Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
61 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Obama DOJ Asks Court to Grant Immunity to George W. Bush For Iraq War (Original Post) cactusfractal Aug 2013 OP
Theives of a Feather ... FreakinDJ Aug 2013 #1
Hmmmm, angling for immunity himself? HooptieWagon Aug 2013 #2
Absolutely. I hope this is merely pro forma... cactusfractal Aug 2013 #8
This is a fucking joke. Right? Autumn Aug 2013 #3
I fear not... cactusfractal Aug 2013 #5
I wonder how the BOG will spin this one. What a joke this man is. roguevalley Aug 2013 #38
You know how nobody would admit to voting for Nixon after Watergate? last1standing Aug 2013 #4
You got that right. Autumn Aug 2013 #6
A massive waste of potential. last1standing Aug 2013 #7
Not just Bush: JoeyT Aug 2013 #9
"Don't round up the usual suspects" cactusfractal Aug 2013 #11
By asking for immunity, they are admitting there WERE war crimes. dixiegrrrrl Aug 2013 #18
Except "THEY" didn't request it scooter rider Aug 2013 #27
Welcome to DU..... dixiegrrrrl Aug 2013 #49
Isn't that what the immunity request was? Oh, you might mean someone who is a member AnotherDreamWeaver Aug 2013 #25
I don't generally start threads... cactusfractal Aug 2013 #10
I would think it would fit in LBN. JoeyT Aug 2013 #13
Wilms cross posted it in GD with a link to your OP Autumn Aug 2013 #14
Thanks for the heads up :-) cactusfractal Aug 2013 #16
Hey welcome to DU. Autumn Aug 2013 #17
Thanks. Long time replier, first time poster. cactusfractal Aug 2013 #23
Your first OP was a big one. Autumn Aug 2013 #28
I guess I like to fire for effect... cactusfractal Aug 2013 #29
This doesn't just need attention, it needs world-wide protests!!!! calimary Aug 2013 #24
That was my immediate response. cactusfractal Aug 2013 #26
plus as high as I can count recommendations to your comment Mira Aug 2013 #41
Bringing Justice to Bush yeoman6987 Aug 2013 #51
I beg to difffer. historylovr Aug 2013 #56
Exactly! Immunity granted to the Iran-Contra thugs left them free to participate in the Iraq fiasco dougolat Aug 2013 #57
Welcome to DU, yeoman6987! calimary Aug 2013 #59
Without accountability, history is doomed to repeat itself. Baitball Blogger Aug 2013 #12
I guess they really are all in it together... n/t cactusfractal Aug 2013 #15
WTF you can't be serious gopiscrap Aug 2013 #19
W.T.F. n/t Catherina Aug 2013 #20
There are not enough swear words in any language Richard D Aug 2013 #21
Just wrote about it somewhere else in this post, but want to say to you, my friend Mira Aug 2013 #44
Thank you. Richard D Aug 2013 #58
This came down from corporate, I assume. nt silvershadow Aug 2013 #22
well put. nt navarth Aug 2013 #30
I'm not surprised at all. Democrats are STUPID.... Spitfire of ATJ Aug 2013 #31
Birds of a feather and all that. Arctic Dave Aug 2013 #32
un fucking believable. navarth Aug 2013 #33
And how is this not expected??? delrem Aug 2013 #34
un-fucking-believable 2 -- I'm at a loss for words. 99th_Monkey Aug 2013 #35
WOW Iliyah Aug 2013 #36
Was The Westfal Act DallasNE Aug 2013 #37
Eff this... dickensknitter Aug 2013 #39
... progressoid Aug 2013 #40
Oh joy.... blackspade Aug 2013 #42
That's fucked up. But it's a clear indication they *know* they committed crimes. gtar100 Aug 2013 #43
This is Teabag bacon that will never be sniffed. countmyvote4real Aug 2013 #45
I knew this would be coming. The Obama Administration has now looked forward so far that MotherPetrie Aug 2013 #46
Plus one...nt Enthusiast Aug 2013 #48
K&R idwiyo Aug 2013 #47
Time for a bump - GWB gets Immunity, Manning gets 35 yrs TBF Aug 2013 #50
I have one question spinning around in my head: "Why now?" snappyturtle Aug 2013 #52
I have no hope. I see no future. n/t Hotler Aug 2013 #53
I'm with you Hydra Aug 2013 #55
2 sets of laws Hydra Aug 2013 #54
my country is a joke Agony Aug 2013 #60
What is the current status of this? (January 2017) Equinox Moon Jan 2017 #61

roguevalley

(40,656 posts)
38. I wonder how the BOG will spin this one. What a joke this man is.
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:28 AM
Aug 2013

As a low point in my thinking about Mr. Obama, this rates right there with his comment to GHW Bush that America is a 'kinder, gentler country' because of him.

last1standing

(11,709 posts)
7. A massive waste of potential.
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:19 PM
Aug 2013

But he chose this path with all the facts before him. He decided to sell out the American people so history will likely judge him accordingly.

JoeyT

(6,785 posts)
9. Not just Bush:
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:35 PM
Aug 2013

From the article:

SAN FRANCISCO, Calif., (Aug. 20, 2013) — In court papers filed today (PDF), the United States Department of Justice requested that George W. Bush, Richard Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Colin Powell, Condoleezza Rice and Paul Wolfowitz be granted procedural immunity in a case alleging that they planned and waged the Iraq War in violation of international law.

Plaintiff Sundus Shaker Saleh, an Iraqi single mother and refugee now living in Jordan, filed a complaint in March 2013 in San Francisco federal court alleging that the planning and waging of the war constituted a “crime of aggression” against Iraq, a legal theory that was used by the Nuremberg Tribunal to convict Nazi war criminals after World War II.

"The DOJ claims that in planning and waging the Iraq War, ex-President Bush and key members of his Administration were acting within the legitimate scope of their employment and are thus immune from suit,” chief counsel Inder Comar of Comar Law said.


The entire gang of war criminals, kidnappers, torturers, and thieves. I'm sure someone will be along to defend it shortly.

dixiegrrrrl

(60,010 posts)
18. By asking for immunity, they are admitting there WERE war crimes.
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:53 PM
Aug 2013

A topic they have not admitted till now.

dixiegrrrrl

(60,010 posts)
49. Welcome to DU.....
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 10:43 AM
Aug 2013

The DOJ is clearly acting on behalf of the war criminals, or else why bother to ask for immunity for people who are not even in gov't anymore?

AnotherDreamWeaver

(2,850 posts)
25. Isn't that what the immunity request was? Oh, you might mean someone who is a member
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 12:09 AM
Aug 2013

of DemocraticUnderground?

I hope not, but we shall see...

cactusfractal

(496 posts)
10. I don't generally start threads...
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:36 PM
Aug 2013

Is this where I should've put it? It isn't mainstream, so I didn't put it in LBN. I think this needs attention, though.

JoeyT

(6,785 posts)
13. I would think it would fit in LBN.
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:43 PM
Aug 2013

It isn't local, and it's current.

It would definitely fit in GD, too. It'll get more exposure in either one, as well as screaming defenses from people that suddenly think Bush totally never broke any laws.

calimary

(81,225 posts)
24. This doesn't just need attention, it needs world-wide protests!!!!
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 12:09 AM
Aug 2013

That is OUTRAGEOUS!!!! That's perhaps the biggest thing that's disappointed me about President Obama. He hasn't done anything to bring bush/cheney to justice! This is FUCKED.

Mira

(22,380 posts)
41. plus as high as I can count recommendations to your comment
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:43 AM
Aug 2013

I WILL NEVER forgive it. I find President Obama more than intelligent, charming, personable, wonderful with babies, gives great speeches when prepared, and mostly heart felt good speeches on the cuff. He has been a President with heart and with caring.
Yet - there is this ongoing absence of a spine, the turning into a politician to forever swear me off ever trusting one ever again. He has shown me that if I were to be sworn in as President, go through "orientation" and start to govern, within a week I would not recognize myself. And I would not be trustworthy to be relied on for what I promised to do.

I will NEVER forgive the above. I will continue to believe with all my gut that the fact Bush/Cheney et al are getting away with so much evil is the worst thing that has happened to us in the modern world, maybe ever.

Not having immediate investigation, and the obviously needed follow up of incarceration and a world court makes us subject to it happening all over again and ever so much worse. And President Obama not having what it takes, even now in re-election victory, is making all of them and all of it subject to a stench I cannot tolerate.

I'm not having a good day on this subject!

 

yeoman6987

(14,449 posts)
51. Bringing Justice to Bush
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 10:59 AM
Aug 2013

I know everyone wants this, but I don't think it is a good idea for the country. First of all, it would consume Obama's entire Presidency. A lot of work would be involved in the case and DOJ, DoD, and many other agencies would only be dealing with this. Plus, what if the jury finds President Bush not guilty or the judge or whatever. What would we have gained. If you think the Republicans don't do anything now, can you imagine what they would be like if their was a trial going on? The government would grind to a halt and President Obama would be very busy with the case and nothing else.

historylovr

(1,557 posts)
56. I beg to difffer.
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 12:47 PM
Aug 2013

That is exactly what this country needs. Giving immunity to these war criminals sends a message that this is okay, that our country's founding ideals aren't worth the ink used to write them. What would we have gained if a jury found Bush not guilty? Respect, dignity, humanity. We would show the world that we are not the rogue nation we are enthusiastically becoming. Democrats need to stop wussing out of doing the right thing because they're afraid of what the nasty Republicans might say or do. We need to open this wound and clean out the rot or this country is finished.

calimary

(81,225 posts)
59. Welcome to DU, yeoman6987!
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 05:35 PM
Aug 2013

Glad you're here! I can understand your point. But there are exceptionally valid points going the other way.

First of all, some here have already posted about how failing to prosecute, or send 'em to the Hague for a war crimes tribunal (which is what SHOULD happen since these were INTERNATIONAL crimes), would send a message that this behavior was okay and that the next guy or gal in charge could just dance along down that path with impunity - and worse, knowing nobody's gonna do anything about it and blah-blah-blah. It'd be open season for any future President to be as thuggish as he or she wanted to, citing the cover of national security, and nobody'd do a thing. There would be no checks, no balances, no restraints keeping them from stepping as far out of line as they felt like doing.

It also reinforces apathy, non-vigilance, and the notion that we as citizens - the people the President SERVES (let's not forget - the President is a PUBLIC SERVANT) have no voice and no recourse. No accountability. Move along + nothing to see here + no corrective action + no penalties or consequences for bad behavior = dictatorship, a silenced public, nobody gives a damn anymore, and among other things, they stop voting.


Further, I'm old enough to remember when President Ford pardoned nixon. That left an oozing wound behind that we still haven't gotten over, as a nation. Granted, that's true mainly for history buffs and those of us old enough to remember when President Ford pardoned nixon - and for all the things he was pardoned for. Younger folks don't care that much 'cause they didn't live it, and didn't see the outrage and the skulduggery and criminality, and abuse of power at the highest levels. At least SOME of those bastards went to prison! Gerry Ford always said he remained convinced he did the correct thing because it did allow America to move on from Watergate and not obsess. But it dealt a mortal wound to the character of this nation and to our system of justice, compromised our honor, and only reinforced the idea that the really powerful can and in some cases should be allowed to get away with it. And he did finally concede that it was the prime reason why he only got two years in the White House - whatever was left of nixon's second term - and failed to win the Presidency on his own. When he was appointed Vice President after nixon's then-veep, spiro agnew, resigned in disgrace, Ford stated that he was keenly aware that he had not arrived there by the vote of the people. So when the rest of nixon's second term ran out, Ford ran for his own term, and had his ass handed to him.

Baitball Blogger

(46,703 posts)
12. Without accountability, history is doomed to repeat itself.
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:39 PM
Aug 2013

These people take these risks into account.

And I fear Obama's legacy will be diminished for this, because he's standing in the way.

gopiscrap

(23,758 posts)
19. WTF you can't be serious
Tue Aug 20, 2013, 11:58 PM
Aug 2013

one of the things that really pissed me off about Obama was that he didn't go after these war mongering pigs

Mira

(22,380 posts)
44. Just wrote about it somewhere else in this post, but want to say to you, my friend
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:47 AM
Aug 2013

that I'm so disgusted I might throw up.
REALLY

 

Spitfire of ATJ

(32,723 posts)
31. I'm not surprised at all. Democrats are STUPID....
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 12:42 AM
Aug 2013

Just look at Clinton dropping all charges against Reagan and Poppy Bush criminals in the name of civility.

And just look at the good it did for him as they payed him back when they impeached his ass.

This pattern will repeat until Democrats admit that criminality is not a "policy position".

delrem

(9,688 posts)
34. And how is this not expected???
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:14 AM
Aug 2013

The US knows what it's into now.
At any rate those who have the capacity know.

I hear that the USA, that bastion of democracy, is wondering what Rep candidate will be put forward in opposition to Hillary Clinton.

It's to laugh, or cry...

 

99th_Monkey

(19,326 posts)
35. un-fucking-believable 2 -- I'm at a loss for words.
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:15 AM
Aug 2013

Every time I think I could not be more disappointed with Obama, he ups the anti,
and pulls a stunt like this and proves me wrong.

Apparently Obama has been accepted into "The Club" (aka the Bush Crime Syndicate)
that George Carlin used to talk about.

How nice for his family.

DallasNE

(7,402 posts)
37. Was The Westfal Act
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:22 AM
Aug 2013

Written to protect Cap Weinberger in Iran-Contra?

I know it was successfully used to protect Yoo for writing the legal opinion that torture was legal by simply renaming it as enhanced interrogation techniques. It is the law that prevents people from being held accountable for their actions that they should have known were illegal.

"acting within the legitimate scope of their employment" That sounds like if the President does it, it is legal but Richard Nixon found out that that was not the case back during Watergate. The Westfal Act may have stood that on its head.

What is unclear to me is how a law passed by Congress can trump International Law.

dickensknitter

(24 posts)
39. Eff this...
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:30 AM
Aug 2013

Yep, I had really hoped when initially voting for him, that Obama, vaunted as a prof of constitutional law, would do something to reestablish justice in the most
Grotesque matter of our most recent wars.
I was disappointed that he did nothing; I am spitting with disgust at this turn.
Sometimes I fantasize, from my place of feeling otherwise powerless, about regularly mailing them old stinky worn out shoes at all of their various addresses.
W. keeps winning the trifecta.

gtar100

(4,192 posts)
43. That's fucked up. But it's a clear indication they *know* they committed crimes.
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 01:46 AM
Aug 2013

Immunity from prosecution... none of them deserve it. They are not giving anything in exchange for it. They are just a bunch of cowards unwilling to take responsibility for themselves. Boot straps, my ass!

That Obama would sign off on such a thing is a clear indication where his loyalties lie. Do you think he could piss on his Nobel Peace Prize any more than he already has? It would be a shockingly pleasant surprise if he turned around and said hell no, but that would be a little out of character for him when it comes to his dealings with the Bush criminals.

 

countmyvote4real

(4,023 posts)
45. This is Teabag bacon that will never be sniffed.
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 02:03 AM
Aug 2013

That caucus would rather repeatedly deny millions of citizens affordable health insurance rather than prosecute war crimes at the highest levels. And the irony is that Obama could be impeached for this attempted cover-up while the Busch conspirators still remain free. Oh look, a new puppy. A pox on both their houses.

 

MotherPetrie

(3,145 posts)
46. I knew this would be coming. The Obama Administration has now looked forward so far that
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 02:19 AM
Aug 2013

It circled around and bit its own self in the ass. A permanent infected stinking wound.

snappyturtle

(14,656 posts)
52. I have one question spinning around in my head: "Why now?"
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 11:08 AM
Aug 2013

Why didn't this request happen when we first learned that
everything of this nature was off the table...2009? Why
now?

I have my suspicions. Can't help but think this isn't
another desperate effort on the part of gov't in reaction to
it's fear of the people awakening. imho

Hydra

(14,459 posts)
54. 2 sets of laws
Wed Aug 21, 2013, 12:42 PM
Aug 2013

1 for the little people, and one for them.

Eh, rule of law was overrated. We needed to go back to rule of decree and aristocracy.




<--- since it's needed these days

Equinox Moon

(6,344 posts)
61. What is the current status of this? (January 2017)
Sat Jan 28, 2017, 01:24 PM
Jan 2017

I did an internet search and did not find anything current on it.

Thanks.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»National Security & Defense»Obama DOJ Asks Court to G...