Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

ericson00

(2,707 posts)
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 07:47 PM Aug 2016

Black Lives Matter must rescind anti-Israel declaration

https://www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/columns/2016/08/12/black-lives-matter-must-rescind-anti-israel-declaration/EHDYV3gNLwrTTwfp0JA8QN/story.html

It is a real tragedy that Black Lives Matter — which has done so much good in raising awareness of police abuses — has now moved away from its central mission and has declared war against the nation state of the Jewish people. In a recently issued “platform,” more than 60 groups that form the core of the Black Lives Matter movement went out of their way to single out one foreign nation to accuse of genocide and apartheid.

...

Genocide means the deliberate extermination of a race, such as done by Nazi Germany to Jews and Sinti and Roma or by the Hutu against the Tutsi in Rwanda. It has no application to deaths caused by self-defense measures taken to protect citizens against terrorism. To falsely accuse Israel of “genocide” — the worst crime of all, and the crime whose very name was coined to describe the systematic murder of 6 million Jews — is anti-Semitic.

Until and unless Black Lives Matter removes this blood libel from its platform and renounces it, no decent person — black, white, or of any other racial or ethnic background — should have anything to do with it. We should continue to fight against police abuses by supporting other organizations or forming new ones. But we must not become complicit in the promotion of anti-Semitism just because we agree with the rest of the Black Lives Matter program.
22 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Black Lives Matter must rescind anti-Israel declaration (Original Post) ericson00 Aug 2016 OP
I know what you mean bluestateguy Aug 2016 #1
I feel the same way. lapucelle Aug 2016 #3
A white guy telling BLM what they must do ZombieHorde Aug 2016 #2
White supremacists don't classify Jews as being white...... King_David Aug 2016 #4
I know. nt ZombieHorde Aug 2016 #5
Actually, the author identifies as a member of a group lapucelle Aug 2016 #6
I never said he wasn't entitled to an opinion. ZombieHorde Aug 2016 #7
Netanyahu and his coalition has taken Israel so far right in its treatment of the Palestinians . . . brush Aug 2016 #8
Where are mediating forces seeking fairness in Israeli society? Seriously? shira Aug 2016 #10
Yet the bulldozing goes on. brush Aug 2016 #14
According to Oslo, area C of the W.Bank is under Israeli control. Their rules. shira Aug 2016 #17
So you're okay with the bulldozing of homes and groves and land grabs? brush Aug 2016 #18
Wow shira ..... Israeli Aug 2016 #19
Black Lives Matter should read this ericson00...... Israeli Aug 2016 #9
The Israeli Minister Who Bullies Migrant Children Israeli Aug 2016 #20
Written by Dershowitz... Little Tich Aug 2016 #11
The Dersh doesn't get it. aranthus Aug 2016 #12
The regressive Left only cares about things that can advance their agenda. shira Aug 2016 #13
Not so Liberal at home. aranthus Aug 2016 #15
Agreed. n/t shira Aug 2016 #16
More words on Dersh. aranthus Aug 2016 #21
Revolting. And I agree with you. The regressive Left is disgusting. n/t shira Aug 2016 #22

bluestateguy

(44,173 posts)
1. I know what you mean
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 07:56 PM
Aug 2016

I really want to support BLM, which has a lot of good policy proposals. But I cannot do so if they insist on this anti-Semitic stance.

lapucelle

(18,303 posts)
3. I feel the same way.
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 07:59 PM
Aug 2016

Although the "otherization" of Israel is well under way, it's not too late to course correct.

ZombieHorde

(29,047 posts)
2. A white guy telling BLM what they must do
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 07:57 PM
Aug 2016

and who is not allowed to support them (decent people). So funny and predictable.

lapucelle

(18,303 posts)
6. Actually, the author identifies as a member of a group
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 08:21 PM
Aug 2016

that has long been perceived as "the other", and he is entitled to have an opinion about what BLM should do as BLM is to have an opinion about what Israel should do.

brush

(53,815 posts)
8. Netanyahu and his coalition has taken Israel so far right in its treatment of the Palestinians . . .
Sat Aug 13, 2016, 09:42 PM
Aug 2016

and its treatment of them before this latest rightward lurch was not good.

That can not be denied. There is valid reason for criticism there as Palestinian villages and groves are constantly being bulldozed.

Where are the mediating forces seeking fairness in Israeli society?

 

shira

(30,109 posts)
10. Where are mediating forces seeking fairness in Israeli society? Seriously?
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 08:34 AM
Aug 2016

Last edited Sun Aug 14, 2016, 02:47 PM - Edit history (2)

Have you ever read Haaretz? Ynet?

Ever heard of PeaceNow?

Labor? Meretz? The Joint list Arab party?

 

shira

(30,109 posts)
17. According to Oslo, area C of the W.Bank is under Israeli control. Their rules.
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 04:41 PM
Aug 2016

That's International Law that the US, UK, EU, Russia, and UN agreed to. The Palestinians under Arafat agreed to those terms. Over 95% of all Palestinians live in areas A & B. So what applies in area C applies to maybe 3-4% of Palestinians in the W.Bank.

Unauthorized building in any part of the world is usually countered by bulldozing.

Israeli

(4,157 posts)
19. Wow shira .....
Tue Aug 16, 2016, 05:00 AM
Aug 2016

.....searching for an icon that can express my total shock and disbelieve ....found it ....

.........

Israeli

(4,157 posts)
9. Black Lives Matter should read this ericson00......
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 04:52 AM
Aug 2016

....for its a damn disgrace and should shame all of us ....

Lieberman orders halt of IDF volunteer work with illegal migrants

Source : http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4841203,00.html

Israeli

(4,157 posts)
20. The Israeli Minister Who Bullies Migrant Children
Tue Aug 16, 2016, 06:22 AM
Aug 2016
Avidgor Lieberman's mobilization of right-wing MKs for such a contemptible cause – cutting off modest assistance to children in need – sets a new record for the government’s dehumanization of the asylum seekers.

Haaretz Editorial Aug 15, 2016

Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman may be taking his time about liquidating Hamas’ Ismail Haniyeh and bringing about the collapse of Hamas in the Gaza Strip – just some of the things he promised to do if he ever got back into the government – but when it comes to other enemies, he’s undaunted. These enemies are the children of asylum seekers: Youngsters from infants to six­-year-olds, who are held in so-called “child warehouses” in south Tel Aviv – makeshift day care facilities in which 15 children have died over the past five years due to the atrocious conditions.

Lieberman has instructed Chief of General Staff Gadi Eisenkot to cancel the volunteer activities that some soldiers were involved in, consisting mainly of playing with these children in south Tel Aviv’s public parks. He was responding to heavy pressure exerted on various MKs and ministers by those who oppose the asylum seekers’ presence in south Tel Aviv. The soldiers’ activities, which included taking the children out of those suffocating “warehouses” for two to three hours, were described by Lieberman’s office as being “activities about which there’s a public dispute … especially when in this case it involves activities with a population that isn’t residing here lawfully.”

Aside from the fact that this population “that isn’t residing here lawfully,” as Lieberman’s office put it, includes people that cannot be deported because of the non-refoulement principle, which forbids deporting someone to a country where his life or liberty would be at risk, Lieberman’s decision reflects an incomprehensible insensitivity. Even if their parents’ status is controversial – and it’s controversial only because the state is evading a solution – taking this out on helpless children growing up in sub-standard conditions borders on evil.

The reason given by Lieberman is similar to the answer provided by his deputy, Eli Ben-Dahan, who had earlier also asked Eisenkot to stop the initiative. “It’s more appropriate that Israel Defense Forces soldiers act according to the concept of ‘the poor of your city take precedence,’ and help out Holocaust survivors, the needy and the elderly,” Lieberman said.

The defense minister’s decision, and the mobilization of right-wing MKs for such a contemptible cause – cutting off modest assistance to children in need – sets a new record for the government’s dehumanization of the asylum seekers. It’s also a new record for racism, abominable morals and cruelty.

Source : http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/1.736922

Little Tich

(6,171 posts)
11. Written by Dershowitz...
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 08:42 AM
Aug 2016

I personally believe that Dershowitz hasn't made a logically valid argument since at least 1994. I read his "The Abuse Excuse: And Other Cop-outs, Sob Stories, and Evasions of Responsibility" back in the day, which has made me believe that he's been 100% fallacious ever since.

aranthus

(3,385 posts)
12. The Dersh doesn't get it.
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 11:57 AM
Aug 2016

Or doesn't want to. Has he read BLM's platform? It's some good things in it with a whole lot of Radical Leftist crap thrown in. The anti-Israelism is just one of many bad things that the BLM platform calls for. What we are seeing is just one more instance of Leftists co-opting a cause to advance an unrelated and unnecessary radical agenda. As long as Leftist radicals are driving the bus, then anti-Israel, anti-Zionism, and antisemitism are going to be passengers. If you want to boot the passenger, you first have to boot the driver.

 

shira

(30,109 posts)
13. The regressive Left only cares about things that can advance their agenda.
Sun Aug 14, 2016, 02:50 PM
Aug 2016

Even if it means supporting fascists like Chavez, Castro, Hamas, and the Iranian Ayatollahs...

Liberal at home in Western societies, but Regressive & neo-fascist Rightwingers outside the Western world.

When Fascism comes to America, it will be under the guise of anti-Fascism!"

Attributed to Huey Long in 1935 by various writers in 1938-1943


Ain't that the truth!

aranthus

(3,385 posts)
21. More words on Dersh.
Tue Aug 16, 2016, 03:21 PM
Aug 2016

I post this because it makes an important point about Black Lives Matter. This is from Thomas Harrington in Counter Punch:

"Those of us that support Black Lives Matter are not particularly interested in anything that he—a serial bully, sycophant to the rich and famous and arch-apologist for Israel’s long and constant history of ethnic cleansing—says to us.

Indeed, many us of find the pose he adopts, the all-too-familiar one of the Zionist—which is to say a person beholden to an ideology that grants civil rights on the basis of a person’s bloodlines—telling us what we can and cannot say about this or that subject to be not only offensive, but borderline comical."

Of course I don't agree with any of this. What he writes here that isn't idiocy is outright lies. But he makes the point that Dershowitz is foolish to tell BLM that they should drop the anti-Israel agenda. Because that agenda is woven into everything that these people believe. It isn't the case that Leftists sometime say things that on their face appear to be antisemitic. It is that Leftism is inherently antisemitic. Everyone who is familiar with the canary in the coal mine analogy of Jewish existence should be very concerned about that. Because these people won't just hurt Jews.

See here for the full article: http://www.counterpunch.org/2016/08/16/alan-dershowitzs-advice-to-black-lives-matter/

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»Black Lives Matter must r...