Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The Polack MSgt

(13,188 posts)
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 03:59 PM Jul 2020

Low budget whiskey review, an occasional series. Part 3

Last edited Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:29 PM - Edit history (1)

Today's pour is Jim Beam Bonded Bourbon.

Jim Beam Distillery gives us the classic White Label Jim Beam Bourbon and the Knob Creek line of whiskeys.

In car maker terms, the Jim Beam White Label is a Chevy Cruise and the Knob Creek Single Barrel Select is a Cadillac Escalade.

The Jim Beam Bonded would be a Buick Sedan nicer, but still a budget-ish choice.

The term "Bonded", or as it is more commonly labeled "Bottled in Bond" has a very precise legal definition and can apply to any American Whiskey, not just Bourbon

Over and above what standards a whiskey must meet to legally be sold as "Whiskey" in America, Bottled in Bond whiskey must be barrel aged no less than 4 years. It has to be distilled in one production season, produced under the direction of a single master distiller, and it must be bottled at exactly 50% ABV (100 proof)

The Bonded liquor laws were one of the very first Consumer Safety laws in the world - Passed soon after the civil war to try to eliminate dangerous sometimes poisonous rotgut being shipped and sold as "WHISKEY" back in the day.

Ok, school is dismissed let's drink liquor now.

I poured an ounce and a half shot into a stemless wine glass to sniff it a bit - It isn't a very complex nose, sweet, some oak and a bright ethanol presence.

I let it sit 5 minutes while I wrote the introduction and smelt of it a second time after that 5-6 minute rest.
The ethanol had faded and there is a faint candied fruit with some brown sugar in the mix that the alcohol vapors hid at first and the wood is still there.

Not gonna lie - It is pleasant - no foul odors or sharp spiky aromas, but it's simple.

The whiskey is middle dark brown, about as brown as apple juice. The legs (the strings that form on the glass as you swirl the whiskey) are long lasting and plentiful - This is a pretty oily liquor

Trying it neat at room temperature gives more of a wood and char flavor than you'd expect, and not nearly the level of brown sugar as I expected from the smell.

The flavor lingers with a long slightly sour finish and the mouthfeel is great. The whiskey coats the inside of you mouth easily.

There is not as much burn as I expected from a 50% alcohol sub $20 fifth of whiskey.

I added an ice cube - I'll taste it cold but with the ice still in the glass, then I'll let the ice melt and taste the resulting watered down whiskey

Cold - OOOOHH Daddy likes. The sourish lingering taste in the finish sweetened up quite a bit - the wood tannins became more present and the fruit sweetness spiked up. This is a sour mash that likes the rocks

Watered and cool - Tastes like the 80 proof Jim Beam White Label with a bit more oak.

Gotta say that on the rocks is the play here - it was delicious cold but rather average watery.

This bottle cost $19.50 at the Class Six - about $4 more than regular Jim Beam and about $2 more than Evan Williams Bottled in Bond.

It is definitely worth the modest up charge over the regular, and it is splitting hairs trying to pick between this bottle and the Evan Williams BIB.

Tell ya what - try them both for less than the cost of a single bottle of a heavy hitter like Old Forester 1920 or about half the price of any decent Scotch

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Low budget whiskey review, an occasional series. Part 3 (Original Post) The Polack MSgt Jul 2020 OP
A friend in Wisconsin turned me on to Ten High "bourbon" whiskey mitch96 Jul 2020 #1
Makers Mark is good The Polack MSgt Jul 2020 #3
Thanks for this! Now I have a question about another budget whiskey. Foolacious Jul 2020 #2
I've never heard of that brand The Polack MSgt Jul 2020 #4
Have you tried Johnny Drum? denbot Jul 2020 #5
I've had it and I liked it, but it isn't generally available here The Polack MSgt Jul 2020 #6

mitch96

(13,904 posts)
1. A friend in Wisconsin turned me on to Ten High "bourbon" whiskey
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 05:43 PM
Jul 2020

A low budget spirit first made by Hiram Walker and then Heaven Hill. Both made in Bardstown Ky. It's a blend now with 51% bourbon and the rest neutral spirits per the google machine...
For a low budget liquor it's nice. Put it in a hi grade bottle and no one would know the difference. Then again that's me.. I don't have much of a pallet.. My fav is Makers Mark. I would like to try Pappy Van W at some time in my life. Got to find a place that sells it by the shot as I could not afford a bottle!!!
m

The Polack MSgt

(13,188 posts)
3. Makers Mark is good
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:14 PM
Jul 2020

and 10 High is fine the way most folks drink liquor in America - Mixed with Coke or 7up.

Really - buying higher end (Higher PRICE) whiskey is no guarantee that you'll get better whiskey.

And I say this over and over and over - If you are mixing cocktails any budget whiskey in a glass bottle is fine.

The plastic half gallon jug for $11 is not gonna cut it but any 13-15 buck fifth of American or Canadian hooch will taste ok in a Coke or a Sprite.

I tend to drink whiskey straight or on the rocks. If that's your jam as well, things get a bit dicier when buying low price whiskey.

My Super Cheapskate all star team so far is

Old Forester Straight Rye - Floral and spicy nose, warm pumpernickel bread notes. It is 100 Proof, stands up to ice and makes a luscious Old Fashioned. About $20 for a 750ml

Evan Williams - the whole lineup is good- you can't go wrong for the price on any EW product. My Fave is the Bonded. Depending on which bottle you choose they run $14-25

Wild Turkey 101. The classic high rye content Bourbon Whiskey. Sweet, spicy, smooth. Hints of Cherry and brown sugar. There is no whiskey application that WT 101 doesn't taste fabulous in. My "Usual" if i say I'll have the usual. 21- 25 look for a sale and buy a couple

Old Forester Bourbon. all of 'em.

There are many expressions of this whiskey that range from 18 bucks - The Old Forester 86 proof - all the way up to $750 for the Birthday Bourbon release.
But the regular old cheap ass 86 is delicious - Milder than the 100, with a softer presentation but more pronounced cherry notes than other distillers' Bourbons

Best whiskey I've ever tasted is the Prohibition style 1920. It's what I bought for my own birthday.

It runs $50-65 depending on the store

Foolacious

(497 posts)
2. Thanks for this! Now I have a question about another budget whiskey.
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:09 PM
Jul 2020

And I mean super-budget. It's called MacAndrews and I bought a sampler bottle about a year ago because it was so cheap it would have been criminal not to. It's from Scotland and the label claims its a scotch, but it's essentially peatless. It punched way above its weight as a sipper, almost on par with Canadian Club (a perfectly decent blend for a non-peater like me) but at a small fraction of the price. A fifth would have cost me the equivalent of about US$5. That's five. Dollars.

I would love to know more about this brand, but info is thin on the web. Have you ever heard of it? Tried it? How can it be so inexpensive?

The Polack MSgt

(13,188 posts)
4. I've never heard of that brand
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:26 PM
Jul 2020

And to be called Scotch Whisky (No e) it only has to be made in Scotland from Grain and be aged in wood at least 3 years.

The other titles and labels are describing subsets of Scotch whisky

Peated means that Peat fires are used to dry the malted grain

Single Malt means one distilllation using only Malted Barley

Blended Malt - More than one whiskey mixed together BUT ALL OF THEM ARE DISTILLED FROM MALTED BARLEY

Which sets them apart from:
Single Grain and Blended Grain Whisky which is usually distilled from unmalted Barley since rye and corn are not native to Scotlland - Some folks do mix in wheat.

I don't like peated whisky. At. All.

I do like Highland and Speyside Scotch - it's sweeter and friendlier

denbot

(9,899 posts)
5. Have you tried Johnny Drum?
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:38 PM
Jul 2020

Used to be cheap until I stumbled across it, and of course it went from low twenties, to last time I came across a bottle, it was in the high thirties..

The Polack MSgt

(13,188 posts)
6. I've had it and I liked it, but it isn't generally available here
Thu Jul 23, 2020, 06:52 PM
Jul 2020

in SW Illinois.

And I've seen that happen before - Weller Reserve used to be a mid $20 to low $30 bottle until the word got out.

Try to find it at all now, and if you do, you're gonna pay $55

Blanton's is even worse - I do think it's worth the $60 bucks it cost 2 years ago - But the last bottle I saw was $250

Infuriating.

I guess I should stop with the cheap hooch recommendations...

All these cheap whiskeys suck!

Good Whiskey costs at Least $80 bucks!

Nothing to see here. Now move along

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Low budget whiskey review...