Do you prefer Miracle Whip ? I like Miracle Whip . I Thought I would start a

[debm55]

thread for us Miracle Whip posters. Are there any out there? Stand up, be proud and be counted!!!!
Edited to take out Mayo so as to not interrupt their thread. We like Miracle Whip!

[roamer65]

1. Olive oil mayo is my go to.

I love the stuff.

[AnnaLee]

23. Me too.

I bought some regular Duke's a while back thinking it might be good for pimento cheese and other sandwich salads. After trying it in chicken salad, I tossed the bottle. I'll stick with the Olive oil mayo even if my pimento cheese doesn't taste the same as when I was a kid and super loved pimento cheese.

[SamKnause]

2. No, I do not prefer Miracle Whip.

[debm55]

4. okay

[oregonjen]

3. Kewpie Mayo for the win!

[50 Shades Of Blue]

5. I'm in the mayo camp (Kraft though!) but my hubby's in the MW camp, so

we get both!

[tblue37]

6. Nope, nope, nope! Mayo only.

[debm55]

12. Yes, Yes, Yes. Miracle Whip is the bomb.

[tblue37]

14. Too sweet for me.

[Callalily]

7. Homemade mayo is the best.

Here's a super easy recipe!

https://www.seriouseats.com/two-minute-mayonnaise?

[samnsara]

11. is it as hard and tricky as Julia makes it look?

[LeftInTX]

64. I used to make it with a food processer. Stupid me, used olive oil to be healthy

No longer have a food processer and rarely eat mayo, so I just keep a small jar on hand.

[samnsara]

13. thank you!!!

im running low on mayo as I've been using it IN all my recipes..even my scrambled eggs!

[multigraincracker]

8. Coincidence whip.

I don’t buy into miracles.

[LakeArenal]

9. Whip. Whip it good. Just whip it. 🎶

[samnsara]

10. ewwwwww....

...but like another poster im gonna go home made mayo a la Julia!

[beveeheart]

15. My mother used Miracle Whip

so that's what I've always used and I'll be 80 this month. No need to change now.

[Ocelot II]

16. Yuck. It's the worst. It's too sweet; not ever a substitute for real mayo.

I call it the Semen of Satan.

[debm55]

17. That's the point Ocelot II. Mayo has no taste. I'm standing by my choice.

[Ocelot II]

18. No taste at all is better than the sickly sweetness of the Semen of Satan.

What you put on your BLT shouldn't be sweet. Anyhow, mayo does have a flavor; it's mildly tart with a lemony overtone.

[debm55]

20. So, I guess I can count you in the no Miracle Whip column.

Last edited Thu Aug 31, 2023, 05:38 PM - Edit history (2)

[ExWhoDoesntCare]

70. Good mayo does have flavor

When you get the good kind.

Try Duke's. It's not in-your-face with the flavor, but it's definitely not bland.

[Freddie]

19. Middle ground

I prefer real Mayo (none of that diet crap) for a sandwich but I like Miracle Whip in egg salad and ham salad.

[debm55]

21. Good for you Freddie. I like it in tuna and egg salad.

[jdadd]

22. MW most of the time ...

[debm55]

27. ----------

[Bluethroughu]

24. Husband loves the whip...

I hate it. Mayo is the one and only!

[debm55]

28. no taste to the mayo

Last edited Thu Aug 31, 2023, 04:58 PM - Edit history (1)

[Bluethroughu]

44. In men, mayo, or both?

[debm55]

46. in mayo

[ExWhoDoesntCare]

71. And you think MW has flavor?

Seriously?

All MW tastes like is sugar in liquid plastic.

[Thunderbeast]

25. I am in a "mixed marriage"

I am a mayo guy (as the gods intended).

She uses Miracle Whip... recalling her Midwestern roots?

We make room in the fridge for both.

[debm55]

26. when I got married in 1979, husband was a mayo, He now has Miracle whip on everything, I did my job

right,

[Thunderbeast]

29. RESIST THE EVANGELISTS!

In ALL matters!

Looking for a deprogrammer to help your husband!

[debm55]

31. He is saved from the tasteless mayo. Glory Be!!

[EYESORE 9001]

30. I can go either way

My wife abhors MW, but I can take it or leave it. We try to keep a small bottle of MW around because children & their families like it. I’ll finish off a bottle if it starts sitting around too long.

[lillypaddle]

32. I like Miracle Whip better than the boring other white stuff

Just adds a bit of zip to everything.

[debm55]

33. Yes it does!

[Bayard]

34. In our fridge,

We have generic MW, regular mayo, and olive oil mayo. So depending on which jar I grab first, that's what I use.

[catbyte]

35. Miracle Whip is a travesty, lol

The only time it's acceptable is at Thanksgiving when I'm making the Waldorf/fruit salad hybrid I grew up on. I won't hold it against you, though!

[debm55]

37. I am a proud MWer, Though I have to admit mustard is way better on ham sandwiches and hot dogs I am

stating my constitutional right to be a MWer

[catbyte]

38. And as a proud mayo devotee, I will defend to the death your right to be a MWer.

It's the American way.

[debm55]

41. And I salute your defending my right as a MWer to use MW, as I defend to the death your choice to

use mayo as you constitutional right
Oh my, I hit the wrong key and posted MFer. instead of MWer.

[catbyte]

42. ...

[rsdsharp]

36. I grew up with Miracle Whip, so I guess I'm in that camp,

but we have both.

[debm55]

48. Good

[avebury]

39. I was raised with Miracle Whip. nt

[debm55]

47. me too

[Probatim]

40. Here are my comments...

Miracle Whip is only good in my macaroni salad which, among those who've had it, is the best they've ever eaten.

I only use mayonnaise in a chipotle aioli. And that's made with an obscene amount of garlic.

Aside from those two recipes, that's the only times I'll use either.

[debm55]

55. I like in tuna and egg salad and potato salad

[Elessar Zappa]

43. I like it on a few things.

Chicken salad sandwiches and roast beef sandwiches, to be specific.

[debm55]

52. So do I --tuna and egg salad. Not ham--mustard only

[Solly Mack]

45. No, thank you. Just a polite, firm No.

[debm55]

56. Thay's okay

[Swede]

49. I prefer Miracle Whip times a million over mayo.

Egg salad, potato salad, sandwiches are all infinitely better with MW.

[debm55]

51. You are a brave soul to post that.

Last edited Thu Aug 31, 2023, 08:18 PM - Edit history (1)

[ironflange]

53. Mayo is too blah

MW adds a nice zing to things.

[debm55]

54. Yep

[Emile]

57. Zero carbs mayonnaise.

[debm55]

58. Good, Emile.

[GP6971]

59. I don't think I've

ever had it.

[debm55]

61. It's somewhat sweeter then mayo.

[Moosepoop]

60. I love Miracle Whip!

I grew up with it. The first time I had actual mayonnaise on a sandwich at a friend's house, it seemed horribly bland in comparison.

Now, decades later, I'm fine with mayo when away from home or out to eat. But I only purchase Miracle Whip to have here in the house. Egg salad, macaroni salad, tuna salad, potato salad... all with Miracle Whip. Any sandwiches calling for a dressing get the same.

I no longer "hate" mayo, but I still love my Miracle Whip!

[debm55]

62. I am the same way.

[LeftInTX]

63. This thread will not end well!

One time I was at my mom's. I bit into a sandwich and OMG..MW...I spit it out. I'm like, "Mom, how could you do this!?"

She was always "dieting", so it was one of her dieting fads.

[debm55]

67. Diet MW sucks, real 100% MW is tangy, My name is debm55 and I am a MWer.

[LeftInTX]

68. I don't know what kind of MW she had in those roast beef sandwiches.

Yes, they were roast beef!!! I was so looking forward to them because she was not a good cook, getting up in age, and for once she was gonna serve us something nice.


I did read that MW is preferred in certain recipes like Waldorf Salad. My mom used to make that. But I don't remember seeing MW in our fridge growing up.

She served plain bologna sandwiches with mayonnaise etc.
She used mayonnaise in tuna fish.
When I was a teen, I made tomato sandwiches with loaded with creamy mayonnaise.
I made my own Dagwood sandwiches.

I never saw MW at our house.
As a matter of fact, I asked about it once because I would see the ads and my mom said, "Mayonnaise is better"

It certainly was a horror to bite into roast beef with cheddar, lettuce and tomatoes on a croissant and it was MW. I wanted to scrape it off. I went hunting for the mayonnaise. To my horror, she had no mayonnaise in the house either...She was losing her faculties a bit...


I guess this might be a 12 step thread!

[malthaussen]

65. No, all of my whips are rawhide. n/t

[debm55]

66. So you like :the whip"

[ExWhoDoesntCare]

69. We're a Duke's Mayonnaise household

Ever since I tried it in Mississippi back in the 80s. The husband found it shocking for me to get so excited about mayo at the grocer's when our local one started carrying Duke's. I was all but hugging that jar.

Then he had his first taste...and understood my delight at finding it at the store. We haven't bought anything else since then.

[Maninacan]

72. Hellman's mayo

Can't explain it but worth the price.