The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsWhat is your favorite Beatle's song. Mine is "Hear Comes the Sun"
Mister Ed
(6,927 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)brewens
(15,359 posts)The into was And My Bird Can Sing if I remember right.
Mister Ed
(6,927 posts)That's where I first heard it. Sadly, I think the reason for that was that Lennon, who wrote the song, just hated the finished work. I've read that he declared it "a horror".
I think that's what kept the song off of the U.S. release of the Revolver album. It became kind of a cast-off, and was relegated to accompanying the opening credits of a Saturday-morning kiddie cartoon show, or added to the collection of odds and ends that was released in the U.S. as "Yesterday...and Today".
I'm sure sorry to know that the author of the song was so dissatisfied with it. Each time I listen to it, I'm filled with a euphoria that I can scarcely describe.
brewens
(15,359 posts)Looking at some of the early season, I don't think I remember it that way. They improved the production quite a bit, I think.
Mister Ed
(6,927 posts)if..fish..had..wings
(880 posts)and then every single other Beatles song
debm55
(60,623 posts)rurallib
(64,688 posts)I just love the imagery of the words
debm55
(60,623 posts)Ocelot II
(130,538 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)displacedvermoter
(4,503 posts)White Album pretty much perfect album.
debm55
(60,623 posts)good song.
claudette
(5,455 posts)"Yesterday" - always loved it and still listen to it on my Beatles #1 Hits CD.
debm55
(60,623 posts)claudette
(5,455 posts)😢 But it has a very special meaning to me. I actually love almost all of the Beatles songs and have a collection of their hits! "Yesterday" will always be my favorite.
randr
(12,648 posts)Final song on "Yellow Submarine"
debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)My favorite songs changed as I grew, matured, endured bad & good times and so on. I've been preferring George songs for awhile, been stuck on this one for years.
justaprogressive
(6,909 posts)followed by I Want You (She's So Heavy)
debm55
(60,623 posts)walkingman
(10,865 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)flying_wahini
(8,275 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)thomski64
(939 posts)..from the show Music Man..
LakeArenal
(29,949 posts)Having said that
.Seeing Sir Paul sing Let It Be in person is something to experience and unforgettable.
So many not so famous beauties like:
Blackbird, Norwegian Wood, Run For Your Life
..
Each stage of our life has a BeatleSong.
For this stage of our life, this one::.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Last edited Sun Aug 25, 2024, 04:33 PM - Edit history (1)
OLDMDDEM
(3,186 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)hlthe2b
(113,974 posts)'Lots of good covers too. I always liked this one from Chantel Kreviazuk
debm55
(60,623 posts)Polly Hennessey
(8,834 posts)The long and winding road
That leads to your door
Will never disappear
I've seen that road before
It always leads me here
Lead me to your door
The wild and windy night
That the rain washed away
Has left a pool of tears
Crying for the day
Why leave me standing here?
Let me know the way
Many times I've been alone
And many times I've cried
Anyway, you'll never know
The many ways I've tried
debm55
(60,623 posts)Mad_Dem_X
(10,193 posts)My all-time favorite song. Second place is A Day In The Life.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Last edited Sun Aug 25, 2024, 11:10 PM - Edit history (1)
my funeral in the chapel
Gaytano70
(1,234 posts)Holds a special place in my 💙 and love to sing along with it 🎤
ms liberty
(11,237 posts)They're one of the most important influences in my musical life. I think of one favorite song, and another pops in my head that I love just as much. They and their music always gets excluded when I'm listing favorites, because they are the model for it all, they are the OG.
debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)He's been diagnosed with dementia 😩
debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)No words. Terry Pratchett went the same way.
patphil
(9,068 posts)Off the top of my head:
&list=PLycVTiaj8OI80AsTGjYJAPi7-i8kTH-Bq&index=8
The fact is that it would be hard to narrow it down to a top 100. Never in the history of rock and roll has a group produced such uniformly great music. They were able to recreate themselves again and again with an amazing variety of music.
They were simply the best.
debm55
(60,623 posts)oasis
(53,695 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)I've read tales of it in some Beatles stuff. Lucky fans and some Apple Scruffs. 4x in a row and it was hot.
Has there ever been a documentary about the people who took part? I think I saw Eric Burden from The Animals and who was the flower man who was acting so flamboyantly? Wouldn't that be a good project?
Imalittleteapot
(3,423 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)mjvpi
(1,931 posts)George Martin was the 5th Beatle. He help take great songs stratospheric. Can you image Penny Lane without the trumpet solo? "A Day In the life without the Strings? They had it all including the creative friction that at times proved synergetic but then became too much.
ProfessorGAC
(76,706 posts)...that George Martin was the THIRD Beatle.
Not that George & Ringo weren't terrific, but Martin's ability to actually create the sounds those guts heard in the head was almost as important as the songwriting.
We didn't mean that as a knock of George & Ringo, just meant it as the highest compliment to Martin.
debm55
(60,623 posts)DBoon
(24,989 posts)Last edited Mon Aug 26, 2024, 07:06 PM - Edit history (2)
An amusing pop song with a deeper meaning going only to the depth that the Corsican octopus collects bright colored objects. Does not refer to matters of war/peace (Lennon), love (McCartney) or things of the spiritual world (Harrison).
This song just wants to make you sing along. I could see a class of elementary school kids singing this and having a great time. It is a very happy song, unlike some other Beatles tunes which have a darker more melancholy side despite seeming equally nonsensical.
The Beatles were masters of well crafted pop and I believe this is their finest example.
Ringo is GOD!
THERE. I FIXED IT.
debm55
(60,623 posts)ArkansasDemocrat1
(3,213 posts)Obla-di, Obla-da
Rocky Raccoon
Maxwell's Silver Hammer
Her Majesty
Dig A Pony
Good Morning, Good Morning
#9...9...9..9......
Mr.Bill
(24,906 posts)When Ringo was filming The Magic Christion with Peter Sellars, Sellars invited him out for a weekend on his yacht, to the Island of Corsica near Italy. When they were docked Ringo looked down into the clear waters and noticed quite a large gathering of multi colored glass, shells and whatever made the area quite visible. He asked the Captain what that was and he told him there was a certain breed of Octopus who gathered those brightly colored objects to attract a mate.
Another bit of trivia is that Octopus's Garden was one of the two Beatles songs written by Ringo. The other was Don't Pass Me By.
whathehell
(30,470 posts)Just sayin'.
DBoon
(24,989 posts)I was relying on memory. Abbey Road came out a long time ago.
whathehell
(30,470 posts)but then it might be best if you correct it.
ProfessorGAC
(76,706 posts)But, I can't do one. I need to do it by era.
Early: Please Please Me
Mid: Penny Lane
Late: A Day In The Life
And, even that was tough!
debm55
(60,623 posts)TommieMommy
(2,902 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)lpbk2713
(43,273 posts)But here are two others.
... and Help!
debm55
(60,623 posts)the memories that their songs hold for us. Thank you.
beaglelover
(4,466 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Onthefly
(1,297 posts)It is melancholic but one of my favorites. On the 45s it was on the b side of yellow submarine. Lived in Germany listening to Beatles with local folk.
Brother Buzz
(39,900 posts)I can count on one hand my least favorite Beatles' songs and have enough fingers left over to order three martinis.
It suffices to say, every Beatles' song is special to me at the right time and place
debm55
(60,623 posts)maccafan
(167 posts)Too many favorites over 60 years but my current favorite is Here, There, and Everywhere. It also happens to be one of Paul's favorites when he is asked.
debm55
(60,623 posts)bif
(27,000 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)nikatnyte
(345 posts)N/T
debm55
(60,623 posts)Different Drummer
(9,083 posts)Glass Onion
I Am The Walrus
debm55
(60,623 posts)Glorfindel
(10,175 posts)"The Walrus was Paul."
debm55
(60,623 posts)kozar
(3,318 posts)Koz
debm55
(60,623 posts)kozar
(3,318 posts)So is life
Koz
darkstar
(5,797 posts)by I Will, Shes Leaving Home, Hello Goodbye and Its All to Much.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Stargleamer
(2,728 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)rsdsharp
(12,004 posts)My favorite if their first US number 1 I Want To Hold Your Hand.
debm55
(60,623 posts)them all.
johnp3907
(4,312 posts)Tomorow it could be Glass Onion or whatever.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Gaytano70
(1,234 posts)Well we all wanna change the world!
debm55
(60,623 posts)Texasgal
(17,240 posts)I guess I'd go with Black Bird.
debm55
(60,623 posts)JoeOtterbein
(7,869 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Demobrat
(10,299 posts)The song that made me fall in love with rock and roll when I was a lonely child listening to records in my bedroom.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Diamond_Dog
(40,579 posts)One that no one has mentioned is Imagine. So simple, so beautiful in its sentiment. John is just brilliant.
debm55
(60,623 posts)that it was put out after the Beatles broke up and was on John's solo album. Anyone know for certain?
Diamond_Dog
(40,579 posts)EarnestPutz
(2,843 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Mike Nelson
(10,943 posts)Yes!
debm55
(60,623 posts)Mike Nelson
(10,943 posts)... he was Beatles drummer on this track, "Besame Mucho!" Ringo replaced Pete mid-to late 1962.
debm55
(60,623 posts)FalloutShelter
(14,466 posts)Checking in and reading everyones faves
I really cant choose one.
Im all
oohhh maybe that one
no wait this one
debm55
(60,623 posts)most or has special meaning for you.
FalloutShelter
(14,466 posts)A Day in The Life.
At a certain time in my life it just blew my mind.
debm55
(60,623 posts)FalloutShelter
(14,466 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)surfered
(13,476 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)chicoescuela
(3,084 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)rampartd
(4,634 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)I always thought that Norwegian Wood would be on the Blue . You can hear George on the sitar and it not a pop song. It was not a dance song but a listening song (for various reasons) I loved this song too. It was a tie between NW and the Sun song. It shows they were moving music wise and lyric wise. Just my opinion of course.
.
skylucy
(4,024 posts)to my eyes. Things We Said Today, Help, I'm Looking Through You...Oh heck, I just love them all. And of course...
The End. And in the end the love you take is equal to the love you make.
debm55
(60,623 posts)artistically gifted.
Siwsan
(27,834 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Mme. Defarge
(9,021 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)CanonRay
(16,171 posts)or Got to Get You Into My Life. Ever since high school.
debm55
(60,623 posts)OldBaldy1701E
(11,143 posts)A very tough question. I have played several of them over the years. I used to do acoustic renditions of 'Rocky Raccoon', 'A Day In The Life', 'Blackbird', and I did a full version of 'Hey Jude'. A tough question, as they were SO influential.
debm55
(60,623 posts)karynnj
(60,968 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Clouds Passing
(7,934 posts)Here Comes The Sun
debm55
(60,623 posts)sweetness. PS And George was my favorite.
OAITW r.2.0
(32,159 posts)Last edited Sun Aug 25, 2024, 10:47 PM - Edit history (1)
Has always stuck with me. I remember the night Howard Kossel and Monday Night Football cut in to announce John Lennon's assassination....they played this song. So appropriate.
https://music.
debm55
(60,623 posts)and frankly I needed a good cry so thank you. Love, Deb.
OAITW r.2.0
(32,159 posts)I know it's a rough time for you, and I'm glad I posted something that you liked.
moniss
(9,056 posts)all of the early stuff that was big to dance to. I would say "Any Time At All" and "Tell Me Why" are two of the best to just get out there and dance to. The whole "Hard Day's Night" album is good for me. "Rubber Soul" and "Revolver" were maybe less about dancing and by the time we hit "Sgt. Pepper" of course dancing to the Beatles was pretty much done although the songs were fine. I'm just a '50's kid who started on Ricky Nelson, Danny and the Juniors and Doo Wop songs. So when the Beatles hit we were still about going to dances and riding around in cars.
debm55
(60,623 posts)the second half was music to listen and reflect on.
Figarosmom
(12,002 posts)And In my life
you know as I went back and started reading the responses I started.singing each one in my head and thinking about personal memories relating to every song and smiling
It's hard to pick a favorite when their whole volume of works means something.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Doc_Technical
(3,764 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)tetedur
(1,418 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)Glorfindel
(10,175 posts)But if there were a gun to my head, probably "All You Need Is Love."
debm55
(60,623 posts)lisa58
(5,809 posts)I cant decide
debm55
(60,623 posts)Jeebo
(2,560 posts)That song is eff-ing brilliant. Somebody on the Beatles channel on Sirius satellite radio revealed something I never knew about the lyrics. He said that in the early 1960s people were trying to read profound meanings into Beatles lyrics and John Lennon wrote those weird lyrics to that song in an attempt to mess with those people. But if that was his purpose, he failed. I thought back to my first few hearings of that song, and as weird as those lyrics seemed at first, after perhaps a dozen times hearing the song, those weird lyrics started making a strange sort of sense to me. Now, I think those brilliant lyrics fit the tone of that song perfectly. And it's a song that I will NEVER get tired of. If I had ever been father to a girl, and I got to name her, I would have named her (first and middle names) Semolina Pilchard.
My other two favorite Beatles songs: When I'm 64 and Eleanor Rigby. Not that I'm confining it to just those three songs; the Beatles are the best band EVER and they wrote a gazillion great songs.
-- Ron
debm55
(60,623 posts)the song? That had the rumor mill going back in the day.
Mike Nelson
(10,943 posts)... to have been said near the end of "Strawberry Fields Forever" (1967). John said he really says, "cranberry sauce," but it sounds like he says, "I'm very bored," to me. Still, I think when you play around with the mix, it's clears up to "cranberry sauce."
debm55
(60,623 posts)John was right --the Beatles were more popular in their time then Jesus was in his time. There was no cut intended, it was true. then came the record trashing by a bunch of religious nuts.
Mr.Bill
(24,906 posts)Actuall the only Beatle on this track was George.
It will be played at my funeral. Google the lyrics and you will understand. It's a very peaceful song and will lift the mood of all those present.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Charlie Chapulin
(387 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)RandySF
(84,328 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)has the answer.
Rustynaerduwell
(782 posts)in the listening of it.
But Here Comes the Sun. I read that and thought, yeah. If I had to give up every Beatles song but one, That'd be the keeper.
debm55
(60,623 posts)RandySF
(84,328 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)madamesilverspurs
(16,512 posts)Mostly because those songs take me back to the time before our innocence was so bloodily shredded. The rest of the '60s had good music along with events we would rather not have experienced.
.
debm55
(60,623 posts)catbyte
(39,154 posts)I love it so much. It's actually one of my 3 favorite songs of all time, right behind "Tunnel of Love" (Dire Straits not Springsteen) and my all-time favorite "Wish You Were Here" (Pink Floyd)
debm55
(60,623 posts)whathehell
(30,470 posts)debm55
(60,623 posts)calguy
(6,154 posts)Can't I just pick all of them? They're all that good.
debm55
(60,623 posts)a couple of songs posters shared that make me cry when I hear them. And there are songs that make me get up and dance.
Ferryboat
(1,264 posts)Every song they released has a outstanding alternative version that can stand on its own.
MGGW has Paul on bass
George on acoustic
with additional verse.
debm55
(60,623 posts)OldBaldy1701E
(11,143 posts)So, his 'entity' may not own them anymore.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Alephy
(158 posts)For some reason, I like "Two of Us" quite a bit these days. I find it pretty whimsical.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Basso8vb
(1,230 posts)Revolver regularly occupied the turntable in my house growing up. I always liked Taxman and El
Basso8vb
(1,230 posts)However, Revolver regularly occupied the turntable in my house growing up. I always liked Taxman and Eleanor Rigby.
But my favorite is a toss up between Hey Jude and Let it Be.
I really had to ponder this one. Great topic!
debm55
(60,623 posts)a sad song. The one I picked was more positive. Both are classics, though. PS Welcome to DU
poozwah
(413 posts)Ive Just Seen A Face.
debm55
(60,623 posts)Jeebo
(2,560 posts)What would be your favorite relatively obscure Beatles song? The Beatles are such a great band that even their less well known songs, and songs that are usually not included in lists of their best songs, are great songs. There are not many groups that are THAT good. Among potential nominees for this honor would be songs that are NOT among the ones that posters have mentioned in this thread. I have two nominees for Beatles songs that fit in this category: Piggies from the White Album and Being For The Benefit of Mr. Kite from the Sgt. Pepper's album. Mr. Kite's lyrics are truly brilliant, the imagery is fantastic, and the tune is wonderful too. It is as good a song as any on that classic album, in my humble opinion.
Another interesting sub-category is one that I think might have been posted on this forum in the past two or three years: Beatles songs that everybody else loves, but you HATE. I have one nominee for that dubious distinction: Hey Jude. That song is SO monotonous, the na-na-na's go on and on and on for WAY too long, and even that part of the song that comes before the monotony begins doesn't particularly resonate with me. I listen often to the Beatles Channel on Sirius satellite radio, but when Hey Jude comes on, I immediately change the channel.
-- Ron