Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumDauphin Island AL - Hit By Dozens Of Hurricanes, Rebuilt Repeatedly At Taxpayer Cost Of $100 Million
Last edited Thu Sep 5, 2019, 09:10 AM - Edit history (1)
EDIT
It isnt hard to see why. The razor-thin section of coast where Dauphin Island lies is a veritable runway for late-season hurricanes sprinting up the Gulf of Mexico. The island is a complex geometry, bordered on the east end by the busy Mobile Bay Ship Channel, with towering sand dunes in the middle and virtually no shoreline or dunes on the pancake flat west end. It might seem surprising, then, that the largest and most expensive homes are located along the vulnerable west end, where Katrina gutted hundreds of vacation homes, sweeping some off their 15-foot-high stilts into the Mississippi Sound. Yet thats where owners and investors want to build. Its flat and has the best views, said Mayor Jeff Collier.
Under Alabama law, theres little Collier can do, assuming he even wanted to stop them. The state has no requirements for setbacks. Property owners can and do build right to the waters edge. In theory, there is a state construction line limiting building beyond it. However, the line was adopted in 1973 and now sits about a hundred yards offshore, under the Gulf of Mexico.
The state has never gone back and reset the line to take into account erosion, storms, or sea-level rise, said George F. Crozier, the former head of a marine research center on the east end. Its kind of a joke. It fell into the water. Weve had a run of bad luck, Collier allowed. Weve had a run like every year with a hurricane. The west end is especially vulnerable. It washes over in every storm. Like I say, the west end goes under in a heavy dew.
EDIT
It is unclear how much federal aid Dauphin Island has received over time. The records are incomplete and dont go back far enough. But it is at least $100 million and some put the figure as high as $200 million. Crozier told me it could be higher yet. But even the lower estimate works out to about $170,000 for each of the islands 1,200 year-round residents. Dauphin Island, and especially the west end, is a poster child for all of our failed public policies, local, state, and federal, Crozier said. Really, it is a case study of schizophrenia. The property owners want to be left alone, except when there is a storm. Then they want the taxpayers to pay for new roads and bridges and sand and [to] help them rebuild.
EDIT
https://e360.yale.edu/features/on-the-alabama-coast-the-unluckiest-island-in-america
democratisphere
(17,235 posts)When we continually have destructive hurricanes along our Atlantic and Gulf Coasts, why do we rebuild to repeat the process over and over again. Many countries that have the same problem with the same destruction create a buffer zone between the bodies of water and any residential or commercial building structures. Instead we keep burning billions of dollars on a no win situation that will continue forever.
DinahMoeHum
(21,786 posts)n/t
Docreed2003
(16,858 posts)This is fascinating to me because we have vacationed with my wife's family on DI for years, going back to pre-Katrina and Ivan.
We have seen the devastation, the empty lots left after storms, and the surge of new construction on the island. As much as we like vacationing there, the policies of building, as well as new beach/new shoreline measures to haul in sand to rebuild beaches after storms is just mind boggling.
Also, I'm not sure when the picture you posted was taken but I can assure you that if you were to take a similar pic today most of those empty spaces would have new homes on them.
Thanks for this.
hatrack
(59,585 posts)Docreed2003
(16,858 posts)rainin
(3,011 posts)I vaguely recall a member of congress influencing flood insurance to protect his seaside investment. The details are fuzzy.
mountain grammy
(26,620 posts)Here in the US of A..