Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Orrex

(63,215 posts)
Sun Feb 5, 2017, 04:14 PM Feb 2017

Demolition of a designated historic building in New Castle PA

There are months of backstory to this, but here's the summary:

City planners decided that the best way to help rebuild this small, economically strained town, would be to destroy two old and historic buildings right in the heart of downtown so that a huge Speedway gas station/convenience store can be installed. In 2010 the median household income of the town is around $25K, and it's likely decreased since then.

Local residents (Trump voters, by a substantial and vocal margin) praise the development for bringing about 30 jobs into town, but they're idiots. These will overwhelmingly be low wage part time jobs with no benefits, so we'll all be subsidizing those employees because they'll qualify for public assistance.

It's being built at the base of a long hill where traffic already snarls, and it's all but guaranteed to kill two independent gas stations nearby along with a string of other locally owned businesses. Residents claim that it will bring business to town, but how? Was a big tech firm biding its time until New Castle had a place to get nachos at three in the morning? Residents also claim that it will bring tax revenue into town, but that's idiocy.

Residents of the well-developed and higher-income community north of town won't use it, because they already have a large Sheetz and several chain gas stations more conveniently located. Since there's no appreciable access to the site from outside, no one from outside the town will use it (I mean, who drives into a town to see a gas station?) In short, any revenue that the business takes in will be coming from local money, and it will be shipped out of state to the owners. Tax revenue will likewise come from the purchases made by those within the already-impoverished community, meaning no new money from outside. And when the Speedway doesn't prosper in this depressed little town, they'll leave a huge derelict lot with buried gas tanks.

It's a lose-lose for the town and everyone in it except those receiving direct financial benefit. And it's all the more infuriating because the locals (with their abundant "Impeach Obummer" and "Killary for Prison" yard signs still standing) think that it's the best thing in the whole history of ever, and anyone who says otherwise is derided for for not wanting to improve the town (as if that's what's happening here).

So here's the latest: as recently as a few days ago, local Code Enforcement stated that no decision had been made re: the demolition of the sites. A judge who'd been monitoring the case was to be informed before further action was taken. Then, this morning, a crew swept in and knocked down the buildings while our locals were sleeping or at church or prepping to watch Brady lose the Superbowl. According to my friend who works nearby, the demolition vehicles were unmarked, with no signs on display to name the company.

There have been public hearings at several points along the way, but it's clear that they were "here's what we're doing" meetings rather than "we want community input" meetings. In short, it's been a done deal all along, and no one but the beneficiaries have had any say in the process, aside from the aforementioned judge.

In fairness, I have no reason to doubt that the judge is acting in good faith and will likely have something to say about the unilateral action, so we'll see.


What can be done in cases like this? Yes, we can vote out local officials, but that's a long way off and they're years-entrenched. Is there some state authority to whom one can appeal when a town fucks its residents this way?


Thanks for listening and for any input.







.

5 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Demolition of a designated historic building in New Castle PA (Original Post) Orrex Feb 2017 OP
Demos suck la1n3yj Feb 2017 #1
Thank you very much for the suggestion! Orrex Feb 2017 #2
And welcome to DU! Orrex Feb 2017 #3
Will this be at the traffic circle in the middle of town? DeminPennswoods Feb 2017 #4
A little farther up, closer to that newish Domino's Pizza Orrex Feb 2017 #5

la1n3yj

(1 post)
1. Demos suck
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 03:58 PM
Feb 2017

Hey Orrex,

I'm sorry about the recent demolition. If your posting was completely true, it honestly sounds kind of illegal. I just heard about this incident on Facebook and seen the comments. It's ridiculous how the higher powers of your community would think that a low-wage gas station would spark any type of economic development. I'd recommend trying to get your SHPO involved (State Historic Preservation Officer). I think his name is Bill Callahan. Try Preservation Pennsylvania too.
The best way to fight these Trump supporting locals is to fight them with facts. Try to publish articles and throw out advertisements about how saving buildings can actually generate revenue. There are tons of information online about this, especially case studies in small town, rural communities. PlaceEconomics specifically focuses on what historic preservation does for a community. Try to reach out to them to see if they have any insight.

As for the rest of the historic structures of New Castle, save what you can. Rally together a community that will buy up these properties or start proposing adaptive reuse ideas to the local officials. All I can say is that a strong community dedicated to a single idea can do a lot. People who care will actually save these places. Convince businesses to invest in these properties and see their potential. Also, check out Federal Tax Credit Incentives (if they still exist in the next 100 days). They really help offset the expense of rehabilitating properties.

Uncalled for demolitions really grind my gears. Especially in small towns where apparently many residents don't understand what historic preservation is. If you want anymore information about preservation in the area, message me and I can try to help out. I've helped out a lot in Pittsburgh and know a few organizations.

la1n3yj

Orrex

(63,215 posts)
2. Thank you very much for the suggestion!
Mon Feb 6, 2017, 09:39 PM
Feb 2017

Last edited Tue Feb 7, 2017, 08:50 AM - Edit history (1)

As for the truth of the story, I can only tell you that I've recounted the events as I know them, but of course it's possible that I'm in error on something or other.

One of my friends is an administrative member of the New Castle Historical Society, and she's particularly upset about this. I'll pass your suggestions along to her, as well. Incidentally, she noted today that the buildings likely contained asbestos, and one of of the demolished structures served as a funeral home for decades, so she's concerned about chemical residues (embalming fluid, etc.)


Thanks again!

Orrex

(63,215 posts)
5. A little farther up, closer to that newish Domino's Pizza
Tue Feb 7, 2017, 06:23 PM
Feb 2017

And I'm still pretty sure that it'll screw up traffic.

Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Pennsylvania»Demolition of a designate...