Which of these sandwiches is your favorite?

[True Dough]

A lot of choices...

[markie]

1. 40 is cancelled

for good reason... although I used to eat cucumber and cream cheese sandwiches

that's a lot of sandwiches!!

as a vegetarian 34 is my go to, IF I eat a sandwich...

[True Dough]

7. My wife enjoys

fresh cucumber sandwiches every summer with the cukes from her garden!

[Clash City Rocker]

9. #40 reminds me of high tea in London

It would typically include some small sandwiches of that variety. They can be quite tasty.

[yardwork]

14. That's because they made it wrong. Needs to have mayo, not butter!

And I don't see tomato sandwiches on here, either. Freshly picked sliced tomatoes, mayo, celery salt on white bread. Mmmmmm.....

[smirkymonkey]

33. I love tomato sandwiches!

But among my top favorites would be the Caprese sandwich (which is listed) and the grilled cheese (with tomato) - they listed the grilled cheese, but no tomato.

I also love lobster rolls w/ very little mayo (only trust them in New England) and a good BLT w/ freshly picked tomatoes, crunchy iceberg lettuce and crispy bacon w/ mayo.

[2naSalit]

34. Indeed...

Though my recipe is a bit different.

I have sliced tomato, garden fresh thank you, on toast with butter on one piece of toast and mayo on the other, nothing else needed.

I have one every day when I have a tomato garden.

[yardwork]

35. Heaven!

[2naSalit]

36. Damn straight!

[Walleye]

2. The cheesesteak and also the Thanksgiving

But the Thanksgiving should be on an Italian roll and here we called it a Bobbie

[bottomofthehill]

26. Delaware?

They just opened a couple of Capriottis in DC in time for the Biden Presidency. One in Georgetown closed but the one in Arlington makes a great steak-n-cheese and a great Bobbie.

There are some amazing choices on the list along with the above two, I also love a good Italian and a good Cuban. The Cuban with a cup of black bean soup was my winter go to. Makes great dip, so does a grilled cheese with bacon and tomato with a cup of tomato soup.

God I also love a BLT with thick sliced bacon and a PBJ, although, as a kid I loved PB and Fluff with a cold glass of Chocolate Milk made with Bosco Syrup. A Club on wheat …amazing also.

[Walleye]

27. Correct! Delaware. I've always lived within a couple of miles of Capriotti's since I came back

To New Castle County years ago. The main Capriotti‘s was about a mile from my office when I was working. It was a staple diet around our shop. I also love a Cuban sandwich. I managed to develop a lot of different tastes for a lot of different nationalities of food when I lived on ninth Avenue and 48th St. in Manhattan in the 80s. I was born and raised in Delaware though also lived in LA in the 70s so You might say I have sort of an eclectic palate

[spooky3]

3. Love chicken salad, as long as it has little mayo and has

Pecans, grapes or raisins, and celery.

[Goonch]

4. ;-{)🖖‍

[bucolic_frolic]

5. 17 & 26

But when I make a roast beef sandwich, I add the works: mayo, mustard, ketchup, cheese, onions, lettuce, kaiser roll at a minimum

[Croney]

6. They snubbed my tomato and mayo.

🍅🍅🍅

[True Dough]

8. Maybe the next 40?

Along with the ol' reliable hotdog!

[Clash City Rocker]

11. Yeah, no hamburger or hotdog?

Those are probably the two most popular sandwiches. I’ve heard some people claim that they’re not sandwiches, but that seems silly to me. Two slices of bread with something between is a sandwich.

So neither of those, but they include bologna? That’s a little weird.

[yardwork]

15. Just saw this! I posted before I read the thread.

[bluecollar2]

52. I prefer butter to mayo

But tomato sandwiches are good too. I likd to add a little salt, onions, a sliver of swiss cheese and a splash of lemon juice.

Delicious

[Achilleaze]

10. Did not see PB & J

[Clash City Rocker]

12. #24

[madaboutharry]

13. 5 and 31

I do love a well made BLT. Lox and cream cheese on a bagel is always a favorite.

But I will say that a cucumber and cream cheese sandwich with watercress is very delicious. I first ate one of these in London.

[House of Roberts]

16. #30 but with mayo, not mustard, and with potato chips.

Mustard is for ham sandwiches without cheese or lettuce.

#3 is second, without slaw, on the sandwich, but as a side, along with french fries.

[sinkingfeeling]

17. 22 and 32

[True Dough]

18. A simple egg salad sandwich

is really satisfying for me too!

[3catwoman3]

40. Childhood story. Egg salad sandwiches give me the creeps. When I was...

...in 3rd, 4th and 5th grade (I'm now 70 so we're talking a long time ago), my mom was one of the few working mothers in our neighborhood. Mornings could be hectic, so my mom aimed for efficiency.

Every Sunday evening, we would make a week's worth of assorted sandwiches and put them in the freezer. On school mornings, she'd put one in our lunch boxes/bags, and it would thaw by lunch time.

Good idea in theory, but terrible in real life. Frozen egg salad on white bread thaws into a disgusting, soggy mess that, to this day, I cannot abide -

Deviled eggs however, are just fine.

[Boomerproud]

19. Chicken salad on a sesame seed bagel and meatball.

Nt

[Chipper Chat]

20. Grilled cheese sandwich

On plain white bread.
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh..........yum

[Emile]

21. BLT

[kacekwl]

22. The ones I don't love make

a much smaller list. Yum.

[Shrek]

23. #17 with kettle chips n/t

[wnylib]

24. The cheese steak, but it has to also have

sauteed green pepper slices along with the onion, and mayo.

Also, one not listed, a fish sandwich - baked, breaded fish fillet, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayo, and pickle relish.

[Floyd R. Turbo]

25. Not one that I wouldn't eat! 😋

[PJMcK]

28. One of each, please (n/t)

[dweller]

29. Where is

The Taco ?




✌🏻

[Iggo]

30. Hot roast beef, Swiss cheese, and a little mayo.

But a French Dip’ll do.

[highplainsdem]

31. It would be pulled pork if I still ate bread. But since I don't, shredded BBQ pork with

coleslaw on the side.

[sarge43]

32. BLT, but I wouldn't turn down any of them. n/t

[2naSalit]

37. I like the looks of most of them...

I would not eat any with beef or liver or other organs, though.

[demmiblue]

38. Either the falafel pita or the veggie & hummus. I can't decide!

[yellowdogintexas]

39. hard choice!

BLT (I kneel at the feet of the person who dreamed that up)
Chicken Salad
Pulled Pork with coleslaw ON the sandwich TYVM
Rare roast beef on a crusty Kaiser roll with horshradish mayo

[3catwoman3]

41. Toss up between a nice greasy dripping grilled...

...cheese and a lobster roll.

[CTyankee]

42. Une croque madam, s'il vous plait.

Merci!

[LuckyCharms]

43. I've boiled it down so far to 2,5,6,7,9,12,14,17,18,21,22,24,33,35,39.

[True Dough]

46. I hope you didn't sample each one in the process

You'd be one bloated fella!

[LuckyCharms]

50. I didn't but I'd like to!

All of those sangies look delicious!

[surrealAmerican]

44. so where's the pastrami ...

... on rye with mustard.

Plenty of good sandwiches on this list, but that is a serious omission.

[Akoto]

45. Take the grilled cheese, remove the grilled. I know, I'm weird. I like cheese sandwiches.

Having said that, being half Japanese, I've had more than my share of tonkatsu. It's normally serve sliced with cabbage and rice, but I've also had it as a sandwich. They make ramen with it, as well. Either way, it's darn good stuff.

[ironflange]

47. Reuben!

Though they all look good.

[electric_blue68]

48. Fascinating - I never think of a hamburger (or cheeseburger) as a "sandwich"! 😄

[electric_blue68]

49. If I had to pick one - 2. Plus these 9, 3, 22, 33, 32, 8...

I make a Grilled Cheese this way -

Preferably a good Artisan White Bread, or Pumpernickel, a bit of mayo, either Extra Sharp Cheddar, or Swiss Cheese, 2 - 3:thin slices of (Heirloom) Tomatoes, a dash of garlic powder.


I never knew what a Po' Boy, or a Caprese was!

[bluecollar2]

51. Bagel and lox

Or Banh Mi.

Cucumber sandwiches are good too...

[area51]

53. #8

Second place, #34.

[nuxvomica]

54. Can't pick just one

1. Bacon, Egg & Cheese -- Yes, but must be on a tosted poppyseed bagel or buttery croissant.
2. Grilled Cheese -- Awesome but awesomer with a slice of tomato.
3. Pulled Pork -- Ruined by BBQ sauce and coleslaw. I like mine with just Dijon mustard.
4. Banh Mi -- Yuck! Cilantro, yuck!
5. BLT -- Alright but needs turkey.
6. Italian Sub -- I could eat one if really hungry and/or drunk.
7. Thanksgiving -- Lovely, especially on a cold, rainy day.
8. Lobster Roll -- Yuck! (Seafood allergy)
9. Turkey Club -- Perfect thing for when you're not very hungry but won't be eating for a while.
10. Tuna melt -- Not bad before I had a seafood allergy. I had a tofu version of this in a restaurant in York, ME, about 30 years ago that I still remember as the best sandwich I've ever eaten.
11. Fried Chicken -- Okay. Just okay.
12. Cheesesteak -- Wonderful, even though I don't like the onions.
13. Cubano -- I like these as paninis.
14. Meatball Sub -- Wonderful but heavy, and depends on how good the meatballs and marinara are.
15. Croque Monsieur -- Never had; would probably like.
16. Croque Madame -- Never had; would probably like.
17. Reuben -- Such a wonderful blend of flavors and made entirely of different ways to preserve food.
18. Gyro -- Hold the onions and more tzatziki, please.
19. Po'boy -- Yuck! An abomination I wouldn't eat even before my seafood allergy came on.
20. Caprese -- Lovely. I feel so light and free after eating one.
21. Patty Melt -- Okay.
22. Egg Salad -- This is the only sandwich they serve in Heaven. Crazy good if you add sprouts.
23. French Dip -- A wonderful sandwich with a better name: roast beef au jus.
24. PB&J -- When life gets me down, this lifts me up. Best eaten after being kept in a brown bag in school locker all morning.
25. Torta -- Never had except as a burrito.
26. Roast Beef -- Hold the BBQ sauce and horseradish but great with Dijon mustard.
27. Jambon Beurre -- Never had but I am already salivating.
28. Tonkatsu -- I have no idea whether I would like this.
29. Monte Cristo -- Nice but a bit much.
30. Ham & Cheese -- The supermarket standby. My usual road-trip sandwich.
31. Bagel with Lox -- Just give me the bagel.
32. Falafel Pita -- Never had but I like all the ingredients except the onion.
33. Chicken Salad -- I know people who always order these but to me it's a sandwich made with garbage.
34. Veggie & Hummus -- Never had; would probably like. I love each of the ingredients.
35. Bologna -- Should have a slice of American cheese. I once made one with peanut butter because I like PB&J and I learned that sandwiches are like your friends as some of them won't get along even though you like them individually.
36. Bocadillo -- Never had; would probably like.
37. Kentuck Hot Brown -- Never had; would probably like.
38. Bocadillo -- Never had; would probably, no, definitely like. I like the idea of this sandwich.
39. Liverwurst -- This is the only sandwich they serve in Hell.
40. Cucumber Tea -- Surprisingly yummy.

[True Dough]

55. Wow!

Nobody should ever accuse you of not being thorough! You are a sandwich connossieur!

[Kaleva]

56. Liverwurst

[Paladin]

57. 17. Reuben (nt)