. I did explain that...
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 01:28 PM
Nov 2019

-

and thanx for the video, but her argument is still lame,

Dave,
the Real AmyStrange,
dug.amystrange.org

-


15. I agree, it was lame. The writers were trying to build a lot of back story in one
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 11:05 PM
Nov 2019

episode, and that part was clearly not as well thought-out as the rest.

Now for the real question: How the hell did Kara get her ears pierced? Bullets can bounce off her chest and she can survive a bomb explosion, but her earlobes are vulnerable to sharp needles? Maybe they were already pierced when she was still on Krypton? Inquiring minds want to know.

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
18. Good question...
Mon Nov 11, 2019, 03:16 AM
Nov 2019

-

and what about her hair, or fingernails, or toenails, unless...

Everything's fake... a lie... or as I like to call it, comic book fiction.

Crap, don't you hate when that happens,

Dave
the real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
10. You might be right...
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 01:46 PM
Nov 2019

-

but the problem I have is why Superboy, when he grew up, became Superman, but Supergirl didn't.

And if you actually read the article I wrote, you'd see that I think calling her Superwoman would be more sexist than keeping her as a girl,

Dave,
the Real AmyStrange
dug.amystrange.org

-

Response to Amy-Strange (Original post)

PatrickforO

(14,585 posts)
13. I had to google it too. SJW means 'Social Justice Warrior'.
Mon Nov 4, 2019, 03:47 PM
Nov 2019

According to Wiki, it is "is a pejorative term for an individual who promotes socially progressive views, including feminism, civil rights, and multiculturalism, as well as identity politics."

In other words, our new friend may be advancing some right-wing talking points. Remember the first thing that happens when power is confronted with the truth about injustice is ridicule. If that doesn't work, then other pressures are applied. And of course, these forces work hard to divide us against one another.

Amy-Strange

(854 posts)
19. division and intolerance...
Mon Nov 11, 2019, 03:18 AM
Nov 2019

-

is what's going to kill us all,

Dave
the Real AmyStrange,
dug.amystrange.org

-

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»SuperGIRL? Shouldn't that...