Environment & Energy
Related: About this forum"Learning To Live With It" - From COVID To Climate, It's The New Way Of Failing
We have a new term for doing nothing: learning to live with. Learning to live with Covid means abandoning testing, isolation and wearing masks in public places. Living with it, dying from it, whats the difference? The same applies to climate breakdown. Its not just that countries like the UK have failed to play their part in preventing this catastrophe. They have also failed to prepare for it.
EDIT
This government is incompetent by design. Doing nothing is what Tory donors pay for. Doing nothing is what the billionaire press demands. Doubtless well soon be told we need to take personal responsibility for ensuring our homes are not flooded and our power lines are not destroyed by storms. But this failure to act is not confined to the government: its a general failure. On Sunday, the Cambrian railway line that runs from Shrewsbury to Aberystwyth reopened after six weeks of emergency engineering. In February, the Severn, swollen by a series of storms, had knocked out the ballast, leaving the track suspended in mid-air in 33 places.
EDIT
Long sections of the rivers affecting the Cambrian line were straightened and shortened during an entirely misguided phase of river management in the mid-20th century. At that time, engineers, without any apparent scientific evidence base, according to a paper in the journal Progress in Physical Geography, believed that rivers needed to be cleared, dredged and trained. The result is that water rushes down them much faster than it would otherwise have done. Using only hard engineering to control floods building higher walls and embankments tends to divert water to the next crisis point. It requires constant reinforcement and upgrading.
But when I asked the company what works it had undertaken to slow the flow and reduce the flood peaks of the rivers that affect the line, it told me: Network Rail is not carrying out any work of the nature you listed. Our focus is on building additional resilience into local rail infrastructure. It is now shelling out another £2m on rock armour to protect the parts of the line washed out in February. As so often in the UK, the idea of making the problem smaller, rather than simply pouring more money, rocks and concrete into making the defences higher, doesnt seem to occur. Working only at the bottom of the catchments, our engineers wait for a wall of water to arrive and pray that this time their defences are high enough.
There is no learning involved in learning to live with. It tends to mean an inability to adapt to new realities, and in some cases looks like a total retreat into abstraction. In 2020, the US conservative commentator Ben Shapiro claimed that 10 feet of sea level rise wouldnt be a problem, because people could just sell their homes and move. Sell them to mermaids, presumably. A few days ago, a senior executive at the Institute of Economic Affairs suggested that instead of preventing climate breakdown, we could simply build sea walls. It is not just denial were up against. Its a belief in magic.
EDIT/END
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/apr/07/learning-live-covid-climate-breakdown-failing-government-flooding