Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

underpants

(182,807 posts)
Sun Jun 10, 2012, 07:15 PM Jun 2012

Most band members in one band?

I don't mean at one-time.

Over the life of a band ..the band as an entity.

I count 22 for Guns n Roses.

Any bands that continued past their original members? Does Wilco have any original members left?

7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Most band members in one band? (Original Post) underpants Jun 2012 OP
7,537.5 ohiosmith Jun 2012 #1
Depending on whom you include, King Crimson has had anywhere from 18-29 different members. Alexander Jun 2012 #2
... lookingfortruth Jun 2012 #3
Foghat had about 23 members SkatmanRoth Jun 2012 #4
Parliament / Funkadelic has had 60+ members since its' inception. Initech Jun 2012 #5
Frank Zappa/Mothers of Invention, Tower of Power. Both over thirty members. bluesbassman Jun 2012 #6
Chicago - hands down. HopeHoops Jun 2012 #7
 

Alexander

(15,318 posts)
2. Depending on whom you include, King Crimson has had anywhere from 18-29 different members.
Sun Jun 10, 2012, 07:32 PM
Jun 2012

Also worth pointing out, from Wikipedia:

"Most of the band members had notable musical careers outside the band, to the extent that it has been calculated that there are over fifteen-hundred releases on which members and former members of King Crimson appear.[91]"

"Current members

King Crimson is currently on hiatus, and the lineup of the band when (or if) they return is unknown. The most recent lineup was:

Robert Fripp — guitars, guitar synthesiser/MIDI guitar, Soundscapes, electric piano, Mellotron, keyboards, allsorts (1969–1974, 1981–1984, 1994–2009)
Adrian Belew — lead vocals, guitars, guitar synthesiser/MIDI guitar, electronic percussion (1981–1984, 1994–2009)
Tony Levin — bass guitars, Chapman Stick, upright bass, synthesiser, backing vocals (1981–1984, 1994–1999, 2003–2009)
Pat Mastelotto — acoustic and electronic drums and percussion (1994–2009)
Gavin Harrison — drums (2007–2009)

These musicians were part of the most recent proper King Crimson formation, which went on hiatus in 2009, but only Fripp is listed as a formal part of the latest ProjeKct, Jakszyk/Fripp/Collins (A King Crimson ProjeKct), featuring:

Robert Fripp — guitars, guitar synthesiser/MIDI guitar
Jakko Jakszyk — vocals, guitars, keyboards (he was the frontman of 21st Century Schizoid Band)
Mel Collins — sax

Former members

Peter Sinfield — lyrics, synthesiser (1969–1971)
Greg Lake — bass guitar, vocals and tambourine (1969–1970)
Michael Giles — drums, vocals (1969–1970)
Ian McDonald — saxophone, clarinet, flute, mellotron, vibes, vocals (1969, 1974)
Mel Collins — saxophones, flute, keyboards (1970–1972)
Gordon Haskell — bass guitar, vocals (1970–1971)
Andy McCulloch — drums (1970–1971)
Boz Burrell — bass guitar, vocals (1971–1972; died 2006)
Ian Wallace — drums, percussion, vocals (1971–1972; died 2007)
Bill Bruford — acoustic and electronic drums and percussion (1972–1974, 1981–1984, 1994–1998)
John Wetton — bass guitar, vocals, occasional electric guitar and piano (1972–1974)
Richard Palmer-James — lyrics (1972–1974)
David Cross — violin, viola, flute, mellotron, electric piano, keyboards (1972–1974)
Jamie Muir — percussion, allsorts (1972–1973)
Trey Gunn — Warr guitar, Chapman Stick, baritone guitar, Ashbory silicone-string bass, "talker" (1994–2003)

Additional/guest musicians

Peter Giles — bass guitar on In the Wake of Poseidon
Keith Tippett — acoustic and electric pianos on In The Wake Of Poseidon, Lizard and Islands
Mark Charig — cornet on Lizard, Islands and Red (from Keith Tippett Sextet and Centipede)
Robin Miller — oboe on Lizard, Islands and Red
Nick Evans — trombone on Lizard and Islands
Jon Anderson — guest lead vocals on Lizard (from Yes)
Rick Kemp — bass guitar, played for two weeks in band prior to recording of 'Islands' and Boz Burrell's hiring
Harry Miller — double bass on Islands
Paulina Lucas — soprano vocals (Islands).
Eddie Jobson — violin and electric piano studio overdubs on USA
Margaret Belew — source text for "Indiscipline" (on Discipline) and lyrics for "Two Hands" (on Beat). (Margaret Belew was an artist and was also Adrian Belew's wife during the time of King Crimson line-up 4)."

 

lookingfortruth

(263 posts)
3. ...
Sun Jun 10, 2012, 07:50 PM
Jun 2012

Menudo

Nefty Sallaberry
Carlos Meléndez
Fernando Sallaberry
Óscar Meléndez
Ricky Meléndez
René Farrait
Johnny Lozada
Xavier Serbiá
Miguel Cancel
Charlie Massó
Ray Reyes
Roy Rosselló
Robi Rosa
Ricky Martin
Raymond Acevedo
Sergio Blass
Ralphy Rodríguez
Angelo García
César Abreu
Rubén Gómez
Robert Avellanet
Rawy Torres
Edward Aguilera
Jonathan Montenegro
Adrián Olivares
Ashley Ruiz
Andy Blázquez
Alexis Grullón
Abel Talamántez
Ricky López
Anthony Galindo
Didier Hernández
Daniel René Weider


Chicago
Robert Lamm
James Pankow
Lee Loughnane
Walter Parazaider
Jason Scheff
Tris Imboden
Keith Howland
Lou Pardini
Daniel de los Reyes
Danny Seraphine
Peter Cetera
Terry Kath
Laudir de Oliveira
Donnie Dacus
Chris Pinnick
Bill Champlin
Dawayne Bailey
Drew Hester

Initech

(100,076 posts)
5. Parliament / Funkadelic has had 60+ members since its' inception.
Sun Jun 10, 2012, 08:35 PM
Jun 2012

The current lineup has maybe 17 - 18.

And then of course there's the Mothers Of Invention which has had like 150+ members from 1960 - 1988.

bluesbassman

(19,373 posts)
6. Frank Zappa/Mothers of Invention, Tower of Power. Both over thirty members.
Sun Jun 10, 2012, 08:52 PM
Jun 2012

I guess you could call it one band as Frank Zappa was the focal point, but the Mothers of Invention had over thirty diferrent members from '66 to '75.

For a band that still plays, I'd say Tower of Power would be up there as they've had over thirty through the years.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Most band members in one ...