The Flight to the Ephemeral | John Michael Greer
R. Buckminster Fuller
Oct. 2, 2013 (Archdruid Report) -- I'd meant to devote this weeks post to exploring the way that new religious movements so often give shape to emerging ideas and social forms during the decline of civilizations, and to sketch out some of the possibilities for action along those lines as industrial society moves further along its own curve of decline and fall.
Still, these essays are part of a broader conversation about the future of todays world, and now and then some other part of that conversation brings up points relevant to the discussion here.
Thats as much excuse as there is for this weeks detour. A few weeks ago, the P2P Foundation website hosted a piece by Kevin Carson titled When Ephemeralization is Hard to Tell from Catabolic Collapse. Carsons piece got some attention recently in the peak oil blogosphere, not to mention some pointed and by no means unjustified criticism. It seems to me, though, that theres a valid point tucked away in Carsons essay; hes got it by the wrong end, and it doesnt imply what he thinks it does, but the point is nonetheless there, and important.
Getting to it, though, requires a certain tolerance for intellectual sloppiness of a kind embarrassingly common in todays culture. When Carson talks about the Jared Diamond/John Michael Greer/William Kunstler theory of catabolic collapse, for example, its hard to escape the conclusion that he simply hasnt taken the time to learn much about his subject. Catabolic collapse, after all, isnt a generic label for collapse in general; its the name for a specific theory about how civilizations fall -- those who are interested can download a PDF here -- which I developed between 2001 and 2004 and published online in a 2005 essay, and the other two names he cited had nothing to do with it.
Mind you, I would be delighted to hear that Jared Diamond supports the theory of catabolic collapse, but as far as I know, hes never mentioned it in print, and the modes of collapse he discusses in his book Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed differ significantly from my model. As for the third author, presumably Carson means James Howard Kunstler, the author of The Long Emergency and Too Much Magic -- very solid books about the approaching end of the industrial age, though once again based on a different theory of collapse -- rather than William Kunstler, the late civil rights lawyer who defended the Chicago Seven back in 1969, and who to the best of my knowledge never discussed the collapse of civilizations at all.
more
http://worldnewstrust.com/the-flight-to-the-ephemeral-john-michael-greer