New Yorker Editor: Not Possible To Evacuate All US Allies From Afghanistan By Aug 31st - MSNBC

[Rhiannon12866]

NewYorker.com executive editor David Rohde, former senior advisor to Defense Secretary Ash Carter, Mark Jacobson, and NBC News’ Pentagon reporter Courtney Kube break down the complicated logistics of evacuating US allies and citizens out of Afghanistan. Aired on 08/23/2021.

[PortTack]

1. Let's give Biden some room. He said he would do this, I know others have said not.

They are air lifting no out approx 9k a day...that’s a lot of ppl

[Rhiannon12866]

2. Senator Chris Murphy - and a few others - have suggested we could call their bluff and stay longer

But I agree that we've made substantial progress, bringing in commercial airlines will certainly help a lot.

[OAITW r.2.0]

4. We should do that. Taliban can suck their date.

We have a lotta fire power left to make this bad news for the incoming government. We take the time necessary and if the Taliban wants to complain, oh well.

[markpkessinger]

5. The original date WE agreed to was May 1 . . . .

. . . And we agreed to that in exchange for the Taliban ceasing attacks on American troops. Biden has already pushed the envelope by extending it to August 31, but so far, the Taliban have continued to honor their agreement. But the President knows that if the Taliban perceives the U.S. to be dragging its feet on the withdrawal, they will abandon the Doha Agreement, and will resume attacks on U.S. troops. That would require Biden to commit still more troops to the effort, and the whole, sorry mess would continue until God knows when!

It was never "their date." May 1 was the date mutually agreed upon by U.S. and Taliban negotiators. And what you don't seem to understand is that we have lost this war, and thus are in no position to say "the Taliban can suck theier date." Nor can Biden unilaterally ignore the Doha agreement, because whether we leave now or five years from now, our exit will require negotiations with the Taliban, whether we like it or not. Reneging on the Doha Agreement would render any and all future negotiations with the Taliban impossible.

As for our "fire power," even with that, there are only about 3,500 troops in Afghanistan, and there are an estimated 70,000 to 100,000 Taliban fighters. So no, we can't make "bad news for the incoming government" unless we are prepared to commit to a continued, protracted engagement!

[Bev54]

3. That is the first time I have heard the number of 300,000

I have only heard around 100,000