The Supreme Court's Crisis of Legitimacy
The Supreme Courts Crisis of Legitimacy
CHRIS WINTERS
9 MIN READ
JUL 5, 2022
(
YES! Magazine) The United States of America today is a fundamentally different country than the United States of America three weeks ago.
In this new U.S., the federal government cant regulate carbon emissions from coal-fired power plants under the Clean Air Act because the law, which first passed in 1963, doesnt specifically give the government that power. In addition, local government cannot stop a school official from leading students in prayer. But it can control what happens inside a uterus. But it cant prevent you from carrying a gun in public. But it can assert legal jurisdiction over Native American reservations.
The common thread is the Supreme Court is the most radically
I dont even want to say Conservative, because this court has been throwing out precedents the way Donald Trump flung his lunch across the White House dining room. So
interventionist? Revanchist? Insurrectionist?
....(snip)....
Theres not a lot to say about the Supreme Courts opinion in
Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization, which overturned
Roe v. Wade, that hasnt already been said. The most succinct criticism came from Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Stephen Breyer, and Elena Kagans fiery dissent: The majority has overruled Roe and Casey for one and only one reason: because it has always despised them, and now it has the votes to discard them. The majority thereby substitutes a rule by judges for the rule of law.
....(snip)....
That solidarity now needs to be turned toward specific political objectives, specifically those that will reverse the direction of the countrys drift toward the extreme right: think ensuring fair and free elections at every level, codifying abortion and other civil rights, adding seats to the court and states to the union, and so on. U.S. Rep. Pramila Jayapal of Seattle has already floated the idea of a general womens strike in response to the overturning of Roe, presumably with the intention of prodding the Biden administration into action.
....(snip)....
Maybe its about time the people demonstrate their full power. A general strike can lead to real gains in liberty; just witness Iceland. And when the arbiters of law are undemocratically installed and unaccountable, the lawmakers are corrupted by lobbying and conflicts of interest, and the chief executive actively seeks to overturn an election and gain unlimited powerall conditions that are illegitimate in a democratic societyresistance is the only legitimate democratic force left. ...........(more)
https://www.yesmagazine.org/opinion/2022/07/05/supreme-court-legitimacy-2