Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumArizona Cotton: The Nexus Of Drought, Money, Water, Law And Unintended Consequences
Pro Publica - long read, but really good.
EDIT
Getting plants to grow in the Sonoran Desert is made possible by importing billions of gallons of water each year. Cotton is one of the thirstiest crops in existence, and each acre cultivated here demands six times as much water as lettuce, 60 percent more than wheat. That precious liquid is pulled from a nearby federal reservoir, siphoned from beleaguered underground aquifers and pumped in from the Colorado River hundreds of miles away. Greg Wuertz has been farming cotton on these fields since 1981, and before him, his father and grandfather did the same. His family is part of Arizonas agricultural royalty. His father was a board member of the Central Arizona Water Conservation District for nearly two decades. Wuertz has served as president of several of the most important cotton organizations in the state.
But what was once a breathtaking accomplishment raising cotton in a desert has become something that Wuertz pursues with a twinge of doubt chipping at his conscience. Demand and prices for cotton have plummeted, and he knows no one really needs what he supplies. More importantly, he understands that cotton comes at enormous environmental expense, a price the American West may no longer be able to afford.
Wuertz could plant any number of crops that use far less water than cotton and fill grocery store shelves from Maine to Minnesota. But along with hundreds of farmers across Arizona, he has kept planting his fields with cotton instead. He says he has done it out of habit, pride, practicality, and even a self-deprecating sense that he wouldnt be good at anything else. But in truth, one reason outweighs all the others: The federal government has long offered him so many financial incentives to do it that he cant afford not to. Some years all of what you made came from the government, Wuertz said. Your bank would finance your farming operation
because they knew the support was guaranteed. They wouldnt finance wheat, or alfalfa. Cotton was always dependable, it would always work.
EDIT
Cottons domestic benefits are questionable. After a price spike in 2010, production of cotton surged while global demand and prices along with it plummeted. Today, China, the worlds largest cotton producer, has enough cotton in warehouses to stop farming for a year. And Texas, the U.S.s largest producer, harvests enough to cover more than one third of U.S. exports alone, relying largely on natural rainfall, not irrigation, to do it. Wuertzs cotton produced with Arizonas precious water is likely to get stacked in cavernous warehouses until the marketing cooperative he uses finds new customers. If Arizona stopped farming cotton tomorrow, Wuertz said, hes not sure anyone would notice. This underscores questions about whether continuing to grow these water-hogging crops at their current levels is in the public interest, and whether such an important pillar of U.S. economic policy as the Farm Bill should continue to champion them. The basic question is how are you going to manage your water supply? And we have managed it in a way that has subsidized agriculture, said John Bredehoeft the former manager of the western water program for the U.S. Geological Survey, referring not just to subsidies for crops like cotton, but also the support for crops like alfalfa that are grown as feed. If you look at the fact that half of the water use in the West is to raise cows can you say, 'Hey, weve got a water shortage in the West?
EDIT
https://projects.propublica.org/killing-the-colorado/story/arizona-cotton-drought-crisis
eppur_se_muova
(36,263 posts)Irrigation in CA is so heavily subsidized that growers have paid as little as 10% of the actual cost of water. Where's the incentive to use less ??
hatrack
(59,587 posts)That way, they'd have baseline data for setting their allotment of the Colorado vs. how much California would get.
eppur_se_muova
(36,263 posts)That cotton is dangerous stuff.