Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 02:28 PM Sep 2023

Scientific American: New Air-Conditioning Technology Could Be the Future of Cool

New Air-Conditioning Technology Could Be the Future of Cool
Standard AC units cool buildings but contribute to global warming. New technology aims to change that

By Lauren Leffer on August 29, 2023

This past July was the hottest recorded month in human history. Heat waves smashed temperature records worldwide and even brought summer temperatures to Chile and Argentina during the Southern Hemisphere’s winter. It’s more than just a matter of sweaty discomfort. Severe heat is the deadliest of all weather events; in the U.S. alone, it kills more people each year than floods, tornadoes and hurricanes combined. As climate change worsens, access to artificially cooled spaces is rapidly becoming a health necessity—and an issue of basic human rights.



For example, some newer air conditioner designs pull moisture from the air with desiccant materials (similar to the silica gel in the packets you might find in a bag of jerky or a bottle of pills). The dried air can then be cooled to a more reasonable temperature. This process can require some additional energy because the desiccant needs to be “recharged” using heat. But some companies, including the Somerville, Mass.–based start-up Transaera, recycle the heat generated by the cooling process to recharge the desiccant. Transaera claims that the system it is developing could use 35 percent less energy than the average standard AC unit.

Even bigger efficiency gains are possible when dehumidification is paired with evaporative cooling, which takes the energy-intensive process called vapor compression out of the equation altogether. Vapor compression—the system by which standard AC works—moves a refrigerant through a cycle in which it is variably condensed and expanded, enabling it to absorb heat from inside and release that heat outside. Conversely, evaporative cooling is a simpler process. It’s the same one through which sweating cools our skin: as water goes from liquid to gas, it absorbs heat. Swamp coolers, DIY devices in which a fan blows air over ice, work the same way. And in dry climates, people have used evaporative cooling for thousands of years. In ancient Iran, for instance, people engineered yakhchāls—large, cone-shaped clay structures with solar chimneys—which harnessed air circulation and the evaporation of adjacent water to lower temperatures so much that they could make ice in winter and store it through summer.

But this strategy also increases air’s humidity, so as a cooling system, it tends to work only when the weather is hot and dry; if humidity rises beyond a certain point, it cancels out the comfort gains of reduced temperature. To solve this, research groups, including Harvard University’s cSNAP team, have designed AC devices that use a hydrophobic barrier to perform evaporative cooling while holding back humidity. As a bonus, refrigerants—which are often greenhouse gases that are many times more potent than carbon dioxide—aren’t involved at all. “We expect to provide a 75 percent more energy-efficient air conditioner,” says Jonathan Grinham, an assistant professor of architecture at Harvard and one of cSNAP’s lead designers.

18 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Scientific American: New Air-Conditioning Technology Could Be the Future of Cool (Original Post) OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 OP
Electric heat pumps too. Think. Again. Sep 2023 #1
Well, a conventional "air conditioner" is a heat pump OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 #7
I have all the new mini-splits in my home. They make it feasible to cool and heat the home LiberalArkie Sep 2023 #13
The article confuses negative feedback loops with positive feedback loops Shermann Sep 2023 #2
I've noticed a lot of positive/negative usage problems lately OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 #3
Desiccant dehumidification can save energy in large natural gas refrigeration and a/c systems Wicked Blue Sep 2023 #5
Not much here beyond a CEO blue-skying about solutions that are many years away nt Shermann Sep 2023 #11
The technology exists. It is not commercialized yet. OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 #12
We can fan ourselves with a copy of Scientific American Dios Mio Sep 2023 #4
My wife works as Maketing manager for HVAC company and I forwarded this article to her boss. Pepsidog Sep 2023 #6
I love to be cool, and I've wondered how we were going to fix this issue for a long time! BComplex Sep 2023 #8
It will be interesting to see how it scales Old Crank Sep 2023 #9
Well... OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 #10
Recharging the dessicant with waste heat seems to be permitted by the laws of physics Shermann Sep 2023 #17
I was thinking about was used in labs Old Crank Sep 2023 #18
up here in the rarified air of the rocky mountains mountain grammy Sep 2023 #14
Now don't brag... OKIsItJustMe Sep 2023 #15
I'd love to have more neighbors, but it's the altitude.. mountain grammy Sep 2023 #16

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
7. Well, a conventional "air conditioner" is a heat pump
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 04:01 PM
Sep 2023

The difference is that with the sort of “heat pump,” you’re thinking of, the process can be reversed (i.e. rather than only “pumping” heat from inside a building to outside, heat can be “pumped” from outside to inside.) — Unless you’re thinking of a “ground source” AKA “geothermal” heat pump.

These unconventional air conditioners would work by different mechanisms.

LiberalArkie

(15,719 posts)
13. I have all the new mini-splits in my home. They make it feasible to cool and heat the home
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 05:21 PM
Sep 2023

in Arkansas fir almost no electricity. I mean heating the air inside to 75 deg when it is 15 outside and only pulling 6 amps.
I have thought they if the refrigerator, water heater and air con units could all be hooked up to an outside units like the mini-split it would really save a lot of energy.

I run 3 mini-splits, a GE hybrid water heater, fridge and all my lights on a 8KW generator the the electric goes out. Everything except the oven/range...

Shermann

(7,423 posts)
2. The article confuses negative feedback loops with positive feedback loops
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 03:04 PM
Sep 2023

Dehumidifying air prior to cooling it sounds great, but I'm a bit skeptical that they've cracked the code for doing this cheaply and reliably.

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
3. I've noticed a lot of positive/negative usage problems lately
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 03:18 PM
Sep 2023

For example, I’ve been seeing companies (and others) saying they’re going beyond “net zero” to being “carbon positive!” (It sounds nice, I mean, who doesn’t want to be positive. Right‽ )

In this case, I think they author is describing a feedback loop, which produces a bad (i.e. negative) result. (It’s a positive feedback loop, but then, does that mean “positive” is bad‽ )


Ah well, languages evolve, and there’s nothing you or I can do to stop it.



_____________
Bring back the interrobang

Wicked Blue

(5,834 posts)
5. Desiccant dehumidification can save energy in large natural gas refrigeration and a/c systems
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 03:44 PM
Sep 2023

I wrote numerous case studies about this from 2001 to 2008. However I don't know whether those cost savings are possible for electric desiccant dehumidification systems. since I only wrote about the gas ones. At that time, natural gas was used to fire burners that dried out desiccant wheels as they rotated. The heat generated is used for water heating and indoor air heating.

Natural gas desiccant dehumidification systems can effectively dehumidify and cool hospital surgical rooms, which must be kept at 55 degrees F or lower for the comfort of the surgical teams. Ordinarily maintaining these rooms at this temperature results in excessive air moisture, which drips onto everything in an operating room and causes unwanted mold growth.

When I retired the industry was working on residential gas cooling desiccant systems, but I'm not sure how far this was pursued.

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
12. The technology exists. It is not commercialized yet.
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 05:16 PM
Sep 2023
cSNAP: Eco-Friendly Air Conditioning
Evaporative-cooling-based system that uses a specially coated ceramic to cool air without adding humidity





This technology is currently being de-risked at the Wyss Institute. It has been tested in real-world conditions at Harvard’s HouseZero, and showed that it effectively cooled indoor air even in extremely hot conditions. The team is combining their evaporative cooling system with additional innovations that pre-treat and dehumidify the input air, further maximizing its cooling capability and allowing it to be used in a wide variety of markets and climate zones around the world. The team plans to launch a startup to commercialize their technology, and is seeking a business development lead to join the project.

BComplex

(8,053 posts)
8. I love to be cool, and I've wondered how we were going to fix this issue for a long time!
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 04:13 PM
Sep 2023

I hope they keep working on it!

Old Crank

(3,596 posts)
9. It will be interesting to see how it scales
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 04:18 PM
Sep 2023

versus costs.
I like using the waste heat generated from cooling to recharge the desicant. Chilling air tends to drive water out of air which is why most AC units have drip lines to remove water from the machinery. (Cars also)
The coments about evaporative, swamp cooling, strike home. When I lived in the Phoenix area we had swampt cooling and gas heating. We helped the cooling by having a couple of vents from rooms go up into the attic. The attic was ventilated. Swamp cooling needs ir flow, you can't shut a building up like you do for regular AC. It definately is not as efficient as the humidity goes up.

OKIsItJustMe

(19,938 posts)
10. Well...
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 04:32 PM
Sep 2023

Conventional air conditioners and “air source heat pumps” are not as efficient when the heat goes up either (or in the case of “air source heat pumps” when the temperature goes down.)

A “ground source heat pump” (AKA “geothermal heat pump”) has the advantage of (relatively) constant temperatures below ground.

Shermann

(7,423 posts)
17. Recharging the dessicant with waste heat seems to be permitted by the laws of physics
Sun Sep 10, 2023, 07:29 AM
Sep 2023

However, this "salt solution" has to be exposed to the air (i.e., an open system). So, it is probably going to get scummy after a while. This is fine in an industrial system where routine maintenance can be expected, however this will be problematic with residential systems.

Old Crank

(3,596 posts)
18. I was thinking about was used in labs
Sun Sep 10, 2023, 11:28 AM
Sep 2023

Drierite. Anhydrous calcium sulfate. So no issue with a brine tank. Have no idea hoe cost effective it would be or the number of cycles you would get before replacement.

mountain grammy

(26,624 posts)
14. up here in the rarified air of the rocky mountains
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 05:28 PM
Sep 2023

we have no need for air conditioning.. The best summers anywhere, as long as there's no fires. Now winter is an entirely different story.

mountain grammy

(26,624 posts)
16. I'd love to have more neighbors, but it's the altitude..
Sat Sep 9, 2023, 08:53 PM
Sep 2023

The older I get the harder it is to breathe.. we'll be leaving soon before I'm strapped to an O2 machine.. That's what gets most of us eventually.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Scientific American: New ...